Take a photo of a barcode or cover
1.45k reviews for:
THE SECRET OF THE OLD CLOCK. Nancy Drew Mystery Stories No. 1.
Carolyn Keene, Carolyn Keene
3.75 AVERAGE
1.45k reviews for:
THE SECRET OF THE OLD CLOCK. Nancy Drew Mystery Stories No. 1.
Carolyn Keene, Carolyn Keene
3.75 AVERAGE
It was great. I recommend this book to any one that likes mysteries. I loved this book it was a little lower in lexile or (how hard the book is) than most mysteries.
Title: The Secret of the Old Clock – A Timeless Tale of Intrigue and Ingenuity
Introduction:
Hello, sleuths and story lovers! It's Kiba Snowpaw, your alpha Ice Wolf from the frozen world of HowlStrom, where the winds howl, and mysteries lie buried in the snow. Today, I’m digging my claws into the iconic classic that started it all: [b:The Secret of the Old Clock|32979|The Secret of the Old Clock (Nancy Drew Mystery Stories, #1)|Carolyn Keene|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1351534678l/32979._SX50_.jpg|151480] by [a:Carolyn Keene|6001|Carolyn Keene|https://s.gr-assets.com/assets/nophoto/user/u_50x66-632230dc9882b4352d753eedf9396530.png]. This was Nancy Drew’s debut mystery, and oh, does it still shine like frost in the moonlight. Let’s unwrap this vintage puzzle piece by piece.
---
Basic Plot Summary:
The story begins in the quaint, fictional town of River Heights, where 18-year-old Nancy Drew, the plucky daughter of attorney Carson Drew, takes on her very first solo mystery. When the wealthy Josiah Crowley dies, his fortune is left to the snooty, undeserving Topham family. Rumors of a second, fairer will set Nancy on a quest to uncover the truth. Her journey takes her to a crumbling clock, dangerous criminals, and heartwarming allies. The stakes? Justice for Crowley’s true heirs and the unveiling of Nancy as the fearless detective we’ve come to admire.
---
Originality:
For a book penned in 1930, this mystery crackles with originality. Nancy Drew broke stereotypes, presenting a strong, intelligent, and resourceful heroine at a time when such characters were rare. However, its “lost will” plotline—while intriguing—has since become a staple in the genre, showing both its enduring influence and how much the series shaped detective fiction.
---
About the Writer:
The “Carolyn Keene” name is a pseudonym representing a legacy of writers. For this first entry, credit goes to Mildred Wirt Benson, whose spirited writing brought Nancy to life. A pioneer herself, Benson’s influence is felt in Nancy’s blend of bravery and brilliance. Compared to modern writers like Agatha Christie or Enid Blyton, Keene’s approach is less intricate but no less engaging for younger audiences.
---
Analysis/Evaluation:
Character Development:
Main Characters:
Nancy Drew: She’s a trailblazer—a mix of charm, wit, and steel. Unlike today’s gritty detectives, Nancy’s positivity and grace add an evergreen quality to her persona.
Carson Drew: A supportive father who subtly showcases progressive parenting by encouraging Nancy’s independence.
The Tophams: Deliciously unlikeable, these antagonists perfectly contrast Nancy’s virtues.
Supporting Characters:
Allison Turner and her family: They highlight the socioeconomic divide, reinforcing the book’s moral center.
Character Arcs and Relatability:
While Nancy remains static as a role model, the supporting characters provide depth. The victims’ struggles resonate universally, and Nancy’s actions reflect a timeless call for justice.
---
Structure and Mechanics:
The linear narrative ensures accessibility, especially for younger readers. Each chapter ends with a subtle hook, encouraging “just one more chapter” reading. While the writing is straightforward, the descriptions effectively paint River Heights’ idyllic charm.
---
Mechanics and Mystery:
The mechanics of Nancy’s detective work rely on intuition and persistence rather than high-tech gadgets or violence—a refreshing change from modern thrillers. The title, however, is a slight spoiler; as soon as the clock appears, readers can piece together its importance.
---
Impact:
This book laid the foundation for generations of readers to fall in love with mysteries. Its cultural impact transcends its story, making Nancy Drew an icon of empowerment and ingenuity.
---
Hook and Thesis:
The central hook—an old clock hiding a secret—is a classic trope but executed with charm. The thesis is simple yet powerful: wit and determination can overcome greed and corruption.
---
Praise and Critique:
What Sparked This Ice Wolf’s Howl:
- Nancy’s Character: A perfect mix of independence, intelligence, and kindness.
- Moral Core: The book champions fairness and justice, themes that never grow old.
- Cozy Atmosphere: River Heights feels like home—safe yet filled with potential for adventure.
What Left My Paws Cold:
- Simplicity of Mystery: While engaging, the plot lacks the twists seasoned readers might crave.
- Underutilized Clock: The titular clock plays a minor role, leaving room for a more thrilling climax.
---
Personal Enjoyment:
As a wolf who thrives on mystery and lore, I found "The Secret of the Old Clock" an enjoyable frolic through simpler times. It doesn’t offer the mind-bending puzzles of, say, Agatha Christie, but it delivers heartwarming charm and timeless lessons.
---
Highlights and Drawbacks:
Highlight: Nancy’s tireless pursuit of justice—a reminder of the power of determination.
Drawback: The straightforward resolution, which felt slightly rushed and overly convenient.
---
Comparison:
Compared to other youth detective stories like [b:The Tower Treasure|87976|The Tower Treasure (The Hardy Boys, #1)|Franklin W. Dixon|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1539191892l/87976._SY75_.jpg|1081259] from the Hardy Boys series, Nancy Drew shines as a more polished, self-reliant protagonist. However, her cases lean cozier and less perilous than some modern young-adult thrillers like [b:The Mysterious Benedict Society|40605329|The Mysterious Benedict Society (The Mysterious Benedict Society, #1)|Trenton Lee Stewart|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1529611235l/40605329._SY75_.jpg|80497].
---
Overall Conclusion:
[b:The Secret of the Old Clock|32979|The Secret of the Old Clock (Nancy Drew Mystery Stories, #1)|Carolyn Keene|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1351534678l/32979._SX50_.jpg|151480] is a charming entry into the world of mystery fiction. It’s a gateway book—simple enough for young readers yet nostalgic for older audiences revisiting their first sleuthing adventures. While the plot may seem tame by today’s standards, its legacy as a cornerstone of the genre is undeniable. As an Ice Wolf who’s roamed the frosty trails of countless tales, I proudly recommend this book to those eager to explore the roots of detective fiction.
Rating:
Story: 4.0 ⭐ / 5 ⭐
Characters: 4.5 ⭐ / 5 ⭐
Atmosphere: 5.0 ⭐ / 5 ⭐
Overall: 4.3 ⭐ / 5 ⭐
Stay frosty, my literary pack. Until next time, may your mysteries be gripping and your adventures endless.
Introduction:
Hello, sleuths and story lovers! It's Kiba Snowpaw, your alpha Ice Wolf from the frozen world of HowlStrom, where the winds howl, and mysteries lie buried in the snow. Today, I’m digging my claws into the iconic classic that started it all: [b:The Secret of the Old Clock|32979|The Secret of the Old Clock (Nancy Drew Mystery Stories, #1)|Carolyn Keene|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1351534678l/32979._SX50_.jpg|151480] by [a:Carolyn Keene|6001|Carolyn Keene|https://s.gr-assets.com/assets/nophoto/user/u_50x66-632230dc9882b4352d753eedf9396530.png]. This was Nancy Drew’s debut mystery, and oh, does it still shine like frost in the moonlight. Let’s unwrap this vintage puzzle piece by piece.
---
Basic Plot Summary:
The story begins in the quaint, fictional town of River Heights, where 18-year-old Nancy Drew, the plucky daughter of attorney Carson Drew, takes on her very first solo mystery. When the wealthy Josiah Crowley dies, his fortune is left to the snooty, undeserving Topham family. Rumors of a second, fairer will set Nancy on a quest to uncover the truth. Her journey takes her to a crumbling clock, dangerous criminals, and heartwarming allies. The stakes? Justice for Crowley’s true heirs and the unveiling of Nancy as the fearless detective we’ve come to admire.
---
Originality:
For a book penned in 1930, this mystery crackles with originality. Nancy Drew broke stereotypes, presenting a strong, intelligent, and resourceful heroine at a time when such characters were rare. However, its “lost will” plotline—while intriguing—has since become a staple in the genre, showing both its enduring influence and how much the series shaped detective fiction.
---
About the Writer:
The “Carolyn Keene” name is a pseudonym representing a legacy of writers. For this first entry, credit goes to Mildred Wirt Benson, whose spirited writing brought Nancy to life. A pioneer herself, Benson’s influence is felt in Nancy’s blend of bravery and brilliance. Compared to modern writers like Agatha Christie or Enid Blyton, Keene’s approach is less intricate but no less engaging for younger audiences.
---
Analysis/Evaluation:
Character Development:
Main Characters:
Nancy Drew: She’s a trailblazer—a mix of charm, wit, and steel. Unlike today’s gritty detectives, Nancy’s positivity and grace add an evergreen quality to her persona.
Carson Drew: A supportive father who subtly showcases progressive parenting by encouraging Nancy’s independence.
The Tophams: Deliciously unlikeable, these antagonists perfectly contrast Nancy’s virtues.
Supporting Characters:
Allison Turner and her family: They highlight the socioeconomic divide, reinforcing the book’s moral center.
Character Arcs and Relatability:
While Nancy remains static as a role model, the supporting characters provide depth. The victims’ struggles resonate universally, and Nancy’s actions reflect a timeless call for justice.
---
Structure and Mechanics:
The linear narrative ensures accessibility, especially for younger readers. Each chapter ends with a subtle hook, encouraging “just one more chapter” reading. While the writing is straightforward, the descriptions effectively paint River Heights’ idyllic charm.
---
Mechanics and Mystery:
The mechanics of Nancy’s detective work rely on intuition and persistence rather than high-tech gadgets or violence—a refreshing change from modern thrillers. The title, however, is a slight spoiler; as soon as the clock appears, readers can piece together its importance.
---
Impact:
This book laid the foundation for generations of readers to fall in love with mysteries. Its cultural impact transcends its story, making Nancy Drew an icon of empowerment and ingenuity.
---
Hook and Thesis:
The central hook—an old clock hiding a secret—is a classic trope but executed with charm. The thesis is simple yet powerful: wit and determination can overcome greed and corruption.
---
Praise and Critique:
What Sparked This Ice Wolf’s Howl:
- Nancy’s Character: A perfect mix of independence, intelligence, and kindness.
- Moral Core: The book champions fairness and justice, themes that never grow old.
- Cozy Atmosphere: River Heights feels like home—safe yet filled with potential for adventure.
What Left My Paws Cold:
- Simplicity of Mystery: While engaging, the plot lacks the twists seasoned readers might crave.
- Underutilized Clock: The titular clock plays a minor role, leaving room for a more thrilling climax.
---
Personal Enjoyment:
As a wolf who thrives on mystery and lore, I found "The Secret of the Old Clock" an enjoyable frolic through simpler times. It doesn’t offer the mind-bending puzzles of, say, Agatha Christie, but it delivers heartwarming charm and timeless lessons.
---
Highlights and Drawbacks:
Highlight: Nancy’s tireless pursuit of justice—a reminder of the power of determination.
Drawback: The straightforward resolution, which felt slightly rushed and overly convenient.
---
Comparison:
Compared to other youth detective stories like [b:The Tower Treasure|87976|The Tower Treasure (The Hardy Boys, #1)|Franklin W. Dixon|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1539191892l/87976._SY75_.jpg|1081259] from the Hardy Boys series, Nancy Drew shines as a more polished, self-reliant protagonist. However, her cases lean cozier and less perilous than some modern young-adult thrillers like [b:The Mysterious Benedict Society|40605329|The Mysterious Benedict Society (The Mysterious Benedict Society, #1)|Trenton Lee Stewart|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1529611235l/40605329._SY75_.jpg|80497].
---
Overall Conclusion:
[b:The Secret of the Old Clock|32979|The Secret of the Old Clock (Nancy Drew Mystery Stories, #1)|Carolyn Keene|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1351534678l/32979._SX50_.jpg|151480] is a charming entry into the world of mystery fiction. It’s a gateway book—simple enough for young readers yet nostalgic for older audiences revisiting their first sleuthing adventures. While the plot may seem tame by today’s standards, its legacy as a cornerstone of the genre is undeniable. As an Ice Wolf who’s roamed the frosty trails of countless tales, I proudly recommend this book to those eager to explore the roots of detective fiction.
Rating:
Story: 4.0 ⭐ / 5 ⭐
Characters: 4.5 ⭐ / 5 ⭐
Atmosphere: 5.0 ⭐ / 5 ⭐
Overall: 4.3 ⭐ / 5 ⭐
Stay frosty, my literary pack. Until next time, may your mysteries be gripping and your adventures endless.
adventurous
lighthearted
mysterious
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
This was our mother/daughter book choice this month. Of all the books we've read together, this one I liked the least. It was like one never ending mystery cliche. The girls loved it, so that is really all that matters.
Yes, I've decided to re-read my old Nancy Drew books. I think for a sub-200-page children's book, it's pretty great. The text is more difficult than I think we would give to second-graders nowadays, but the story itself is fairly simple. I look forward to reading a few more to see if they all seem as simplistic now, or if they can manage to seem as intricately mysterious as I thought they were a couple of decades ago (I remember The Crooked Bannister as being particularly impressive).
adventurous
lighthearted
mysterious
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
I can see how this was pretty great for children back in the day, but we have come a long way in terms of sexism and complexity in young adult fiction.
This was one of the first series that got me into reading when I was in middle school. This book brought me back. Nothing beats reading a Nancy Drew mystery.