Reviews

As We Were/Strange Someone by Kel McDonald, Melissa Curtin

valjeanval's review

4.0

Not totally in love with the artwork, but I think it might just take a bit of adjustment. The "Strange Someone" art is like Jhonen Vasquez took a course in moe-manga. A bit disconcerting, but more than covered by the wonderful dialogue. "As We Were" is more seriously toned, but equally engaging. Also, it's just nice to read funny, cute werewolf stories. I like werewolves. I picked these up at Otakon on a whim and my sister's recommendation. Glad I did and will definitely be following McDonald's other works.

loveinpanels's review against another edition

2.0

This is getting two stars for "it was okay." I wish I hadn't spent money on this book, if I'm honest. Boring, not much in the way of romance or mystery, and the artwork wasn't Kel's best writing or choice for collaboration. their later stuff is better.

noysh's review

3.0

Two charming urban fantasy short stories, written by McDonald and drawn by two different artists. They were actually both of them quite good.