Scan barcode
unladylike's review against another edition
5.0
Tom King and crew are killing it in this retrospectively-told tale of a major ongoing bloodbath that occurred when Batman had just a year of caped crusading under his utility belt. If you've been following Batman in recent years, you know Riddler has leveled up to being one of the most menacing antagonists. He still speaks in riddles all the time, but his Question Mark symbol is now dripping in gruesomely shed blood. He derives his power not from cheap, gimmicky parlor tricks and elaborate death traps, but by being a tactician who uses his psychological manipulation skills to control others while seeing all likely outcomes and moves in any given "game."
This book has plenty of great easter eggs, like when Joker takes a cab to 69 Dick Sprang Ave., which the driver points out is kind of a funny name for an address. At first the reference was lost on me, and I just remembered the time in university when some of my friends looked through the phone book (those thick books with thin white, yellow, and grey pages that nobody uses now except as a doorstop) and found a Dick Weiner who lived on Wood Street, and paid him a visit just to confirm it was real. Anyway, Dick Sprang is actually the artist who first drew Riddler back in 1948!
This volume is also a milestone for the culmination of its narrative mechanic - Bruce Wayne and Selina Kyle are talking in bed in their underwear throughout the whole book, and they adorably call one another "Bat" and "Cat" both in and out of costume. Minor plot spoiler that's probably not a secret by now: they get engaged to be married! I'm actually enjoying their chemistry and complicated romance in this series, but it pisses me off more that they're allowing this after refusing to allow Batwoman's previous writer to have her (Kate Kane) marry her long-time girlfriend, claiming that a wedding in the Bat Family was not allowed.
The art throughout is superb and fitting for the story. There are some plot holes, but the overall point is achieved to great effect. Batman is basically ineffective and powerless against the murder and mayhem Riddler and Joker are able to cause. This is shown in some particularly powerful pages by just having a multi-page spread of black and white photos of a sample selection of the deceased, listing their name, how they died, and who killed them. It is a very long list.
I found it a bit incredible that Joker and Riddler were so quickly able to recruit ALL of the Gotham-based villains (aka Batman's Rogues Gallery) to their respective sides. Like, it wasn't really explained at all how those two had that much leverage, especially in the case of villains with tremendous superpowers, invulnerability, and no family or loved ones. But aside from that little squabble, this is just a fan-fucking-tastic Batman book.
This book has plenty of great easter eggs, like when Joker takes a cab to 69 Dick Sprang Ave., which the driver points out is kind of a funny name for an address. At first the reference was lost on me, and I just remembered the time in university when some of my friends looked through the phone book (those thick books with thin white, yellow, and grey pages that nobody uses now except as a doorstop) and found a Dick Weiner who lived on Wood Street, and paid him a visit just to confirm it was real. Anyway, Dick Sprang is actually the artist who first drew Riddler back in 1948!
This volume is also a milestone for the culmination of its narrative mechanic - Bruce Wayne and Selina Kyle are talking in bed in their underwear throughout the whole book, and they adorably call one another "Bat" and "Cat" both in and out of costume. Minor plot spoiler that's probably not a secret by now: they get engaged to be married! I'm actually enjoying their chemistry and complicated romance in this series, but it pisses me off more that they're allowing this after refusing to allow Batwoman's previous writer to have her (Kate Kane) marry her long-time girlfriend, claiming that a wedding in the Bat Family was not allowed.
The art throughout is superb and fitting for the story. There are some plot holes, but the overall point is achieved to great effect. Batman is basically ineffective and powerless against the murder and mayhem Riddler and Joker are able to cause. This is shown in some particularly powerful pages by just having a multi-page spread of black and white photos of a sample selection of the deceased, listing their name, how they died, and who killed them. It is a very long list.
I found it a bit incredible that Joker and Riddler were so quickly able to recruit ALL of the Gotham-based villains (aka Batman's Rogues Gallery) to their respective sides. Like, it wasn't really explained at all how those two had that much leverage, especially in the case of villains with tremendous superpowers, invulnerability, and no family or loved ones. But aside from that little squabble, this is just a fan-fucking-tastic Batman book.
daileyxplanet's review against another edition
4.0
Joker and Riddler are at each other's throats and Batman and Gotham are in the middle. Basically a sequel to the Zero Year archs. More of a character driven story of how low Batman will sink to stop the senseless murder of Gothamites. The body count is surprisingly high, and practically every classic villain makes some sort of appearance.
priorglass's review against another edition
4.0
Nothing hurts more than finding out Kite Man's background. Tom King is a champ.
mazloum's review against another edition
3.0
Good: Gorgeous art, interesting storyline.
Bad: Plenty of clutter, characters that sometimes add nothing to the plot.
Important: Kite Man. Hell yeah.
Bad: Plenty of clutter, characters that sometimes add nothing to the plot.
Important: Kite Man. Hell yeah.
rbreade's review against another edition
Points deducted for artist Clay Mann drawing Catwoman in action wearing high heels during "The Ballad of Kite Man"; this violates the internal logic of both story and character, a serious no-no when trying to suspend the reader's disbelief about a world of costumes, masks, and superheroes. Points regained for writer Tom King's complex resolution to the over-the-top mayhem in "The War of Jokes and Riddles," especially in unexpectedly turning the spotlight on Kite Man and finding a seam of pathos in this normally one-note and deep bench bad guy.
moonlightmai's review against another edition
4.0
Finally finished reading the war of jokes and riddles, probably one of my fave batman arcs in a while, it was so intense and fun I’m glad I waited and read it in one go because it’s more engaging that way.
Tom King has been a hit or miss for me, I really only enjoyed the first arc, that last 3 have been meh for me.
Tom made me actually care for Kite Man, his story is tragic and sad but I actually enjoyed him here, I also loved the whole is it a joke or riddle thing, and the joker asking himself if his jokes are riddles. I also enjoyed the riddler in this book.
Can’t wait for the wedding!
Tom King has been a hit or miss for me, I really only enjoyed the first arc, that last 3 have been meh for me.
Tom made me actually care for Kite Man, his story is tragic and sad but I actually enjoyed him here, I also loved the whole is it a joke or riddle thing, and the joker asking himself if his jokes are riddles. I also enjoyed the riddler in this book.
Can’t wait for the wedding!
scottpm's review against another edition
5.0
Wow that was good. A brutal story with awesome visuals and storytelling.
bat_books's review against another edition
1.0
one star for batcat. i didn't think it was possible for a comic to be entirely telling & not showing, but here we are. this was just a bunch of drawings of the batman rogues gallery standing in a lineup together