Reviews

Blameless by Gail Carriger

lamom77's review

Go to review page

3.0

I am a bit torn on this series. I like the unique storyline and really like the main characters and the author's humor. However, I am feeling bored with the way the story is progressing. I found myself skimming most of the middle of this book as it did not feel necessary to the overall storyline. Not sure I will continue with this series although my curiosity on how it will end in Book 5 may push me to pick up the next 2 installments.

readingjag's review

Go to review page

2.0

Two and a half stars, really. It wasn't my favorite in the series (I feel Soulless will always be the best, I'm afraid). Too little interaction between Alexia and Lord Maccon, too much running away from vampires. The writing is still clever as can be and the world is interesting, but I feel like Carriger wants us to be really in love with Madame Lefoux. Which, I'm sorry, but I'm just not. Oh, and at the end when Alexia makes up with her husband by asking him for expensive presents? That was just kind of distasteful to me.
I couldn't put the first book down--I devoured it in just a couple of days, and it took me a week to finish this one. That pretty much says it all.

whatsmacksaid's review

Go to review page

3.0

Three and a half stars--full review later.

missbookiverse's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Über 3 Jahre ist es her, dass ich Changeless eingeschnappt zuschlug. Die Entwicklung am Ende hat mir so sehr missfallen, dass ich einen ganzen Stern abgezogen habe. Lustig wie sich die Wahrnehmung verändern kann, denn als ich Blameless anfing, hatte ich plötzlich gar kein Problem mehr mit den Entwicklungen. Ist doch aufregend, dass Alexia schwanger ist. Und dass Conall nicht glaubt, das Kind sei von ihm, bringt Spannung rein (außerdem ist ja irgendwie klar, dass er noch zur Besinnung kommen wird). Ich habe mich köstlich amüsiert über seine demente Betrinkerei, die der arme Lyall ständig ausbaden muss. Überhaupt finde ich Lyall ganz toll (und auch die Entwicklung mit Biffy). Dagegen war Alexias Handlungsstrang mit den Templern manchmal ein bisschen langweilig. Ich fand es toll Paris, Nizza und Florenz mit ihr zu bereisen (obwohl wir gern ein bisschen mehr Zeit in Paris hätten verbringen können, wo es schon auf dem Cover abgebildet ist), aber das wissenschaftliche Gebrabbel der Menschen um sie herum, war mir zu hoch. Dafür ist es herrlich wie mokiert die Engländer auf Kaffee reagieren und dass Alexia eine Vorliebe für Pesto entwickelt.

Ich hab fast das Gefühl ich musste für die Reihe erst ein bisschen älter werden. Mir fällt es auch lange nicht mehr so schwer den Schreibstil zu lesen. Ich freue mich jetzt riesig auf die nächsten 2 Bände, die ich definitiv noch dieses Jahr lesen werde.

alanaleigh's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Well phooey. I loved Soulless, I really quite liked Changeless, but I just wasn't pleased with Blameless. It was missing some spark that the other two had in spades. Part of it has to do with what I felt was an unnecessary location change and part of it had to do with Alexia herself, who had the opportunity to be a stronger and more interesting character (aka just staying as she was) and Carriger opted not to take the story in an interesting direction for the sake of a tidier ending. If you haven't read the second book in the series, Changeless, then stop reading this review now if you hope to have the ending of book #2 unspoiled.

In Changeless, we learned that a mummified preternatural had a shocking range for the whole nullifying supernaturals thing, thus reducing any supernatural in a certain radius mortal. This provided Alexia etc. with the surprising information that preternatural bodies seemed to keep their soul-sucker/curse-breaker abilities when mummified -- good thing that no one knows how the Egyptians mummified folks. Should word get out, though, surely renewed efforts might be made to relearn this trick and at that point, Alexia becomes worth more dead than alive. Alexia was able to dispose of the preternatural mummy, thus returning her husband's old clan (who were in possession of the offending mummy) back into their usual werewolf selves, but her personal life took a significant hit when what should be a happy event (the discovery of her pregnancy) turned ghastly. Her husband raged, insisting it couldn't be his, as immortals could no longer procreate. He flew off the handle and Alexia was forced to abandon Scotland post haste.

Maybe I'm crazy, but I thought this was a *fantastic* cliffhanger ending. It made me feel that Gail Carriger was really being faithful to the true natures of her characters (and hence, my anger at the end of Blameless). Of *course* Conall Maccon might flip out and overreact when faced with information that suggests his wife was unfaithful if everything he's ever known about supernatural reproductive capabilities is true. What made it truly awesome, though, was that he was so venomous in his denunciation of her. His language towards the woman he is supposed to love was completely horrifying. I loved the dramatic position it put Alexia in at the beginning of Blameless. She has a loyal band who believe she's telling the truth and what they have on their hands is a miracle indeed (even if they know next to nothing as to how this is possible), but Lord Maccon is initially convinced of her infidelity (even if we all know he'll realized the truth soon enough) and his complete and utter overreaction is unforgivable. It's awesome.

Once he's been completely sauced for a few days (quite a feat for a supernatural), Lord Maccon was bound to come around and realize that his Alexia would never cheat on him, but the damage is done and eventually he'll need to figure out how to get her back, if that is, indeed, possible. Alexia, meanwhile, would simply seek refuge in the home of her friend, Lord Akeldama, but apparently Lord Akeldama and his drones have completely disappeared. So Alexia takes off for Italy and we begin to suspect all new things of Floote's capabilities and what services he might have rendered for Alexia's father. Italy turns out to be a colossally bad decision on several levels (sure, the Templars will protect her, but they'll also want to use her and experiment a bit with her) and unsurprisingly, the main action of the book has to deal with escaping their clutches (while still surviving vampire attacks, as a price has been put on Alexia's head by the vamps). Back in London, Professor Lyall is trying to hold the pack together (and fighting off challengers who would see Lord Maccon in a precarious position) while simultaneously attempting to sober up the Alpha and drum some sense into his head. Lyall is also almost entirely alone in trying to figure out what plots are afoot that would drive Lord Akeldama into hiding.

What results from the London intrigues is a wonderful plot twist... but then everything goes wishy washy in Italy. It's spoilers from here on out, folks, so consider yourselves warned.

In London, the storyline about Biffy is actually quite excellent -- Biffy is one of Lord Akeldama's drones who is kidnapped by the potentate. Lord Akeldama flees the city (or at least goes into deep cover hiding) as he's clearly being threatened and yet we assume he's doing something to get Biffy back and not just relying on poor stretched-thin Lyall. Just when it appears that Conall and Lyall have rescued the chap... Biffy gets shot. The only choice is to let him die or try to turn him into a werewolf (though as a drone of Lord Akeldama, clearly he hoped to be a vampire). The twist here is really quite wonderful, and yet this doesn't make up for the inconsistency in Alexia's actions and lack of imagination with regards to that plot ending.

Alexia does manage to achieve one thing with her trip to Italy -- she finds the proof she needs to prove the baby is Conall's. Preternaturals cannot tolerate the presence of other preternaturals to the point that no preternatural female has ever been able to carry a child to term. They inevitably miscarry and the only way preternaturals can pass along their abilities is when males procreate with human females; and preternaturals always seem to "breed true," thus resulting in preternatural babies. The key here is that they can procreate with humans which doesn't quite qualify when Lord Conall Maccon is concerned, even if he is, essentially, human when touching Alexia. But because of his supernatural state, a preternatural and a supernatural procreating would create a child with some soul, so the child is not a preternatural. Alexia finds an account of a preternatural/vampire offspring known as a "soul-stealer" which is apparently even more fearsome than a preternatural. It could be interesting, but it's all terribly convenient. Ah well.

Truth be told, my real issue is this: I feel that Carriger did not properly keep to Alexia's character with the ending of this novel. In England, Conall publishes a public statement insisting that Alexia's child is his and in Italy, Alexia ends up inadvertently finding this out (a little unlikely, but fine). She bursts into tears (hormones, whatever) and when he shows up later on, she forgives him with the only "stipulations" of that forgiveness hinging on gifts. Alexia, our proud and strong preternatural, completely forgives her husband for saying horrifying things to her face and completely doubting her word and trust... and she does this so easily, with the gifts being only, really, a bit of humor? I'm sorry, but I was hoping Carriger was a better writer than this and could have seen the possibilities that come with Alexia refusing to forgive Conall (at least for now). To me, this shows that Carriger herself is too in love with Conall and is willing to forgive him anything, but quite frankly, for the way Alexia is established, I would assume that his error was far too extreme to simply be forgiven on the spot. It's not like his agreeing to purchase her requested items are a serious factor here and we know it, so I won't make any irritating comments about her being bought off, as we know it's not true. Alexia simply misses her husband and is willing to forgive him... but I honestly believe her character up to this point would see her as too stubborn to just give in. It's more than the public humiliation, it's the fact that he immediately assumed she'd been unfaithful and didn't even try to entertain the possibility of trusting her before flying off the handle. HIS character held true, but Alexia's yielded as soon as she might get her husband back. I was expecting her to appreciate his apology but refuse to return to him on principle. Clearly, this was a major issue for me and rather ruined the novel on the whole, even if I thought things were a bit dull anyway (at least for Alexia in Rome).

It's all quite unfortunate, as the novel was perfectly passable up to that point -- amusing, even if not quite as great as the first two. This hasn't turned me completely off of the novels, but I really do hope that Carriger returns to something delightful in book four or I'm going to think she's quite lost the fresh sparkle that charmed me so much in Soulless.

smuttea_matcha's review

Go to review page

3.0

I'll admit, I was a little disappointed with this book. I guess it's because of the lack of romance {since I'm pretty much a sucker for a little romance in every book I read}. One good quality of this book is the action. Alexia fights more {this time with a stool} and Floote and Madame Lefoux are featured more. I absolutely love Madame Lefoux because she's so modern and she doesn't care much for what other people say. Lord Maccon doesn't show up much in this book. :( I thought Carriger could have wrote more on Alexia's feelings on carrying a child, but I guess she didn't since this isn't written in first person and Alexia doesn't like showing much weakness. Alexia's humor and wit was lovely {as always} and Floote makes a wonderful sidekick. I enjoyed Lyall's scenes {since he sort of takes the front row for Werewolf since Conall was mostly away or inebriated}. I also didn't care much for the little plot twist Carriger threw in there. I guess there's two, but I didn't care for the one involving the vampire chase. I don't want to spoil it, so I'll just move on to the next thing. XD I liked this book, but I didn't love it like I did the first in the Parasol Protectorate series {Soulless}.

amym84's review

Go to review page

4.0

After the explosive ending of [b:Changeless|6933876|Changeless (Parasol Protectorate, #2)|Gail Carriger|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1292566141s/6933876.jpg|7165488], I was really happy that I waited to read this series until all the books were out. I was really interested to see what would become of Alexia. While i did enjoy this book, I missed the interactions between Lord and Lady Maccon. Plus there was the fact that our dear Lord Akeldama was out of the picture for most of the book as well. She did have Madam Lefoux along for her adventure and I really do like the inventor so it was nice to see her again.

This book really took Alexia and cast her out of her already established place. True, in Chageless she leaves London to go to Scotland, but she was traveling with friends and she was going to meet up with Conall. Here, she leaves London for Italy with no Ivy, Conall, or Akeldama. She's in a completely different setting with characters that we haven't gotten to learn too much about at this point. The good side of this is the fact that we do get to learn more about Madam Lefoux and Floote, whose devotion to Alexia I've always liked.

I will say that I enjoyed the fact that Professor Lyall got more page time to himself in this book. With Lord Maccon not mentally fit to do anything,it's obvious that Lyall would have to take up the reigns.

After Alexia discovers her delicate condition, along with the rest of London, she's considered a scandal in Lonodn society and even her own family (although not surprising) casts her out. When somone tries for her life (again) she thinks that maybe a change of location would be best. She decides on Italy and we finally get to meet the often mentioned Templars. Let me tell you I was not impressed and Alexia probably wasn't either. We did get to learn a lot more about her preternatural state and I can kind of see threads of storylines that will lead us to the conclusion.

I continue to adore the world the Gail Carriger had created. One of the only things I have small issue with was the easy resolution at the end. I didn't want anything to be dragged out, but sometimes when it comes to Alexia I find her lack of emotions a little irritating. I know this is blamed on her not having a soul, but it seems to me that there are times when the reader can tell she cares for something very much, but won't admit to it, and I feel like her lack of emotion in this case was the same. I would have liked to have seen her a little more out of her element in this case. She had some very dramatic and heartbreaking things happen to her over the past few weeks and I don't think it would have hurt to really let Conall know just what he did to her. I just don't really think he understands.

Regardless, I look forward to continuing the series and look forward to other books written in this world. Until Then!

gem9589's review

Go to review page

5.0

edited rating: 5 stars

one those books I think I would love to read over and over again and still find delight in. This series has everything I appreciate in a sff-romance- banter, humor, worldbuilding, a light mytsery plot and tricky supernatural politics. I love all the characters in this series, from the impersonal, menacing yet weirdly goofy German scientist to the delightful side characters who we've seen already before, manipulating things from the bg and really coming into their own in this volume. I don't know why I rated this volume 3 stars on first read- maybe because I was so mad at Conall. But I really see that his reaction was out of love, and deep loyalty to Alexia in the first place.

Standout characters for me in this volumes had to be Alexia & Lyall both. Alexia showed a side of her that I hadn't seen since book 1. Lyall was just incredibly competent the whole way through, knowing *exactly* what it took to keep his pack together and to snap Conall back to his senses. Lefoux was a treasure but weirdly was rendered useless in a few scenarios during the book, knocked unconscious for whatever reason in ome scene so that Alexia could prove herself and then subsequently be saved by Channing.

And god, Channing. I love me a bastard. I genuinely need more of that man in my life.

In any case, this might have been my favorite volume of them all, despite the lack of sexy times between Alexia & Conall. I'm taking a break from the series *for now*, but this volume generally just encapsulates everything I could want in a politically fraught, often humorous, yet still heartfelt supernatural adventure across Europe.

kraley's review

Go to review page

3.0

I didn't like this one as well as the first two books, but I still am so in love with the characters that I will continue to read as long as she will keep writing. Part of why I think it wasn't as good as the others is the lack of Ms Hisslepenny(?) and Lord Akeldama. Because she was traveling, we missed them both. I think this one only had one garish hat description, and not nearly enough tea time for me. Love the Parasol Protectorate though!

susan_ok's review

Go to review page

4.0

Love this series. So fun.