Reviews

La Sorcière captive by Melissa Caruso

benelux's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous

3.25

aly_ssa_k's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Amazing!! One of the best fantasy books I've found since Harry Potter and the Tamora Pierce series. Incredibly captivating plot, and even better were the characters. The author effortlessly built a world with women truly in power and where all sexualities are already accepted and unquestioned. I cannot wait to read the next book. I only put it down once, and regretted to do so, finishing it in two sittings. I cannot wait to read the next book!

little_red_dragon's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

“My throat tightened. 'I'm not good at these games. Not like you are, Mamma.'

'Then don't play. Figure out what you are good at, and make that the game.”


The Tethered Mage hits the perfect balance of fantasy, magic, politics, and just a touch of romance. The magic system was fascinating, with hints of a bigger world that I can't wait to explore. Overall, there was a solid, fast-paced plot, though the middle gets a bit more political, so it may not be for everyone.

However, I found the characters to be relatable and complex. Zaira is fiery and loyal, while Amalia is independent and smart. They play off each other so well and it's wonderful to see their relationship grow and develop.

It reads a bit like YA, but that's certainly not a bad thing--it makes it more approachable. And that ending was great! I would highly recommend this one.

york0215's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous hopeful mysterious tense medium-paced

3.0

storytimed's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I'm so here for POLITICS! It's a sign of how inured I've become to trashy YA fantasy novels that I was surprised and gratified to find that The Tethered Mage had a plot that 1) made sense 2) mattered and 3) ended in a satisfying way.

Surprisingly, the characters were the weak part this time around. The love interest is Standard YA Generic Hot Sword Guy, and for a novel about two characters magically bound to be partners for the rest of their lives, Zaira and Amalia don't get to do very much bonding.

Okay, I'll admit it: I'm disappointed this wasn't gayer. I wanted some of that tentative earning of trust on both sides. Some buddy cop aggressive banter. That moment where they end up having a good time together or making a good team despite not expecting to, despite actively fighting their True Partnership Connection. I'm happy Zaira's canonically bi, but the premise of the novel begs for at the very least a deep platonic connection between the two linked characters, and we really don't get it.

Part of this is because this book is so plot-driven, and Zaira's for the most part secondary to the actual plot. Sure, her power is relevant, but she has no incentive to be a major political player and therefore is treated like an afterthought. The actual politically relevant characters (Amalia, Ruven, Amalia's uncle, Amalia's MOM) are much better written.

Amalia herself is pretty great: she's an academic who hates having to live up to her mother's political expectations, and her shyness and growing skills are realistically portrayed. I liked that she was chronically ill without a big melodramatic deal being made of it, but that her illness informed what she could do narratively.

And, well, Amalia's mom. What's that, Alison, your favorite character in the book is the morally ambiguous, powerful older woman who lives according to her own realpolitik code? Yeah, okay, I have a type, but it's SUCH a good type. She's deployed to perfection too, as a forbidding presence who looms over the actual novel but never a deus ex machina.

meganmreads's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

The Tethered Mage has been sitting on my shelf for quite some time, but once I realized I could get the sequels from my library, I decided it was time to finally read it!

I really enjoyed the story! It was smart, fun, and magical. The magic system was interesting and I enjoyed the world, politics, and characters. This wasn’t a YA fantasy, but it wasn’t a super dense adult fantasy, either. It would be a good jump for people who enjoy YA fantasy but might be sick of following the lives of teenagers since the characters in this trilogy are a bit older.

My only issue was that I thought the potential romance between Amalia and Marcello was way too wholesome for me. I’m not a Marcello fan, but I enjoyed the conflict and plot enough to be genuinely interested in the fate of the characters and will definitely continue the series.

strangethedreamer's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

2.5 stars. The characters are generally likeable and well drawn, although the romance felt unnecessary. Giving this a low score because of the way slavery is treated and morally elided by the author makes me deeply uncomfortable. I’m unlikely to continue with this series.

cloudedhalo's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Really enjoyed this, and the narrator on the audiobook was excellent. The magic system and how the world controls those with magic was fab and gave for interesting dynamics. I liked both the main female characters, and the political intrege they had to navigate and I will deffo be continuing with the series but am going to try and continue with the audiobook but it doesn't seem to be on my app yet.

esknight89's review against another edition

Go to review page

11% in and I can already see where things are headed. I really dislike fantasy from the perspective of an elite, so finding out that the entire book is from the POV of a naive but pampered daughter of a countess didn't give me a good feeling. Then I see some CW-inspired romantic chum tossed into the mix, so my YA alarm started blaring. 

Most of the way each named character acted seemed unrealistic and if someone did feel realistic, it felt forced, petulant, & unreasonable. 

I could have been hook a number of different ways by the introduced plot, but nothing was barbed or sharp enough to grab me. 

shellycampbellauthor's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Excellent pacing and lovable characters

The Tethered Mage is one of those rare gems that sucks you right in and doesn’t let go. Gorgeous, streamlined prose, pace that tugs the reader along to the very end, and relatable, well-fleshed out characters. The plot had just enough twists and complexity to keep me intrigued. A sure recipe for an excellent read. Loved it.