Scan barcode
anniereads221's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
5.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Kidnapping, Body horror, Ableism, Grief, Violence, Torture, Death, Blood, Racism, and Murder
keysmashhh's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.75
Plot: 3/5
Character: 4.75/5
Relationships: 4.5/5
World-Building: 4/5
Genre: 4.5/5
Plot: I always find Cassandra Clare's books to be a bit lacking in the plot but honestly she always makes up for it with her characters and relationships. This plot I found to be a bit slow (kind of like exposition for the other books to follow but I really didn't mind. The pace could be considered slow but I love that she took the time to flesh out the characters and the subtleties of their relationships and didn't lose the plot completely. The betrayal! now that was a good plotline - which honestly I didn't see coming the first OR THE SECOND time I read this book which is amazing! I was genuinely moved by the deaths as well - Will saying goodbye to Thomas made a few tears in my eyes
Character: CASSANDRA CLARE YOU ARE AMAZING AT WRITING CHARACTERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! JEM CARSTAIRS IS THE BEST FICTIONAL MAN - THERE I SAID IT! WILL IS SO COMPLICATED AND ANGSTY BUT IS STILL SO AMAZING AND TESSA - SHE IS THE PERFECT BALANCE OF QUIRKY WITHOUT GETTING ON MY NERVES. All of the side characters work as well - I don't really feel that emotionally attached but considering she has somehow created 3 main characters I love - I will let that go. I also loved that we got to see more of Camille and MAGNUS in this book - it was nice to flesh out their characters in other centuries
Relationships: ugh this book makes me so torn when it comes to romance - on the one hand, Will and Jem are perfect for each other - they are such a power couple and so caring and perfect and I love them. On the other hand, the intellectual, flirty snarkiness of Will and Tessa fuels my main character syndrome but finally Jem and Tessa are perfect, they are the epitome of balance in a couple - so I give up and think they should all just kiss each other and be done with it - I'm not choosing
World-Building: The world of shadowhunters is so intricate and amazing whilst also seemingly having no useless exposition - it manages the balance of amazing descriptions of Victorian London (which are so sensory) and forwarding the plot - it really is amazing. The tiny details CC added in this such as the colours of mourning and the differences in vocab between England and America make this book so authentic
Genre: The teen fantasy romance adventure chaotic genre is so dense but these always rise to the top - not just for their characters but they rise even higher than the original Mortal Instruments series - there is something so amazing and so heart-breakingly well written in these books are that will always make me love them
1st Read: March 2021
Finally, I'm back reading Cassandra Clare books again! I read this in a day and loved it. It is so much better than the 1st books in my opinion. Maybe that's to do with me being British and loving books set in London, maybe I am just a sucker for Victorian London?Jem is my favourite by far, I would protect him with all my heart. Im interested in how Jems addiction is going to effect the rest of the plot and hopefully I will get some good content out of that in the future I loved that we got to see more Magnus content because boy oh boy does my little heart sing when he talks. I loved the bit where he mentioned his type and then basically described Alec. Also the bit right at the end with Will and him is intriguing. Tessa is so much more likeable than Clary, she is 10x more intresting and I don't roll my eyes every time she opens her mouth. Romance: Jem x Will is the supreme couple. However, I don't totally hate Will and Tessa, they are the predictable couple but they don't make me want to throw up like Clary and Jace.
Character: 4.75/5
Relationships: 4.5/5
World-Building: 4/5
Genre: 4.5/5
Plot: I always find Cassandra Clare's books to be a bit lacking in the plot but honestly she always makes up for it with her characters and relationships. This plot I found to be a bit slow (kind of like exposition for the other books to follow but I really didn't mind. The pace could be considered slow but I love that she took the time to flesh out the characters and the subtleties of their relationships and didn't lose the plot completely. The betrayal! now that was a good plotline - which honestly I didn't see coming the first OR THE SECOND time I read this book which is amazing! I was genuinely moved by the deaths as well - Will saying goodbye to Thomas made a few tears in my eyes
Character: CASSANDRA CLARE YOU ARE AMAZING AT WRITING CHARACTERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! JEM CARSTAIRS IS THE BEST FICTIONAL MAN - THERE I SAID IT! WILL IS SO COMPLICATED AND ANGSTY BUT IS STILL SO AMAZING AND TESSA - SHE IS THE PERFECT BALANCE OF QUIRKY WITHOUT GETTING ON MY NERVES. All of the side characters work as well - I don't really feel that emotionally attached but considering she has somehow created 3 main characters I love - I will let that go. I also loved that we got to see more of Camille and MAGNUS in this book - it was nice to flesh out their characters in other centuries
Relationships: ugh this book makes me so torn when it comes to romance - on the one hand, Will and Jem are perfect for each other - they are such a power couple and so caring and perfect and I love them. On the other hand, the intellectual, flirty snarkiness of Will and Tessa fuels my main character syndrome but finally Jem and Tessa are perfect, they are the epitome of balance in a couple - so I give up and think they should all just kiss each other and be done with it - I'm not choosing
World-Building: The world of shadowhunters is so intricate and amazing whilst also seemingly having no useless exposition - it manages the balance of amazing descriptions of Victorian London (which are so sensory) and forwarding the plot - it really is amazing. The tiny details CC added in this such as the colours of mourning and the differences in vocab between England and America make this book so authentic
Genre: The teen fantasy romance adventure chaotic genre is so dense but these always rise to the top - not just for their characters but they rise even higher than the original Mortal Instruments series - there is something so amazing and so heart-breakingly well written in these books are that will always make me love them
1st Read: March 2021
Content Warnings
Graphic: Addiction and Terminal illness
Moderate: Death, Murder, and Grief
Minor: Drug use, Infertility, and Death of parent
helpme71's review
adventurous
dark
emotional
funny
hopeful
mysterious
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death of parent, Violence, Death, Grief, Kidnapping, Blood, Chronic illness, Murder, and Toxic relationship
Moderate: Abandonment and Addiction
Minor: Animal cruelty, Cursing, and Infertility
dannythestreet's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Grief, Injury/Injury detail, Kidnapping, Murder, and Physical abuse
Moderate: Abandonment, Addiction, Blood, Death of parent, and Torture
Minor: Alcohol
ukalaylee's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Addiction, Blood, Death, Death of parent, Drug use, Grief, Kidnapping, Violence, and Child death
Moderate: Alcohol, Murder, and Infertility
brookey8888's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
I just love the book/series so much. I love all of the characters especially Henry he just makes me laugh. I really love Tessa. I also just love the plot with the clockwork and all the twists. I also do love this love triangle like ugh it’s so good.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Addiction, Blood, Death, Drug use, Grief, Murder, and Violence
cait's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
hopeful
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
I find it rather difficult to transition from The Mortal Instruments to The Infernal Devices and back again. It’s not just that it’s the same world and such a similar plot – girl’s life is turned upside down and she discovers that she’s somehow part of the Shadowhunter world when she never even knew demons and their like existed. It’s certainly not the tone of the stories – TID is very, very dark when compared to TMI and has much more imaginatively detailed world-building than its present day American counterpart, assumedly because we can’t exactly Google Earth 1800’s London to see what the town looks like – or even, really, the characters’ interactions and behaviors.
I think a part of it is the name Herondale. It is not strictly Jace’s anymore; it’s now shared with Will – rightfully Wills’, if you will. (Teehee.) I feel like Clare did try to differentiate as much as possible between Will and Jace: Jace is blonde and beautiful and made of light and kindness towards the girl he cares about; Will is black-haired and cruel and dark and filled with an inexplicable rage and destructiveness. But I keep imagining Will exactly as I imagine Jace, right down to the blond hair and gentle golden eyes.
Part of me wonders if that’s just because of their shared heritage, as Jace is clearly Will’s descendant, but a bigger part thinks it might be their personalities: Both are snarky, aggressive, self-destructive, unwilling/unable to keep their mouths shut when they should, and fiercely loyal to the people they care about – though Will’s affection for Jem is far more evident that Jace’s for Alec. But I think a huge part of it is the mysterious darkness of their pasts that will be uncovered over the course of their respective series: Jace’s mysterious parentage, horrific upbringing, and concealed pain vs. Will’s mysterious flight from his parents to the Institute, horrifying secret, and wickedly cruel disguise for his hopelessness.
Both are willing to throw themselves in harm’s way with nary more than a smart comment, find amusement in things that they shouldn’t, and hope for the worst: But then comes the main female protagonist, a girl who knows nothing of the world to which she belongs as their lives become entangled, and they are instantly thrown off kilter as they fall almost immediately for a girl with messy hair and a love for all things nerdy … even though that word probably wasn’t invented yet in Will’s situation.
Maybe I should have viewed these books as character studies, I don’t know, but I do know it’s time to get to the point…
I enjoyed this book. It took me a while to figure out how to disentangle one series from the other – especially since I knew Magnus would eventually make an appearance – but, once I did, I got a full set of feelings and anticipations for this book. Even though I’ve read it, I couldn’t remember almost anything that occurred and was pleasantly surprised by some of the twists and turns this novel took.
I love the wider range of characters in this novel: It was nice to have some Mundanes join the mix and see how the Shadowhunter-Downworlder relationship was actually somewhat healthier earlier in Shadowhunter history than in TMI. I loved the relationships and the myriad personalities and the tribulations these characters faced.
The premise of this novel is a fascinating one: If no force of heaven or hell can overcome that which God hath wrought, what if human invention can? It most certainly seems like it will, but I can only assume that it doesn’t since Shadowhunters still exist in TMI.
We follow Tessa as she arrives in London from America to live with her brother following the death of the aunt who had raised her since her parents died in her toddler-hood. Greeted instead by her brother’s denizens, Tessa finds herself trapped in a world of horror as she is imprisoned by a pair of evil witches and forced to learn how to shapeshift into murdered person after murdered person, her brother’s life hanging in the balance, all in preparation for her impending marriage to a mysterious creature known only as the Magister. Hope comes in the form of Will, a Shadowhunter boy, who rescues her the night she is due to be married and, with the help of the London Enclave, they begin an investigation into the identity of the Magister, the rash of robotic creatures appearing throughout the city, the mysterious Pandemonium Club, and the location of her brother.
I really loved Tessa as a character. I loved all the different elements and obstacles Clare threw at her to drag her completely out of her comfort zone: American in London, family dead, kidnapped by witches who essentially torture her into doing magic, rescued by Shadowhunters who terrify her, Downworlder who didn’t even know the Downworld existed, unidentifiable Downworlder on top of that, separated from her last remaining family member, caught up in a boy with more issues than anyone can count, part of some sort of mysterious plot, robots attacking the world. It all seems like too much and yet it flowed so smoothly and so beautifully through the novel and never seemed to tip over the edge into absurd. Tessa faced all of these obstacles head on with amazing poise, wit, and strength. And I loved her for it.
I had so much respect for this powerful girl in a time when women weren’t meant to have any of their own power. She kept it together, managed to not make a fool of herself in situations in which 90% of characters would have, and was just the type of person I want to be and be friends with without ever crossing over into the realm of Mary Sue.
And then there is Jem. Oh, Jem, who I adore. I’d completely forgotten his backstory and was absolutely devastated to find out what his “disability” was. It’s rare these days to be introduced to characters who are going through so much without feeling sorry for themselves, who are ceaselessly kind without being boring, and who rise up when it feels like they should be sinking fast. The whole time the masochistic part of my mind was loving the tension and cruelty of Will, what I really wanted were those short moments with Jem, where he’d say something mildly or make a single gesture mean the world to another person.
My one complaint about Jem is that I feel like he’s not fully developed yet. I want to know what lights his soul on fire. What makes him angry. What it is that he fears. And I’m sure that I’ll get it, too.
I did struggle with this book initially. It wasn’t just that I was confusing the characters and the setting with TMI, but also that it took me awhile to move out of that world of quick action and battles to this one with social etiquette and proper phrasings. The beginning of this story, despite the action, does take a while to really get rolling. It was entertaining enough to be picked back up when I put it down, but it took me nearly 200 pages to reach that point where I couldn’t bear to put it down, I just had to speed through and find out what happened next and who the Magister was and what Will would do next and who would live through the battle.
Overall, a very solid Cassandra Clare experience. I have now moved back over to TMI - City of Fallen Angels to be exact – and am facing the same struggles in transitioning, but that’s beside the point.
The point is that I had finals this morning at 8am in my most difficult class of the semester and I decided to stop studying after only two hours and stay up til 2am reading Clockwork Angel instead.
I think a part of it is the name Herondale. It is not strictly Jace’s anymore; it’s now shared with Will – rightfully Wills’, if you will. (Teehee.) I feel like Clare did try to differentiate as much as possible between Will and Jace: Jace is blonde and beautiful and made of light and kindness towards the girl he cares about; Will is black-haired and cruel and dark and filled with an inexplicable rage and destructiveness. But I keep imagining Will exactly as I imagine Jace, right down to the blond hair and gentle golden eyes.
Part of me wonders if that’s just because of their shared heritage, as Jace is clearly Will’s descendant, but a bigger part thinks it might be their personalities: Both are snarky, aggressive, self-destructive, unwilling/unable to keep their mouths shut when they should, and fiercely loyal to the people they care about – though Will’s affection for Jem is far more evident that Jace’s for Alec. But I think a huge part of it is the mysterious darkness of their pasts that will be uncovered over the course of their respective series: Jace’s mysterious parentage, horrific upbringing, and concealed pain vs. Will’s mysterious flight from his parents to the Institute, horrifying secret, and wickedly cruel disguise for his hopelessness.
Both are willing to throw themselves in harm’s way with nary more than a smart comment, find amusement in things that they shouldn’t, and hope for the worst: But then comes the main female protagonist, a girl who knows nothing of the world to which she belongs as their lives become entangled, and they are instantly thrown off kilter as they fall almost immediately for a girl with messy hair and a love for all things nerdy … even though that word probably wasn’t invented yet in Will’s situation.
Maybe I should have viewed these books as character studies, I don’t know, but I do know it’s time to get to the point…
I enjoyed this book. It took me a while to figure out how to disentangle one series from the other – especially since I knew Magnus would eventually make an appearance – but, once I did, I got a full set of feelings and anticipations for this book. Even though I’ve read it, I couldn’t remember almost anything that occurred and was pleasantly surprised by some of the twists and turns this novel took.
I love the wider range of characters in this novel: It was nice to have some Mundanes join the mix and see how the Shadowhunter-Downworlder relationship was actually somewhat healthier earlier in Shadowhunter history than in TMI. I loved the relationships and the myriad personalities and the tribulations these characters faced.
The premise of this novel is a fascinating one: If no force of heaven or hell can overcome that which God hath wrought, what if human invention can? It most certainly seems like it will, but I can only assume that it doesn’t since Shadowhunters still exist in TMI.
We follow Tessa as she arrives in London from America to live with her brother following the death of the aunt who had raised her since her parents died in her toddler-hood. Greeted instead by her brother’s denizens, Tessa finds herself trapped in a world of horror as she is imprisoned by a pair of evil witches and forced to learn how to shapeshift into murdered person after murdered person, her brother’s life hanging in the balance, all in preparation for her impending marriage to a mysterious creature known only as the Magister. Hope comes in the form of Will, a Shadowhunter boy, who rescues her the night she is due to be married and, with the help of the London Enclave, they begin an investigation into the identity of the Magister, the rash of robotic creatures appearing throughout the city, the mysterious Pandemonium Club, and the location of her brother.
I really loved Tessa as a character. I loved all the different elements and obstacles Clare threw at her to drag her completely out of her comfort zone: American in London, family dead, kidnapped by witches who essentially torture her into doing magic, rescued by Shadowhunters who terrify her, Downworlder who didn’t even know the Downworld existed, unidentifiable Downworlder on top of that, separated from her last remaining family member, caught up in a boy with more issues than anyone can count, part of some sort of mysterious plot, robots attacking the world. It all seems like too much and yet it flowed so smoothly and so beautifully through the novel and never seemed to tip over the edge into absurd. Tessa faced all of these obstacles head on with amazing poise, wit, and strength. And I loved her for it.
I had so much respect for this powerful girl in a time when women weren’t meant to have any of their own power. She kept it together, managed to not make a fool of herself in situations in which 90% of characters would have, and was just the type of person I want to be and be friends with without ever crossing over into the realm of Mary Sue.
And then there is Jem. Oh, Jem, who I adore. I’d completely forgotten his backstory and was absolutely devastated to find out what his “disability” was. It’s rare these days to be introduced to characters who are going through so much without feeling sorry for themselves, who are ceaselessly kind without being boring, and who rise up when it feels like they should be sinking fast. The whole time the masochistic part of my mind was loving the tension and cruelty of Will, what I really wanted were those short moments with Jem, where he’d say something mildly or make a single gesture mean the world to another person.
My one complaint about Jem is that I feel like he’s not fully developed yet. I want to know what lights his soul on fire. What makes him angry. What it is that he fears. And I’m sure that I’ll get it, too.
I did struggle with this book initially. It wasn’t just that I was confusing the characters and the setting with TMI, but also that it took me awhile to move out of that world of quick action and battles to this one with social etiquette and proper phrasings. The beginning of this story, despite the action, does take a while to really get rolling. It was entertaining enough to be picked back up when I put it down, but it took me nearly 200 pages to reach that point where I couldn’t bear to put it down, I just had to speed through and find out what happened next and who the Magister was and what Will would do next and who would live through the battle.
Overall, a very solid Cassandra Clare experience. I have now moved back over to TMI - City of Fallen Angels to be exact – and am facing the same struggles in transitioning, but that’s beside the point.
The point is that I had finals this morning at 8am in my most difficult class of the semester and I decided to stop studying after only two hours and stay up til 2am reading Clockwork Angel instead.
Content Warnings
Minor: Abandonment, Ableism, Alcohol, Child abuse, Chronic illness, Drug abuse, Fire/Fire injury, Stalking, War, Addiction, Blood, Bullying, Classism, Death, Death of parent, Drug use, Emotional abuse, Gaslighting, Genocide, Gore, Grief, Infertility, Injury/Injury detail, Kidnapping, Murder, Physical abuse, Toxic friendship, Toxic relationship, and Violence
More...