You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

Reviews tagging 'Gun violence'

Midnight In The Garden of Good and Evil by John Berendt

40 reviews

informative mysterious medium-paced

The voyeur in me loved that most of the content in this book is gossip. I absolutely ate that up and it kept me riveted! However, this book is so problematic on multiple levels.

First things first is the rampant homophobia and transphobia. Early on in the narrative, the author befriends Chablis, a trans woman, but is kind of afraid of her because he finds her attractive. He also never takes anything Chablis says or does seriously, seemingly maintaining friendship with her just to scandalize everyone he knows and have someone "unusual" to write about. As for the homophobia - it is continuous throughout the book, waxing and waning in its severity, with hate crimes being casually discussed and the f-slur being used repeatedly by the characters.

The second problem is the treatment of all Black people featured in this book. Berendt describes Black people that he meets as curiosities, taking a creepy anthropological approach. It's incredibly dehumanizing. Outside of Berendt himself, the people that he gets to know best over the course of his time in Savannah are very bigoted. For instance, the heavily-featured character Joe Odom loves to drop the n-word. Odom's racism is the most overt but there is quite a lot more covert racism throughout. Often, the high society of Savannah seems to be surprised that Black people who don't serve them even exist!

The third problem with this book is its entire elitist approach. Berendt is cashing in on people's very real lives in a way that ultimately paints him as above it all. Everyone is two-dimensional. Clearly, Berendt enjoys merely collecting folks in his life for their writability. As the story progresses, it begins to feel more and more like a mocking story told over drinks at a bougie New York party. (Berendt is from NY). I can see him saying "You wouldn't believe all these wealthy Southerners and their odd habits. Or the crazy gay people I met! Isn't the South so quirky and bizarre? Isn't bigoted behavior & conversation just so quirky and fun?"

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
informative mysterious medium-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
adventurous funny mysterious fast-paced

A collection of stories from one period of time in Savannah, Georgia. Told from first person POV. Fun characters and interesting discussions around crime, money, and public opinion.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
adventurous funny informative mysterious tense medium-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
informative mysterious slow-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
mysterious tense slow-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
adventurous relaxing slow-paced

Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil certainly gets points for one of the coolest titles. I almost can’t believe this book is non-fiction. These characters are larger than life. They almost cross the line into caricature at times. It makes me wonder if any truths were exaggerated or embellished for dramatic effect. This brings into question how much trust we place in an author, especially a non-fiction author. Did Berendt’s outsider status help him see Savannah, GA and its inhabitants more clearly? Though I enjoyed this overall, I’m annoyed at the elements of racism, classism, and transphobia. Some of it is just language that’s aged out (it feels dehumanizing to constantly call the Black community just “Blacks”), but other points are just Berendt being a privileged white dude uncomfortable imagining life outside the status quo. When someone explains those runners are an interracial couple that pretends not to know each other, he blindly accepts this. No questions at all. When a report comes out about Savannah’s high murder rate, he quickly blames it on the Black population with little discussion of how economic and social disadvantages are at play. The most cringeworthy parts were his treatment of Lady Chablis, especially at the end during the cotillion. I’m glad that this book helped Lady Chablis gain attention, because she sounds absolutely incredible, but ugh the transphobic language was tough to read.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark funny mysterious medium-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
informative mysterious fast-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark funny informative mysterious medium-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings