Scan barcode
alimoo511's review
adventurous
dark
mysterious
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
caitlin705's review
adventurous
dark
mysterious
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.75
The characters are all morally askew but it makes for them to be interesting and have depth emotions, but the forging of friendship/relationships is very fun to read about!
patchworkbunny's review against another edition
4.0
Some say you only get one chance to visit Smiler’s Fair. When first death comes, the fair moves on, its buildings drawn around the land by mammoths. As the fair nears a small goat-herding settlement, one of the herders is about to learn the truth of who he is. He has eyes the colour of the moon and a fate bound with that of the kingdom.
Smiler’s Fair is happily lacking in many of the things that put me off epic fiction; it’s a decent length and there isn’t a cast of millions, with complicated relationships or confusing names. There are a fair number of characters but soon their narratives weave together and I can see the point of them all by the end of book one. The book is split into two parts, partings and meetings, which I think works quite well with the forever in motion cast of characters.
It doesn’t get too bogged down with politics of the rulers. Yes, we have a king who wished to murder his son and an arranged marriage to help a family’s position, but these acts move the plot into place. The story revolves around a boy who is part of a prophecy and the return of the moon god who has been missing for a considerable time.
The fair itself is a movable town. Its habits are that of a travelling circus but instead of performance, its wares consist of vice; gambling, drinking, sex. There’s also merchants and worshippers and a menagerie for visitors to gaze at unusual animals. Its movement throughout the land introduces us to different people and cultures, whilst providing a thread which ties everything together.
I liked the nomadic culture of the various races. The ship-born are nobility and their castles are forever in motion, dragged around lakes by mammoths. The land-born, move around too, for there are unimaginable things in the darkness. If your home keeps the ground in darkness for too long, the worm men will come. There are some who form permanent settlements, but most think this is madness.
As for the races, the cast is diverse. For once, the ruling race isn’t based on white Europeans, they have dark skin and hair. Attitudes towards women and sexuality differ amongst cultures, but there is the feeling of a complete world with lots of different people in it. The people of the plains see women as those in charge, even to the point where they will castrate clever boys to stop them losing their brains as they grow into men. The whore’s point of view we see in the book is male and gay and there’s women sharing multiple husbands. The Ashane are little more medieval about their women, but this fits in amongst a multicultural world.
Eric’s story felt a little out of place to me. The world is one mostly without magic (we see it return alongside the return of the moon god’s presence). Yet where Eric ends up is such a contrast to the rest of the world-building. Perhaps, as the story moves on, and more world-building is added, it will become more real in my mind. I did like the giant bat character though!
On a final note, there are plenty of willies (honestly, I think every time my boyfriend looked over I was on a page with a penis) and not too much sexual violence. I would say the opening chapter is the goriest bit and it mellows a lot after that. The second instalment, The Hunter’s Kind, will definitely be heading onto my bookshelves.
Review copy provided by publisher.
Smiler’s Fair is happily lacking in many of the things that put me off epic fiction; it’s a decent length and there isn’t a cast of millions, with complicated relationships or confusing names. There are a fair number of characters but soon their narratives weave together and I can see the point of them all by the end of book one. The book is split into two parts, partings and meetings, which I think works quite well with the forever in motion cast of characters.
It doesn’t get too bogged down with politics of the rulers. Yes, we have a king who wished to murder his son and an arranged marriage to help a family’s position, but these acts move the plot into place. The story revolves around a boy who is part of a prophecy and the return of the moon god who has been missing for a considerable time.
The fair itself is a movable town. Its habits are that of a travelling circus but instead of performance, its wares consist of vice; gambling, drinking, sex. There’s also merchants and worshippers and a menagerie for visitors to gaze at unusual animals. Its movement throughout the land introduces us to different people and cultures, whilst providing a thread which ties everything together.
I liked the nomadic culture of the various races. The ship-born are nobility and their castles are forever in motion, dragged around lakes by mammoths. The land-born, move around too, for there are unimaginable things in the darkness. If your home keeps the ground in darkness for too long, the worm men will come. There are some who form permanent settlements, but most think this is madness.
As for the races, the cast is diverse. For once, the ruling race isn’t based on white Europeans, they have dark skin and hair. Attitudes towards women and sexuality differ amongst cultures, but there is the feeling of a complete world with lots of different people in it. The people of the plains see women as those in charge, even to the point where they will castrate clever boys to stop them losing their brains as they grow into men. The whore’s point of view we see in the book is male and gay and there’s women sharing multiple husbands. The Ashane are little more medieval about their women, but this fits in amongst a multicultural world.
Eric’s story felt a little out of place to me. The world is one mostly without magic (we see it return alongside the return of the moon god’s presence). Yet where Eric ends up is such a contrast to the rest of the world-building. Perhaps, as the story moves on, and more world-building is added, it will become more real in my mind. I did like the giant bat character though!
On a final note, there are plenty of willies (honestly, I think every time my boyfriend looked over I was on a page with a penis) and not too much sexual violence. I would say the opening chapter is the goriest bit and it mellows a lot after that. The second instalment, The Hunter’s Kind, will definitely be heading onto my bookshelves.
Review copy provided by publisher.
blodeuedd's review against another edition
3.0
I should have written this at once while I remembered names!
*looks at blurb*
No one was particularly hero like, more like a gang of antiheroes, and to be honest, villains.
Nethmi, is the one sent to marry some old guy. I mean I get it, but at the same time, come on girl, that is the way of noblewoman.
Dae Hyo, keeps mourning his slaughtered people.
Eric, was the whore who kept wanting more.
Marvan, was this psycho guy who loved killing. Riiight, not someone to meet.
Krish, oh yes the lost prince who grew up a goatherder but not even he was the hero from the beginning. Even he fs up.
Which is strange, cos with all this seemingly dark characters one would think it would be a dark book, but it wasn't. It felt lighter than epic, not by much. We did not really get to see the world much, it was more about the characters running in different directions making bad decisions so that they one day can meet up, or not. I did learn about their religions since Krish is the Moon God born again. Or so they say.
The book kept a nice pace, which meant it was always good, never ok, never awesome either. Good enough for me to want to see more because all things holy, what the f. Seriously deranged people some of them.
*looks at blurb*
No one was particularly hero like, more like a gang of antiheroes, and to be honest, villains.
Nethmi, is the one sent to marry some old guy. I mean I get it, but at the same time, come on girl, that is the way of noblewoman.
Dae Hyo, keeps mourning his slaughtered people.
Eric, was the whore who kept wanting more.
Marvan, was this psycho guy who loved killing. Riiight, not someone to meet.
Krish, oh yes the lost prince who grew up a goatherder but not even he was the hero from the beginning. Even he fs up.
Which is strange, cos with all this seemingly dark characters one would think it would be a dark book, but it wasn't. It felt lighter than epic, not by much. We did not really get to see the world much, it was more about the characters running in different directions making bad decisions so that they one day can meet up, or not. I did learn about their religions since Krish is the Moon God born again. Or so they say.
The book kept a nice pace, which meant it was always good, never ok, never awesome either. Good enough for me to want to see more because all things holy, what the f. Seriously deranged people some of them.
eshied's review against another edition
4.0
A much darker book than the cover or blurb would suggest - but in the best possible way. Easily takes a place in the Grimdark genre alongside Joe Abercrombie. Elucidating a fascinating world through several viewpoints that intertwine and intersect, it's the start of what promises to be a great epic. Also, the UK hardcover is one of the most beautiful books I own - in person the cover is just stunning.
vickylovesreading's review against another edition
5.0
I loved the multi narrative nature of this book and became incredibly attached to some characters throughout the story. The world building was intricate and I seriously enjoyed this book.
annataxis's review against another edition
3.0
First 50% was a bit meh, got into it in the second half.
hjalmar's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0