Scan barcode
curlypip's review
4.0
It took me a while to get into, but by the second quarter, I was hooked. I found myself thinking about it even when I wasn’t reading the story, and I approached the end with anticipation but also dread - I wanted to know what happened but didn’t want it to be over.
I’m not a fan of the ending, but, otherwise I enjoyed it
I’m not a fan of the ending, but, otherwise I enjoyed it
pewterwolf's review
2.0
Review Taken From The Pewter Wolf
Based very loosely on the lives of danish artists, Lili Elbe and Gerda Wegener. It looks at a marriage and the story of Lili, pioneer in transgender history.
Now, I am going to admit that I struggled while writing this write-up. Its hard to put into words my feelings over this as, while I believe the story is interesting and important, I have equal feeling towards it that it annoyed me and the story missed the point.
I have read other reviews and I know I am one of the few int he minority, but I am going to be honest about my thoughts and feelings about this.
There were elements of the writing that reminded me of The Hours by Michael Cunningham. I can't put my finger on why I kept drawing comparisons between the two, but my mind kept going there. And there were moments where words and lines just flowed.
However, I struggled with this at times too. There were times, I found the writing and the way the narrator read the story hard work and, on two or three occasions, I considered quitting. It felt like hard work to like the characters when the story was doing no favours for them.
But my biggest issue, the thing I had the most problems over, was how the issue of transgender was handled. I completely understand why the author wrote Lili and Einar as separate characters - but I fear some readers will struggle with this. But my biggest things was how this was handled. It was written in a way that, I fear, would make the reader feel that, instead of reading a book about a person who is transgender, they are reading a character who is suffering from a mental health issue, such a split personality disorder.
And I say this because there was one or two times, I felt like I wasn't reading someone who was transgender and I was going "Nononono!" over how this was handled. I wasn't happy over it!
I do want to watch the movie when it comes out on DVD so my opinion might change. But I wasn't a fan of this story, and I believe the movie might tell this story better.
Based very loosely on the lives of danish artists, Lili Elbe and Gerda Wegener. It looks at a marriage and the story of Lili, pioneer in transgender history.
Now, I am going to admit that I struggled while writing this write-up. Its hard to put into words my feelings over this as, while I believe the story is interesting and important, I have equal feeling towards it that it annoyed me and the story missed the point.
I have read other reviews and I know I am one of the few int he minority, but I am going to be honest about my thoughts and feelings about this.
There were elements of the writing that reminded me of The Hours by Michael Cunningham. I can't put my finger on why I kept drawing comparisons between the two, but my mind kept going there. And there were moments where words and lines just flowed.
However, I struggled with this at times too. There were times, I found the writing and the way the narrator read the story hard work and, on two or three occasions, I considered quitting. It felt like hard work to like the characters when the story was doing no favours for them.
But my biggest issue, the thing I had the most problems over, was how the issue of transgender was handled. I completely understand why the author wrote Lili and Einar as separate characters - but I fear some readers will struggle with this. But my biggest things was how this was handled. It was written in a way that, I fear, would make the reader feel that, instead of reading a book about a person who is transgender, they are reading a character who is suffering from a mental health issue, such a split personality disorder.
And I say this because there was one or two times, I felt like I wasn't reading someone who was transgender and I was going "Nononono!" over how this was handled. I wasn't happy over it!
I do want to watch the movie when it comes out on DVD so my opinion might change. But I wasn't a fan of this story, and I believe the movie might tell this story better.
dcliz's review against another edition
2.0
I think the author could have done so much more with these characters. As written, I didn't find it a compelling story at all, although it did make me very curious about what the real story was! I was very disappointed with the invented elements, when the true-life people had such interesting stories that could have been explored.
lovely_smiles's review
This was a very interesting book. I enjoyed the journey of the transformation from Einar to Lili. Although by the end I was sad that it almost felt like Greta was left again trying to keep her life together.
sprockette's review against another edition
emotional
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
krobart's review against another edition
4.0
See my review here:
http://whatmeread.wordpress.com/2016/09/09/day-967-the-danish-girl/
http://whatmeread.wordpress.com/2016/09/09/day-967-the-danish-girl/
readmetwotimes's review against another edition
2.0
Mi dispiace un po' dare solo due stelline, perché in realtà questo libro mi è piaciuto. Ma secondo me manca di anima, è troppo freddo, sia come scrittura che come scelta della storia (solo vagamente basata sulla realtà). Inoltre, lo scopo del libro secondo l'autore era dare un'idea della psicologia del rapporto tra Greta (Gerda) e Lili (prima Einar), cercare di comprenderne le dinamiche. Ecco, secondo me, non c'è riuscito. Ci sono momenti molto toccanti tra loro, per carità, ma non credo abbia colto la loro vera essenza, il primum movens. Non mi è proprio parso.
davisek223's review
2.0
Couldn't finish it. The subject matter is fascinating but it's told in such a dry, boring way. The characters are flat and I found I didn't much care what happened to them. How is it possible to take such interesting people and events and make them dull as dishwater?