Reviews with content warning for Suicide - Blood Over Bright Haven

Despite the slow start it began to pick up in the second half. The climax and ending of the book was a total page-turner.
It presented the brutality of living in a racist and sexist world without feeling like this brutality was included for the sake of being voyeuristically grimdark.
The story really hit the sweet spot of despair and hope.
The magic system of the world is interesting and well thought out.
The heroine was given space to be flawed and complex. She was a really good example of how a progressive person living in a racist society will make racist assumptions. The changes in her belief system and world perspective over the course of the novel felt well earned.
I enjoyed the chemistry between the two leads.
The story was an interesting examination of intersectionality.

Bad

Occasionally the dialog felt a little bit too on the nose regarding the themes of the story.
The first half of the book was slow.

YMMV

The book contains an in-depth exploration of themes that some people might find difficult. While I felt like it struck the right balance between despair and hope, it's ultimately not a happy story.
The opening scene included one of my biggest first-chapter pet peeves. I appreciate this scene a lot more having read the entire story and seeing where the author ended up going with it, but it definitely almost put me off the book.

Content Warnings

bookish_panda's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional hopeful inspiring sad tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

“Maybe it would be a hundred generations before the sun rose on a life of dignity for their descendants, but the worthwhile run was not the sprint.”

What a masterful story. Heartbreaking and so necessary in these times. It was difficult to read sections of this book knowing how close it is to what has and still is going on in today’s world. As sad as the ending was (I’m still crying) it was perfect and hopeful.

The author portrayed the toxicity of patriarchy, colonialism and, above all, white feminism/fragility to such a perfect degree. I feel like everyone should read this book!

Content Warnings

boba_nbooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional inspiring mysterious reflective sad tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

Starting off the year with a 5-star read feels SO good. Truly, this book is probably a rare 6-star read for me. It's just that good.

The city of Tiran is considered a utopia--a place where people can live freely and enjoy the conveniences of modern living thanks to the magic provided by the High Magistry. Sciona is the first woman accepted into the High Magistry. With a sizable ego and a strong drive to prove herself, Sciona sets out to become one of the best mages Tiran has ever seen. However, fitting in the boy's club is more difficult than she thought, and she ends up getting stuck with an assistant who doesn't know anything--a Kwen immigrant, originally a janitor in the building, who is at the bottom of the totem pole. As time goes on, Sciona realizes that this indigenous Kwen, Thomil, who used to live in the land beyond Tiran, is more than her peers have made him out to be--he's highly intelligent and asks questions that keep Sciona on her toes. It turns out that his previous experience as a hunter beyond Tiran's barrier, and as a Kwen, is invaluable to Sciona's research and leads her to discover something no mage before her ever has. This secret could change the world for the better... or make it even more volatile than it already is. Sciona and Thomil have to decide if the truth is worth the risk.

Blood Over Bright Haven is one of the most thought-provoking books I've read (its intellect and subject matter comparable to Babel by R.F. Kuang). Not only does it provide insight into the human psyche and how far we're willing to go for our own egos and absolution, it also pulls back the curtain on the true climate of our current reality. If I've learned anything from this book, it's the fact that our actions have consequences, and we need to be aware of what kind of impact they have on our environment and our fellow human beings.

The female main character, Sciona, gives a great character study into a modern white woman who goes through life unaware of what kind of effect their behavior has on others. Her journey was a difficult one to watch as it was all too real to me, but I'm glad I sat in that discomfort and took the time to reflect on my own life and the ways I might be causing harm. After her discovery of the true cost of magic in Tiran, I loved watching how she took that guilt and, instead of pushing it on the Kwen who do not benefit from those feelings, used it as energy into making a mark on the world that would not soon be forgotten. A mark that will, hopefully, lead others to question the cost of magic and how they use it.

The male main character, Thomil, is a complex character mirroring an indigenous person in the real world. His struggles of coming to terms with being the last of his people was heartbreaking but a very authentic experience. Thomil could have easily been a one-dimensional character, but he truly did come to love Sciona even though she stood for everything he despised for years. He had to come to terms with the fact that some people can change for the better and that, despite their best efforts, sometimes their solo advocacy is not enough to revolutionize an entire society. Throughout the novel, Thomil stayed true to his people and his ideals. He did have to assimilate into society to an extent, but through his niece, Carra, his people live on.

All in all, read this book. Blood Over Bright Haven is such a radical read that requires rapt attention and self reflection, and it is completely worth it. I hope this novel is read and remembered for years to come and is one that will compel people to action.

Content Warnings

thenoboshow's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional hopeful mysterious sad tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? N/A
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

Content Warnings

More...