Scan barcode
golden_lily's review against another edition
4.0
Read This Review & More Like It At Ageless Pages Reviews
In an exciting and joyful sequel that will delight sci-fi fans of all ages, we once again join the Hashoone family on their privateer ship around Jupiter. Two years have passed since the first book, and the Shadow Comet has fallen on some hard luck. The Hydra is embroiled in a nasty legal battle, ensuring the Hashoone’s haven’t seen their money for capturing the infamous pirate ship, and with tensions heating up between the Jovian Union and Earth, they’re not capturing many merchant vessels, either. But when a long dead ship turns up with a clue to a buried treasure, Tycho and his siblings are once again on the hunt.
It’s a great plot that brings to mind classic adventure stories, a’la Treasure Island, and Star Trek. In addition to treasure hunting and space battles, there’s espionage as a mysterious government figure joins the search and a real focus on the individual strengths of each of the kids. Possibly my favorite part was a solid explanation for something I found arbitrary in the first novel: the contest for captain. The kids’ deeds are still being entered in The Log, but they’re also starting to question why only one can be Captain. The reason being, that while the kids may respect each other if they all get their own ships, will the respect their cousins? Second cousins? Soon space would be full of Hashoones fighting each other, and family has to be there to support, not tear down. Great message, though I think Tycho made it clear it’s not so cut and dried.
There are very few negatives this time around. I’m not sure the time skip of two years works, as I don’t know if the twins felt any older. Everyone still has the same roles on the ship and still talks about the Hydra, so it didn’t feel like any time had actually passed. This isn’t a huge issue that detracts from the book, just a little quibble. Additionally, the universe feels smaller this time, as most of the traveling either takes place off screen or is between Jupiter’s moons. There is a time limit on the treasure hunt, that ends up feeling kind of silly and rushed,
The time skip could have been used to introduce more mature plot elements, but it’s not. There are still no love interests, though the crew get a bit more screen time, so there are other characters than the immediate family. There is a side plot dealing with an ex-spacer who’s developed substance abuse problems, which might be a bit heavy for some younger readers. It’s used to teach a really good lesson, though, and all actual use takes place off screen. There are some fight scenes, again with off screen deaths, but nothing more intense than an episode of TNG.
Comparing the book to Star Trek is both a huge compliment and the best description I can give. It lives up to Roddenberry’s desire to mix Gulliver’s Travels’ adventure and morals with the mystery of space. I know the author writes for the Star Wars EU, but perhaps he should consider a move to the better Star franchise*.
*This is of course said in love and jest. Except that it’s not. Trekkie 4 Lyfe.
Whatever he writes for, I hope he continues the Jupiter Pirates, as it has the potential to inspire a lot more wonder.
In an exciting and joyful sequel that will delight sci-fi fans of all ages, we once again join the Hashoone family on their privateer ship around Jupiter. Two years have passed since the first book, and the Shadow Comet has fallen on some hard luck. The Hydra is embroiled in a nasty legal battle, ensuring the Hashoone’s haven’t seen their money for capturing the infamous pirate ship, and with tensions heating up between the Jovian Union and Earth, they’re not capturing many merchant vessels, either. But when a long dead ship turns up with a clue to a buried treasure, Tycho and his siblings are once again on the hunt.
It’s a great plot that brings to mind classic adventure stories, a’la Treasure Island, and Star Trek. In addition to treasure hunting and space battles, there’s espionage as a mysterious government figure joins the search and a real focus on the individual strengths of each of the kids. Possibly my favorite part was a solid explanation for something I found arbitrary in the first novel: the contest for captain. The kids’ deeds are still being entered in The Log, but they’re also starting to question why only one can be Captain. The reason being, that while the kids may respect each other if they all get their own ships, will the respect their cousins? Second cousins? Soon space would be full of Hashoones fighting each other, and family has to be there to support, not tear down. Great message, though I think Tycho made it clear it’s not so cut and dried.
There are very few negatives this time around. I’m not sure the time skip of two years works, as I don’t know if the twins felt any older. Everyone still has the same roles on the ship and still talks about the Hydra, so it didn’t feel like any time had actually passed. This isn’t a huge issue that detracts from the book, just a little quibble. Additionally, the universe feels smaller this time, as most of the traveling either takes place off screen or is between Jupiter’s moons. There is a time limit on the treasure hunt, that ends up feeling kind of silly and rushed,
The time skip could have been used to introduce more mature plot elements, but it’s not. There are still no love interests, though the crew get a bit more screen time, so there are other characters than the immediate family. There is a side plot dealing with an ex-spacer who’s developed substance abuse problems, which might be a bit heavy for some younger readers. It’s used to teach a really good lesson, though, and all actual use takes place off screen. There are some fight scenes, again with off screen deaths, but nothing more intense than an episode of TNG.
Comparing the book to Star Trek is both a huge compliment and the best description I can give. It lives up to Roddenberry’s desire to mix Gulliver’s Travels’ adventure and morals with the mystery of space. I know the author writes for the Star Wars EU, but perhaps he should consider a move to the better Star franchise*.
*This is of course said in love and jest. Except that it’s not. Trekkie 4 Lyfe.
Whatever he writes for, I hope he continues the Jupiter Pirates, as it has the potential to inspire a lot more wonder.
scubajen's review against another edition
4.0
A fun sci-fi thriller, that has a few "morals of the story" bits. Most enjoyable.
missprint's review against another edition
4.0
Who knew space pirates could be so fun? ("WE DID," say the 11 and 10 year olds in the audience, for whom this book is PERFECT.)
Okay, so I didn't even REALIZE this was a sequel, so my review is basically going to treat it as the first in a series or a stand-alone. This is actually an excellent quality in a series-based book, because despite getting it out of order I didn't feel lost at all. - Okay, slightly, upon reflection. There were moments when they'd talk about particular incidents or characters (all, I realize now, surrounding the Hydra) when I felt a little lost, but mostly I was able to cobble it together.
"Curse of the Iris" follows Tycho and his family (twin sister, older brother, parents and half-cyborg grandfather) and crew and (in the case of Tycho's mother) captain their starship Shadow Comet. Tycho and his siblings are competing for the captaincy of the ship - per family tradition, one child will inherit the ship, while the others move dirtside to the family holdings.
The Hashoone family catches wind of a "cursed" treasure and sets out to find it, following leads that dig up long-dead family history as well as much less dead politics.
Most of all, I loved that this was an exciting, space pirate-y tale that meshed perfectly with family dynamics and strong relationships that categorize good middle grade.
Okay, so I didn't even REALIZE this was a sequel, so my review is basically going to treat it as the first in a series or a stand-alone. This is actually an excellent quality in a series-based book, because despite getting it out of order I didn't feel lost at all. - Okay, slightly, upon reflection. There were moments when they'd talk about particular incidents or characters (all, I realize now, surrounding the Hydra) when I felt a little lost, but mostly I was able to cobble it together.
"Curse of the Iris" follows Tycho and his family (twin sister, older brother, parents and half-cyborg grandfather) and crew and (in the case of Tycho's mother) captain their starship Shadow Comet. Tycho and his siblings are competing for the captaincy of the ship - per family tradition, one child will inherit the ship, while the others move dirtside to the family holdings.
The Hashoone family catches wind of a "cursed" treasure and sets out to find it, following leads that dig up long-dead family history as well as much less dead politics.
Most of all, I loved that this was an exciting, space pirate-y tale that meshed perfectly with family dynamics and strong relationships that categorize good middle grade.
More...