Scan barcode
jessmay27's review
emotional
hopeful
informative
inspiring
reflective
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
angeladobre's review against another edition
4.0
3,5
https://booknation.ro/recenzie-luminile-pierdute-din-st-kilda-speranta-regasirii-de-elisabeth-gifford/
https://booknation.ro/recenzie-luminile-pierdute-din-st-kilda-speranta-regasirii-de-elisabeth-gifford/
hera90's review
emotional
informative
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
5.0
daniellewalsh's review against another edition
4.0
Set on the isolated Scottish island of St Kilda, the simple life and beautiful surroundings of nature are so lyrically written.
I was drawn to the book as it's a historical fiction based on an isolated island, but with the stunning writing it added so much more than that. The everyday living and descriptions of the wind, birds, and rocks gave a really magical and mesmerising feel. With this in mind, it was a bit of a slow-burner for me, not one that I devoured all at once - but I think that pace suited the book and the style of the writing.
With alternative chapters from Chrissie and Fred from 1927 to 1940s the love story spans several years and countries. Captured behind enemy lines, Fred escapes from the Nazis and attempts to get back to Chrissie after all these years. There is the classic miscommunication and a bit of frustration, which is a bit of an 'eye-roll', but it was necessary to give the book that rounded and finished feeling.
I think it's a good pick for historical fiction/romance lovers, for a slow burner, or lovers of books about isolated/island living. Also, I am a huge fan of a book with a map, so before I even started reading, I was a big fan of the endpapers.
I was drawn to the book as it's a historical fiction based on an isolated island, but with the stunning writing it added so much more than that. The everyday living and descriptions of the wind, birds, and rocks gave a really magical and mesmerising feel. With this in mind, it was a bit of a slow-burner for me, not one that I devoured all at once - but I think that pace suited the book and the style of the writing.
With alternative chapters from Chrissie and Fred from 1927 to 1940s the love story spans several years and countries. Captured behind enemy lines, Fred escapes from the Nazis and attempts to get back to Chrissie after all these years. There is the classic miscommunication and a bit of frustration, which is a bit of an 'eye-roll', but it was necessary to give the book that rounded and finished feeling.
I think it's a good pick for historical fiction/romance lovers, for a slow burner, or lovers of books about isolated/island living. Also, I am a huge fan of a book with a map, so before I even started reading, I was a big fan of the endpapers.
portybelle's review against another edition
4.0
The Lost Lights of St Kilda is the first book I have read by this author and having read it, I would definitely be keen to read more of her work. I was attracted to the book because it is set on St Kilda, a place I find fascinating. And this was indeed a fascinating read, with that atmospheric cover reflecting the story inside.
The book focuses on Cambridge student Fred Lawson who arrives in St Kilda to work for the summer. If you don't already know, St Kilda is in fact a very remote group of islands off the west coast of Scotland. The people who lived there, lived a very different way of life from most, often cut off from the mainland in winter and where survival could be a real struggle. The community which Fred joins will turn out to be the last to live there as eventually, the struggle became too difficult and the islanders were evacuated.
Fred falls in love with island girl Chrissie and she with him. But with very different outlooks on life, it seems that it must be impossible for them to be together. Thirteen years later, Chrissie now lives on the mainland and hasn't heard from Fred since he left at the end of that summer. Fred has been captured during the Second World War but has escaped and while making his way back to Britain, thinks of the girl he once loved, and still does. His determination to see her again is what keeps him going.
This was a beautifully written account of a way of life that was unique and showed the real challenges of living in this beautiful but wild place. The islanders' love for their home and their pride in surviving there was clear. Through Chrissie eyes we see the beauty of nature but also its harshness. We see how fiercely independent the islanders were and how difficult it was for them to finally admit that living on the island was no longer sustainable. I thought it was particularly poignant to think of what they were leaving: not just their homes, their way of life and all they held dear, but also the graves of their loved ones. It must have been heart-breaking.
The Lost Lights of St Kilda weaves together storylines from two different times, moving smoothly from one character's viewpoint to another and from one time to another. It is a detailed, evocative novel telling of the love not just between the characters but also a deep love of the land.
The book focuses on Cambridge student Fred Lawson who arrives in St Kilda to work for the summer. If you don't already know, St Kilda is in fact a very remote group of islands off the west coast of Scotland. The people who lived there, lived a very different way of life from most, often cut off from the mainland in winter and where survival could be a real struggle. The community which Fred joins will turn out to be the last to live there as eventually, the struggle became too difficult and the islanders were evacuated.
Fred falls in love with island girl Chrissie and she with him. But with very different outlooks on life, it seems that it must be impossible for them to be together. Thirteen years later, Chrissie now lives on the mainland and hasn't heard from Fred since he left at the end of that summer. Fred has been captured during the Second World War but has escaped and while making his way back to Britain, thinks of the girl he once loved, and still does. His determination to see her again is what keeps him going.
This was a beautifully written account of a way of life that was unique and showed the real challenges of living in this beautiful but wild place. The islanders' love for their home and their pride in surviving there was clear. Through Chrissie eyes we see the beauty of nature but also its harshness. We see how fiercely independent the islanders were and how difficult it was for them to finally admit that living on the island was no longer sustainable. I thought it was particularly poignant to think of what they were leaving: not just their homes, their way of life and all they held dear, but also the graves of their loved ones. It must have been heart-breaking.
The Lost Lights of St Kilda weaves together storylines from two different times, moving smoothly from one character's viewpoint to another and from one time to another. It is a detailed, evocative novel telling of the love not just between the characters but also a deep love of the land.
jemmacm's review
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
2.5
heidirgorecki's review
3.0
While the book was a bit slow, it was such a beautiful story of community, and of love and forgiveness. I enjoyed learning about the community of St Kilda - the family and culture they had. Amazing how resilient their people were and how hardworking, and yet incredibly isolated. I really loved how Fred kept talking to Chrissie in his portion of the narrative. It made it feel more personal and heartfelt.