410 reviews for:

Shadow Study

Maria V. Snyder

3.96 AVERAGE

slow-paced

I give this one a four because while I enjoyed the plot of this story with all the flashbacks and returning characters, I missed the romance. I know these books aren't solely romantic and that is 100% okay but I feel like Fire Study (the previous book) contained more romantic moments between two of my favorites.

However, I did enjoy the plot and the way everything got twisted in this book. It makes you question everyone and you're not sure who to trust. On the adventure end, it was definitely a 4.5 :)

3/18/15 - done. not sure for certain if the reveal is the reason or not... hopefully i'll find out in early 2016, when Night Study comes out!

3/15/15 - i just started reading this, as i just borrowed it from my library. as i was putting my due date slip in the book a page or two after the end of the story, i just happened to glance at the last line. (i won't say what it is!) if that's the reason what for what happens to Yelena (i won't say what that is either!), right now i'm reading the book from the point of view to find out the ways that information becomes known to her as opposed to her finding out what happened. for me, it's now a HowDunIt, as opposed to a WhoDunIt. i look forward to the journey to the Reveal.

Actual rating: 2.5 stars
“Yelena?”
“Hmm?”
“I’d like you to stay with me while we figure out how to unblock your magic. We’re stronger together.”
“All right.”
He laughed. “I thought I’d have more of a fight.”
“I’m too tired to argue.”
“Then I should take advantage of the situation.”
I cracked one eye open. “And?”
“I’d like you to stay with me forever.”

I was prompted to read this after seeing the above snippet of conversation between Valek and Yelena, which I found quite cute. I loved Poison Study and, while I didn't much like the sequels, Valek and Yelena have always held a spot in my heart. However, the issues I had with the sequels did not vanish in this book – if anything, they intensified.

Once again, Valek and Yelena only spend about 2% of the book together and that time generally consists of them in bed. The fantastic, push-and-shove relationship dynamic and quick dialogue from the first book are gone, replaced by empty platitudes and love-making. The rest of the book was then reduced to a plodding mystery that felt like more of a check-in with old characters than a solid storyline. Valek's chapters primarily consisted of flashbacks of Valek's assassin training and the commander's takeover; while somewhat interesting, I kept assuming they would somehow be tied back into the story, but the ending did not satisfactorily provide an explanation for their inclusion and I was left with the impression that they were just added to increase page-count.

What kept me reading was the need to reach the snippet of conversation, and I confess, there were some boring and detail-oriented pages that I skimmed. I finally found the quote two pages before the end and it wasn't much expanded upon – quite the let down. Can't say I'll be reading the sequels to this one, despite the cliffhanger-ish ending. Or maybe I will, I seem to have a weakness for reading these books despite not really liking the direction they take.


This book seemed a bit out of place to me. Perhaps I read things out of order (I did skip the little books in between, maybe that’s why?) but the plot felt a bit disjointed, referring to characters I didn’t know with histories I didn’t have. And the end didn’t resolve anything, just left us with a blatant cliffhanger. The only reason that I didn’t give this only two stars is that I really enjoyed reading about Valek’s backstory. That was interesting, although didn’t really advance the main, convoluted, storyline.

HOW DO I EVEN BEGIN???? It took me a while to finish this book because of life, work, school and everything else BUT I FINALLY FINISHED and oh my GOODNESSSS!!!! This has officially became one of my favorite series of ALL TIME!

Yelena: I adore her craziness, madness, stubbornness, loyalty and everything about her.
Valek: Deadly but definitely has a soft spot for his woman, Yelena
Janco: BAE
adventurous challenging dark emotional mysterious tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

This book feels like it was combined with Night Study to be one book. I don't know how I feel about it. It just sort of.... stopped. Suddenly. Like I ran into a wall. I'm annoyed.

Let's go back a tad further though.

Things are getting serious in this universe. There's a drug that can paralyse magic and incapacitate a person. There's a drug that can open a person's mind and leave them vulnerable to psychic attacks. There's a type of magic that prevents magic from being used near another person. There's a type of magic, now outlawed and hopefully lost, that allows a person to use another's magical potential as their own. There's a magical way to swap a person's soul into another's body.
There are countless poisons that will be undetectable to the average person.

And then, you have a rag-tag bunch of magicians and assassins and spies trying to keep the world as balanced as they can without everything turning to mush when they go on holiday.

Caught up?

Yelena is a soul-finder. She finds souls. Frees them. Let's them move on. Pretty much what it says on the box.
At the start of this book though, she loses her magic. The rest of the book is a tight plot following her search to find out how she lost her magic - it covers all possible avenues, almost tiresomely at times.

This is also the first time the book has not been told entirely from Yelena's point of view. We get chapters titled with other characters names and the story is told 3rd person from their point of view. Helpful for all the action we miss when Yelena splits the party.

We also get Valek's backstory. I know people were dying to have it and to be honest, I could have done without. The version in my head was so much richer. And he was so much more brutal and fierce for not having a fleshed out backstory.

I'm going to finish this because I love this series and as always, the secondary characters are amazing in Snyder's books. It just didn't rock my world the way the first series did.

adventurous lighthearted fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: N/A
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: N/A

this is like a second part of the trilogy i was reading before which was really really good and all 4 or 5 star reads. this one is still good but i rated it lower cause it just didn’t live up to the other ones. too much was going on and i didn’t follow all of what was happening