Reviews

Or Else the Light by John Joseph Adams, Hugh Howey

philibin's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

(3.0 Stars)

There were some good stories, a few real rems, and some that just didn't hit the mark with me.

All-in-all, I liked the series, but maybe I would have liked it more if I read each author as a complete story from all three books, and book-hopped between authors.

donotronix's review against another edition

Go to review page

this series was fun overall but some of the stories didn't land and a lot of the political messaging was heavy handed to the point of cringe (not because they were bad politics, but just like twitter liberal fanfic level messaging)

samilearnstoread's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Great collection of short stories. Gave me lots of new authors to follow and worlds to inhabit.

brenn's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I've been reading this triptych off and on since I bought it. All these short stories interconnected in one way or another. A lot of it has sunk into my subconscious, what with what we're living through at the moment. We being America specifically with our political blindness and we as the world with Covid-19. FYI to international folk, this series is predominantly US in focus.

But I feel over all, this qualifies as Hope Punk. Yeah, we're a messed up species, but we survive. The world goes on and we change. And maybe for the better, in the long run.

jenbooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I got these on kindle in a box set, but I'm shelving them as separate books. Honestly, I wish I'd read them through separately, rather than jumping through the kindle links to read each 3-part story as a whole. I think my ratings would have been different.

3.85 stars

YOU HAVE BEEN CROWDFUNDED WE TAKE CARE OF EVERYTHING: PART 3 by CARRIE VAUGHN - 5 stars

SPHERES AND HARMONIES WRACK: PART 3 by TIM PRATT - 3 stars

FAILSAFE DEEP/FAKE: PART 3 by RICH LARSON - 3 stars

DRESSES LETTERS: PART 3 by CADWELL TURNBULL - 4 stars

SAKURA AIDEN: PART 3 by KARIN LOWACHEE - 4 stars

BLOOD RELATIONS TARGETS: PART 3 by ADAM-TROY CASTRO - 5 stars

THE SHADOW PRISONER’S DILEMMA SHADOW PRISONS: PART 3 by CAROLINE M. YOACHIM - 5 stars

INHERITORS OF THE EARTH THE INHERITORS: PART 3 by HUGH HOWEY - 4 stars

A FOREIGN-BORN HEIR WEIGHT OF THE STORM: PART 3 by AN OWOMOYELA - 3 stars

RECOVERY HARVEST: PART 3 by SEANAN MCGUIRE - 5 stars

HUMAN COUNTRY ROBOT COUNTRY: PART 3 by DOMINICA PHETTEPLACE - 4 stars

BLACKBERRIES NIL DESPERANDUM: PART 3 by ALEX IRVINE - 5 stars

THE MACHINE VOTES ROBOTS RISE: PART 3 by TOBIAS S. BUCKELL - 4 stars

THE SADNESS & JOY V. INVADENS: PART 3 by SCOTT SIGLER - 3 stars

MAKING FACES (EARTH) KU KO NÉ Ä: PART 3 by DARCIE LITTLE BADGER - 2.5 stars

WHY CAN’T I SLEEP A LITTLE LONGER? SLUMBERLAND: PART 3 by VIOLET ALLEN - 2.5 stars

THE LAW IS THE PLAN, THE PLAN IS DEATH THE LAWLESS: PART 3 by MERC FENN WOLFMOOR - 3.5 stars (minus a star for second person perspective (you))

severina2001's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

The third book of the Dystopia Triptych closes off the stories that began in the first two books, in some cases pushing the characters years into the future.

Some thoughts: Failsafe: Deep/Fake 3 by Rich Larson takes us into the country, but the chaos of the city follows. This one had a great ending line. The concluding stories of Targets by Adam-Troy Castro, Harvest by Seanan McGuire and Robots Rise by Tobias Buckell all had hopeful endings, but in some cases I felt that they were satisfying but perhaps not all that surprising. On the other hand, the ending of Lawless 3 by Merc Fenn Wolfmoor finished off the anthology by giving us a fabulous, semi-dark yet cathartic ending that reminded me a little of John Carpenter's "Escape From L.A."
More...