Scan barcode
agnewjacob120's review
adventurous
dark
emotional
hopeful
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
kb_208's review against another edition
3.0
This was a pretty interesting read with some good events taking place. But since this is kind of a stand alone novel, I don't know much about the surrounding history or time period. I don't read the comics, and this was taken from those. It was still a decent book, though.
jaredkwheeler's review against another edition
3.0
Star Wars Legends Project #33
Background: Knight Errant was published in January 2011. It was written by [a:John Jackson Miller|20028|John Jackson Miller|https://d.gr-assets.com/authors/1272316895p2/20028.jpg], , whose other works of course include the excellent [b:Star Wars Omnibus: Knights of the Old Republic, Volume 1|17705149|Star Wars Omnibus Knights of the Old Republic, Volume 1|John Jackson Miller|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1364740474s/17705149.jpg|24753104] comic series (my review) and unique [b:Lost Tribe of the Sith: The Collected Stories|13023324|Lost Tribe of the Sith The Collected Stories (Star Wars Lost Tribe of the Sith)|John Jackson Miller|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1326407357s/13023324.jpg|18186079] (my review).
Knight Errant is set 1032 years before the Battle of Yavin (or 1000 years before The Phantom Menace). The novel begins a month or two after the events of [b:Aflame|11099746|Aflame (Star Wars Knight Errant Comic, #1)|John Jackson Miller|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1403209180s/11099746.jpg|16021815] (my review), with the return of protagonist Kerra Holt and rival Sith Lords (and siblings) Daiman and Odion. The action takes place across several previously unmentioned planets in Sith space.
Summary: Jedi Kerra Holt, still stranded far behind Sith lines with no hope of Republic support, remains torn between her obligation to help downtrodden Sith subjects and her desire to wage war on their masters. Meanwhile, she knows that any action she takes may have grave and unexpected consequences. But she doesn't know that, behind the state of permanent conflict between rival Sith in the sector, darker forces are pulling the strings, and they may have plans for her, as well.
Review: I really wanted to like this more than I did. So much so that I kept trying to convince myself that I was enjoying it until I finally realized near the end that I really wasn't very much. As I said of the comic that precedes this story, the set-up has a lot of potential, and I still love how unique it is among other Star Wars stories. The things I like about this premise (and at least some of the execution) are just as true of this novel as they were of that comic.
It may be that some of my problems have to do with this not being a comic, itself. Given that it continues a story begun in a comic, and is continued in further comics, I wonder why the decision was made to write this portion of Kerra's story as a novel, instead. There is an episodic quality to the story that would probably have been better served by the multi-issue comic format. And a lot of the new characters, particularly the diverse variety of Sith Lords that appear throughout the story, are practically begging for a more illustrated depiction.
The book's portrayal of the Sith in general remains it's greatest strength. We often don't get a lot of variety when it comes to Sith Lords in Star Wars. They all kind of want the same things, and they all kind of go about getting them in the same ways, just with different-shaped lightsabers. This really feels like Miller took a step back and said, "Wait a minute, evil can take a lot of forms. Let's explore some of those." There are half a dozen or more Sith that play a significant role in this story, and every one of them feels totally unique and fresh and distinct from the others. I loved that.
Unfortunately, I'm just not as excited about the protagonist. Not only is she far from being the most interesting character, she never feels very interesting in her own right at all. Miller leaves all the scheming and plotting and ambiguity and nuance to his other characters. Kerra is just a standard-issue hero Jedi. And even though she finds herself dealing with no-win scenarios on a scale that no other hero Jedi has to face, her unique circumstances don't make her any more unique as a character. She ends up playing second-fiddle to the other two semi-protagonist anti-heroes: Rusher, an independent mercenary with a crack force of artillery for-hire to the Sith with the deepest pockets, and Narsk, a Bothan spy and saboteur whose true motivations and allegiances remain shrouded in mystery for much of the novel. But they aren't really interesting enough (or developed enough) to carry the entire story, either.
And, while several other characters are sporadically engaging, the story moves forward a bit at a time without developing any recognizable greater arc until quite late in the book. I noted in my review of Aflame how mystifying it is that Kerra failed to kill a Sith that was at her mercy, without any explanation as to why. This bizarre decision is rendered even more annoying when Kerra spends the first half of this book attempting to assassinate the same Sith she spared before. But that just ends up feeling like an attempt to give her something to do until the rest of the plot could develop.
Trying to pinpoint exactly why this novel didn't work for me, even though so many elements of it did, I keep coming back to Kerra herself. Miller doesn't really do anything with her. It's almost as though, after making her the central character of this series, he lost interest and spent all of his attention elsewhere. She doesn't seem to grow a great deal as a character over the course of the book. She rarely seems to have any agency, always being used or manipulated by those around her, and generally lacks any meaningful choice in how to proceed. This is exacerbated by her stubborn black-and-white attitude towards anyone she regards as morally-compromised (which is basically everyone in Sith space). Even though she is constantly confronted with the complicated moral realities of negotiating life among the Sith, she remains weirdly inflexible towards several characters who are just doing what they have to do to survive.
There's still enough payoff and potential here that I'm looking forward to the remainder of the series, but there are too many obvious flaws for this really to work the way it should.
C+
Background: Knight Errant was published in January 2011. It was written by [a:John Jackson Miller|20028|John Jackson Miller|https://d.gr-assets.com/authors/1272316895p2/20028.jpg], , whose other works of course include the excellent [b:Star Wars Omnibus: Knights of the Old Republic, Volume 1|17705149|Star Wars Omnibus Knights of the Old Republic, Volume 1|John Jackson Miller|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1364740474s/17705149.jpg|24753104] comic series (my review) and unique [b:Lost Tribe of the Sith: The Collected Stories|13023324|Lost Tribe of the Sith The Collected Stories (Star Wars Lost Tribe of the Sith)|John Jackson Miller|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1326407357s/13023324.jpg|18186079] (my review).
Knight Errant is set 1032 years before the Battle of Yavin (or 1000 years before The Phantom Menace). The novel begins a month or two after the events of [b:Aflame|11099746|Aflame (Star Wars Knight Errant Comic, #1)|John Jackson Miller|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1403209180s/11099746.jpg|16021815] (my review), with the return of protagonist Kerra Holt and rival Sith Lords (and siblings) Daiman and Odion. The action takes place across several previously unmentioned planets in Sith space.
Summary: Jedi Kerra Holt, still stranded far behind Sith lines with no hope of Republic support, remains torn between her obligation to help downtrodden Sith subjects and her desire to wage war on their masters. Meanwhile, she knows that any action she takes may have grave and unexpected consequences. But she doesn't know that, behind the state of permanent conflict between rival Sith in the sector, darker forces are pulling the strings, and they may have plans for her, as well.
Review: I really wanted to like this more than I did. So much so that I kept trying to convince myself that I was enjoying it until I finally realized near the end that I really wasn't very much. As I said of the comic that precedes this story, the set-up has a lot of potential, and I still love how unique it is among other Star Wars stories. The things I like about this premise (and at least some of the execution) are just as true of this novel as they were of that comic.
It may be that some of my problems have to do with this not being a comic, itself. Given that it continues a story begun in a comic, and is continued in further comics, I wonder why the decision was made to write this portion of Kerra's story as a novel, instead. There is an episodic quality to the story that would probably have been better served by the multi-issue comic format. And a lot of the new characters, particularly the diverse variety of Sith Lords that appear throughout the story, are practically begging for a more illustrated depiction.
The book's portrayal of the Sith in general remains it's greatest strength. We often don't get a lot of variety when it comes to Sith Lords in Star Wars. They all kind of want the same things, and they all kind of go about getting them in the same ways, just with different-shaped lightsabers. This really feels like Miller took a step back and said, "Wait a minute, evil can take a lot of forms. Let's explore some of those." There are half a dozen or more Sith that play a significant role in this story, and every one of them feels totally unique and fresh and distinct from the others. I loved that.
Unfortunately, I'm just not as excited about the protagonist. Not only is she far from being the most interesting character, she never feels very interesting in her own right at all. Miller leaves all the scheming and plotting and ambiguity and nuance to his other characters. Kerra is just a standard-issue hero Jedi. And even though she finds herself dealing with no-win scenarios on a scale that no other hero Jedi has to face, her unique circumstances don't make her any more unique as a character. She ends up playing second-fiddle to the other two semi-protagonist anti-heroes: Rusher, an independent mercenary with a crack force of artillery for-hire to the Sith with the deepest pockets, and Narsk, a Bothan spy and saboteur whose true motivations and allegiances remain shrouded in mystery for much of the novel. But they aren't really interesting enough (or developed enough) to carry the entire story, either.
And, while several other characters are sporadically engaging, the story moves forward a bit at a time without developing any recognizable greater arc until quite late in the book. I noted in my review of Aflame how mystifying it is that Kerra failed to kill a Sith that was at her mercy, without any explanation as to why. This bizarre decision is rendered even more annoying when Kerra spends the first half of this book attempting to assassinate the same Sith she spared before. But that just ends up feeling like an attempt to give her something to do until the rest of the plot could develop.
Trying to pinpoint exactly why this novel didn't work for me, even though so many elements of it did, I keep coming back to Kerra herself. Miller doesn't really do anything with her. It's almost as though, after making her the central character of this series, he lost interest and spent all of his attention elsewhere. She doesn't seem to grow a great deal as a character over the course of the book. She rarely seems to have any agency, always being used or manipulated by those around her, and generally lacks any meaningful choice in how to proceed. This is exacerbated by her stubborn black-and-white attitude towards anyone she regards as morally-compromised (which is basically everyone in Sith space). Even though she is constantly confronted with the complicated moral realities of negotiating life among the Sith, she remains weirdly inflexible towards several characters who are just doing what they have to do to survive.
There's still enough payoff and potential here that I'm looking forward to the remainder of the series, but there are too many obvious flaws for this really to work the way it should.
C+
graff_fuller's review
adventurous
challenging
informative
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.25
You know...I enjoyed the story...as I read it, but it really didn't pull me in.
It's got a lot going against it. The only thing that we know...that ties it to Star Wars are the Jedi and the Sith, oh...and lightsabers.
The rest is nebulous (honestly). It was well written, as much that the author does, but I guess I wanted more Sith inspired history spread in and out of the plot. There was a LITTLE, but not nearly enough IMO.
I also thought that it would be slightly darker (in tone). There were dark moments, but I think if he'd punched that aspect of the storyline...a bit, it would've been better.
AND, I do believe that more world building should've been done (in the way that it connects this to the earliest Jedi/Sith confrontations. Like the big named Jedi and Sith stories sprinkled in. I don't know. I just wanted to revel in the earlyness of the story, but it was meh.
I'm moving forward in this time period, having already read the Darth Bane trilogy (Path of Destruction, then Rule of Two, then Dynasty of Evil), Dawn of the Jedi - Into the Void, then this story. Next one is Lost Tribe of the Sith - The Collected Stories, then Red Harvest, then reading the four book Old Republic series (Revan, Decieved, Fatal Alliance and Annihilation). I will then be done with the Old Galactic era.
It's got a lot going against it. The only thing that we know...that ties it to Star Wars are the Jedi and the Sith, oh...and lightsabers.
The rest is nebulous (honestly). It was well written, as much that the author does, but I guess I wanted more Sith inspired history spread in and out of the plot. There was a LITTLE, but not nearly enough IMO.
I also thought that it would be slightly darker (in tone). There were dark moments, but I think if he'd punched that aspect of the storyline...a bit, it would've been better.
AND, I do believe that more world building should've been done (in the way that it connects this to the earliest Jedi/Sith confrontations. Like the big named Jedi and Sith stories sprinkled in. I don't know. I just wanted to revel in the earlyness of the story, but it was meh.
I'm moving forward in this time period, having already read the Darth Bane trilogy (Path of Destruction, then Rule of Two, then Dynasty of Evil), Dawn of the Jedi - Into the Void, then this story. Next one is Lost Tribe of the Sith - The Collected Stories, then Red Harvest, then reading the four book Old Republic series (Revan, Decieved, Fatal Alliance and Annihilation). I will then be done with the Old Galactic era.
hstapp's review against another edition
3.0
Kerra Holt. A Jedi born into an age when Jedi are warriors. She's on her own trapped in Sith Space.
It's quite an interesting story, and it's pretty cool that they included a bit of a comic that takes place before the book at the end as well.
I found the book to be well written and interesting. Junky cobbled together ships always seem to be a big hit, and I liked the conflict and differences among the sith lords in this region of space.
It's quite an interesting story, and it's pretty cool that they included a bit of a comic that takes place before the book at the end as well.
I found the book to be well written and interesting. Junky cobbled together ships always seem to be a big hit, and I liked the conflict and differences among the sith lords in this region of space.
mtaylor414's review against another edition
3.0
All in all I enjoyed it. It kind of felt like Stargate SG1 with all the Sith Lords. I always thought there was only one at a time. Shows you how much I know. I probably would have given it more than 3 stars, but this was my first sci-fi book and it took some getting used to. I would have enjoyed it as a movie.
justin_wong's review
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.25
medea_jade's review against another edition
5.0
I absolutely love all the books about the ancient Sith empire. This one was exceptional. Great plot, well written, added so much to the mythology.
kecresser's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
funny
mysterious
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
evgenia127's review against another edition
adventurous
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0