3.62 AVERAGE

informative inspiring reflective slow-paced
challenging informative slow-paced

cevans2000's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH: 42%

Repetitive references in every chapter
informative medium-paced
dark funny reflective medium-paced

Incredibly interesting narrative and really expanded my view on gay history. Definitely would NOT listen to the audiobook aloud or around children. Will read again soon to make sure I got all of the details. 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
informative reflective medium-paced
challenging funny informative medium-paced
challenging informative fast-paced

Following gays throughout history who have traditionally been erased from queer narratives due to their ‘badness’, such as Ronnie Kray and Ernst Röhm, Bad Gays offers a compelling argument against the dilution of queerness into a line of moral superiority - not every queer person is a good person, but they’re still part of queer history. With each chapter focusing on a different 'bad gay', this is accessible and digestible while also offering a compelling argument against only acknowledging 'morally correct' gays.

It looks at the contributions of ‘bad gays’ to queer culture and wider society, delving into the politics and social ties of these gays and helping the reader to understand shifting attitudes to queerness, and particularly queerness as understood by elites who were generally white. It draws attention to the respectability of queerness and queer identities, along with the ties to masculinity and the presentation of sexuality in order for queerness to be presentable, or at least, tolerated.

Its major downfall is that it almost exclusively focuses on wealthy western gay men (Margaret Mead and Yukio Mishima are the only exceptions to that), and I found the repeated focus on the idea that elites were accepting of homosexuality if it was hidden and/or presentable to be overly emphasised - I would have enjoyed a deeper analysis of the exploitation of queer people in spite of their queerness due to their positions/resources.

Overall, this is a really interesting challenge to moral queerness and claims these bad gays, for better or for worse, as part of the queer community.
challenging funny informative reflective medium-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
informative medium-paced