Reviews

This Shattered World by Meagan Spooner, Amie Kaufman

nettevc's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

so good!

booktallie's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

So after finishing These Broken Stars, I quickly jumped into reading the sequel This Shattered World.

Jubilee Chase and Flynn Cormac should have never met. “Lee” is the captain of the army assigned the job of crushing the rebellion on Avon. Flynn is one of the rebels fighting for his freedom. But when Flynn captures Lee and brings her back to the rebel’s secret camp as a prisoner, the rebels are all in favor of slaying Lee. But before the can kill her, Flynn makes the decision that changes his life, he
leaves, fleeing the camp with Lee in tow.

Even those Tarver and Lilac are not the main characters in the story; we do cross paths with them and find them living life magnificently. However much like in These Broken Stars; Spooner and Kauman team up once again bring to life another round of fantastic world building and character detailing. The scenes are elaborate and well described. While Flynn and Jubilee’s story doesn’t take place on the same planet as Lilac and Tarver, it does take place in the same world; and the mystery of the Whisperers and the dubious thoughts towards the LaRoux industry is only elevated in this installment. The character detailing is very lifelike and realistic. They have complex personalities and the emotions makes you feel like you know who they true are.

Not only are Lee and Flynn phenomenal individually but they are spectacular as a couple as well. The urgency, the desperation, all of it is absolutely wonderful and you can’t help but to root for Lee and Flynn. However once again much like their debut team Spooner and Kauman took their sweet time getting to the good parts but the forbidden love is so worth the wait.

As a sequel, This Shattered World was a perfect match for These Broken Stars. I can’t wait to see what happens in the finale and recommend this great love story to all.

kaikai1618's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

4.47 stars

leafblade's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

It took a while for the story to start being interesting, but once it did it was as phenomenal as the first book. The whispers are the romance was really well done and avoided insta love with all its strength. Seeing Lilac and Tarver again was a nice surprise too, so I hope to see all four of them in the final book!

annettebooksofhopeanddreams's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

It's been a while since I read the first book in this series. I enjoyed it immensely. I remember that I got myself the other two books because I really wanted to read them right away. And as so often happens I was distracted by other books and other stories. However, I was in the mood for sci-fi. Real sci-fi. With a touch of romance and I rediscovered this series. So, it was finally time to dive into this second book.

The authors take their time to paint a picture of the planet, of life on this planet and of the situation on the planet. It took me a little while before I really connected with the characters and the place, but once the where and how were established and we started to focus more on the who and the what I got more and more invested. By the end of the story I just wanted to keep on reading and reading and reading, because I had to find out if the characters would succeed.

It also took a while before the overarching plot, connecting the first and this second book, made a clear appearance. But once I realized what was going on I got more and more exited. It got even better when our lovebirds from the first book made an appearance and our characters started to join forces. Of course I knew that things were not really gonna be solved in this book, there is a third book after all, and yet I loved how it truly felt like there was some progress.

The main star of the book, and probably the series in general, is the romance though. I love how the authors have these characters grow closer and closer. They're on opposite sides of the conflict. They're starcrossed lovers in the true sense of the word. And yet time after time they find ways to choose each other, to pick each other, to fight for each other. Sometimes someone comes along who is truly worth changing the planet for.

I can't wait to read the third book and to find out how it all ends!

teeggzz's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

*3.75

Again, another almost 4 star. This series isn't one of my favorites, merely a time killer but they're just a bit of mindless entertainment, I guess. Just like These Broken Stars I started off liking this book, almost thought it was better than the first and then it just kinda dwindled on. I don't know, I just felt really detached from the story.

So let's talk about the main couple, Jubilee and Flynn. I enjoyed their hate to love even if they did begin to trust one another fairly early on. The distance and back and forth element between the two was nicely done, although I didn't particularly feel any emotion towards them as a pair. Despite their questionable romance I did enjoy each character individually. Both Flynn and Jubilee were so complex. Jubilee being were methodical and hard hearted while Flynn was more of a sporadic pacifist. I also did like seeing Tarver and Lilac in this novel.

My main problem is I don't think I care too much about the plot line. The start was action packed, gritting and tense but the middle dragged immensely. It was a pretty standard ending that didn't have me gasping or tearing my hair out but it was well done. I just don't think I'm all that invested in what happens to the characters and that's why this wasn't as enjoyable as it could've been. Although the whole element with the whispers was cleverly done and definitely left an impact.

Over all this was a standard read that wasn't necessarily bad, nor mind blowing. I probably will be picking up the last book and I just hope that's not a 3.75 as well XD.

clockworkbook's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

3.75

abaugher's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Beautiful! Love how it loosely and smoothly ties in with the first book.

izzys_internet_bookshelf's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

3.5/5

This book was dramatically different from the first book in the series. Which is good and bad. There were many questions I had for the first book that weren't answered in this. But, on the plus side.. hey! New characters to cry over when they almost die. I really enjoyed the two main characters and how their story grew. The plot was pretty crazy and I did get confused at times, but it was fun to just read it and not really think about it so much. I do hope that the last book isn't another story and some how merges the two previous stories together somehow.. Now that would be a satisfying ending. My favorite scene from the book was when the two main characters were star-gaising and talking about what they would do after the war was over.

sdloomer's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

--4/5 stars--
"Some things you just can't live with."

"Some things you can't live without."
I read this whole book straight through with absolutely no intention of doing so, so I think that should speak volumes for how entertained I was. To be honest, I was rather bored with the first third, especially since the romance seemed to come on a little too fast and too strong, but once that was squared away, I found myself turning pages faster and faster.

This story takes place eight months after These Broken Stars and doesn't follow Tarver or Lilac--though they do have small cameos--but instead focuses on two new leads, Jubilee and Flynn. Though they have a similar relationship as Tarver and Lilac, as in: they don't really work well together until they're thrown into an impossible situation, theirs is rather more violent and painful. To put it shortly, they're on opposite sides of a ten year long war, with neither side willing to back down or give up.

I am wondering how the third book will tie everything together; the problems presented in the first two books seem pretty vast and too intricate to just be wrapped up with a pretty bow. I'm very curious to see what the deal is with these strange other "beings" that aren't physical at all--but I'm sure they're meant to stay a mystery (please no, I'd really really like an explanation!) to add to the allure.
-----
These Broken Stars: ★ ★ ★ ★