Reviews

Catching a Storyfish by Janice N. Harrington

tashrow's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Moving away from Alabama is hard for Keet. She is moving closer to her beloved grandfather though, which helps. The two of them spend days together fishing, something that Keet used to find challenging because she loves to talk and tell stories. But at her new school, she is teased for her accent and suddenly her words start to dry up. She finds it hard to make friends and even at home she isn’t talking much. Slowly though, Keet starts to find her voice again and makes a new friend. Just as she starts to talk though, her grandfather suffers a stroke and struggles with the slow recovery. Keet though has just the solution, showing him the way forward with stories.

Harrington’s verse novel is pure loveliness. Throughout she plays with various poetic forms, delicately moving from haiku to concrete poems to narrative form with many others included too. She nicely lists them at the end of the book, talking about their difficulty and what makes a poem that form. Her skill is evident throughout with all of the forms as she tells the story of Keet and her progress from losing her confidence and her voice to finding it again. The voice of Keet’s new friend is including in the poems as well, often playing against ones in Keet’s voice.

The characters here are given time to grow and stretch on the page. Keet is a wonderful character filled with a great energy and drive, but also stuck in a lack of confidence that hits her out of nowhere. It is a book about quiet and both its power and the ability to drown in being silenced. It is a book about friendship, about family and the importance of finding your place and your voice.

Beautifully written and strikingly gentle, this book is a celebration of the individual and their ability to speak their own stories. Appropriate for ages 8-12.

nexttotheblues's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I really enjoyed this one, especially for a novel in verse. This one had a really strong story that I think fit the format really well. This was also some of the most interesting and fun language usage I've ever read in a kids novel. I loved the family and the characterization and how Allegra was basically Latina Violet from Matilda.
I also had a small inward struggle about Keet being some sort of Mary Sue character since she's just the best storyteller ever and what kid actually has an amazing talent like that, but you know what? I think it worked really well in this and sometimes you just want to hear about people who can do things better.

book_beat's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

7. CATCHING A STORYFISH by Janice N. Harrington // #middlegrademarch
.
“I like the way library books talk to me, and / tell me stories, and make me remember / I have stories, too.”
.
Written in verse, CATCHING A STORYFISH tells the story of a little girl named Keet and her recent move north to live near her grandpa. In the transition, she deals with normal struggles: finding friends, hobbies, and her own voice. Fishing and talking with her grandpa is her one constant.

What is special about this middle grade book: the poems are very accessible and use a few different forms (which the author explains in the back). It would be a great tool for the poet-novice. I enjoyed Keet’s journey to becoming a writer and how stories are used to help heal, too.
More...