Scan barcode
_egg_wash's review against another edition
mysterious
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
2.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Bullying
Moderate: Animal death, Death of parent, Death, and Addiction
Minor: Confinement, Blood, Drug use, Grief, Kidnapping, Murder, Vomit, and Cursing
onceuponabookcase's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
Pine by Francine Toon was recommended to me by a friend for the 12 Challenge (read 12 books recommended by 12 friends in 12 months), and I was really intrigued. A mysterious woman who just disappears, a missing teenager, and a 10-year-old child for a narrator. It wasn't quite the story I expected, but I really, really enjoyed it!
Had a friend not recommended Pine to me, I don't think it's one I would have come across on my own, let alone decide to read it; reading mainly YA and fantasy, it's not a story that would be on my radar. But it was so good! Pine is very much a slow burner thriller; it's mysterious and intriguing, but in the great scheme of things, not a huge amount happens. There's the strange, silent woman, hurt and in a dirty white dressing gown who keeps appearing, that everyone seems to forget the existence of once she's out of sight, except for Lauren. There are the questions Lauren has about her mum, Christine, who is longer around. And then there's the panic and uncertainty when a teenager goes missing. Even though it's a slow burner, it's a very quick read; while it's 320 pages long, the font is quite big, and there's a lot of space in the margins, so you fly through it.
I love the way the story is told. It's a dual narration from the perspective of 10-year-old Lauren and her alcoholic dad, Niall. There are certain things that you don't discuss with or in front of children, so there are things Lauren simply doesn't know. With Niall, we have an unreliable narrator; when it comes to Lauren's mother, Christine, he simply won't talk about her, and tries not to think about her, too. All we know is she's no longer in their lives, and it's led Niall to alcoholism, which adds to his unreliability, because he forget things that happen when he's very drunk. So there are all these questions, things the adults of the village know, but we just don't get any answers. It's so well written, and I loved being with Lauren's narration; Toon has done such a great job of getting into the mind of a child, while also not making the story feel like a book for children - which it absolutely isn't. Toon also manages to create an unsettling and foreboding atmosphere with the setting. It's such a small village they live in, with just four houses and Lauren and Niall's house a bit further away, and they're right by a forest. They're not completely shut off, but there is the sense of isolation. The forest itself feels like a character, the floor carpeted in pine needles silencing everything, hiding secrets, confusing and trapping those who stray off the path. So it's not completely surprising when a woman appears out of nowhere, and seems to vanish in thin air. But with everyone forgetting her as soon as she's gone, Lauren is so confused as to what's happening, who she is, why she keeps appearing and disappearing, why people are forgetting.
Then there's the disappearance of her mother. For a long time, it's left open as to what the situation is, all Lauren knows is she's gone. But what does that mean? Did she leave? Did she die? Did she go missing? We don't know. But what we do know is that Lauren and her father are treated differently. There are looks and whispers. Lauren knows there are rumours, but she doesn't know what they are. And she's horribly bullied at school because of it. The bullying really upset me and made me cry, it's just so awful. That poor girl, who doesn't know anything, doesn't understand, and is being treated so badly. And she doesn't say anything to her dad, because he's not really there, even when he's physically in the house. I wouldn't go so far as to say she's neglected in the abusive sense, but he definitely checks out quite a lot. I just felt so sorry for her.
What I loved is how Lauren tries to keep a connection to her mum in secret. She only just remembers her, but her mum was into the occult, and read tarot and cast spells. Lauren has her book, a notebook that has obviously been passed down through generations, and added to, on witchcraft and tarot. Lauren pours over this book, and has learnt so many things. She reads tarot herself, experienced enough to be able to use playing cards when she doesn't have her own with her, and casts her own little spells. It's a way for her to feel close to her mum, but it also gives her a sense of control. She's doing something, she's trying to get answers somehow. It's also not a joke, there's no sense of Toon laughing at Lauren, a silly little girl with her fantasies, of even her mother. There is respect there, and as someone who practices, I really appreciate it, and it's inclusion.
I felt Pine ended a little abruptly; we get out answers, but we don't see much of the consequences. We get told things, but we don't see them. I would have liked there to have been a conversation between certain characters. I just wanted to know why, to have an explanation, beyond the obvious. But Pine is such a captivating story, slow and quiet, atmospheric and unsettling. I absolutely adored it! And I'm really looking forward to seeing what Toon writes next!
Had a friend not recommended Pine to me, I don't think it's one I would have come across on my own, let alone decide to read it; reading mainly YA and fantasy, it's not a story that would be on my radar. But it was so good! Pine is very much a slow burner thriller; it's mysterious and intriguing, but in the great scheme of things, not a huge amount happens. There's the strange, silent woman, hurt and in a dirty white dressing gown who keeps appearing, that everyone seems to forget the existence of once she's out of sight, except for Lauren. There are the questions Lauren has about her mum, Christine, who is longer around. And then there's the panic and uncertainty when a teenager goes missing. Even though it's a slow burner, it's a very quick read; while it's 320 pages long, the font is quite big, and there's a lot of space in the margins, so you fly through it.
I love the way the story is told. It's a dual narration from the perspective of 10-year-old Lauren and her alcoholic dad, Niall. There are certain things that you don't discuss with or in front of children, so there are things Lauren simply doesn't know. With Niall, we have an unreliable narrator; when it comes to Lauren's mother, Christine, he simply won't talk about her, and tries not to think about her, too. All we know is she's no longer in their lives, and it's led Niall to alcoholism, which adds to his unreliability, because he forget things that happen when he's very drunk. So there are all these questions, things the adults of the village know, but we just don't get any answers. It's so well written, and I loved being with Lauren's narration; Toon has done such a great job of getting into the mind of a child, while also not making the story feel like a book for children - which it absolutely isn't. Toon also manages to create an unsettling and foreboding atmosphere with the setting. It's such a small village they live in, with just four houses and Lauren and Niall's house a bit further away, and they're right by a forest. They're not completely shut off, but there is the sense of isolation. The forest itself feels like a character, the floor carpeted in pine needles silencing everything, hiding secrets, confusing and trapping those who stray off the path. So it's not completely surprising when a woman appears out of nowhere, and seems to vanish in thin air. But with everyone forgetting her as soon as she's gone, Lauren is so confused as to what's happening, who she is, why she keeps appearing and disappearing, why people are forgetting.
Then there's the disappearance of her mother. For a long time, it's left open as to what the situation is, all Lauren knows is she's gone. But what does that mean? Did she leave? Did she die? Did she go missing? We don't know. But what we do know is that Lauren and her father are treated differently. There are looks and whispers. Lauren knows there are rumours, but she doesn't know what they are. And she's horribly bullied at school because of it. The bullying really upset me and made me cry, it's just so awful. That poor girl, who doesn't know anything, doesn't understand, and is being treated so badly. And she doesn't say anything to her dad, because he's not really there, even when he's physically in the house. I wouldn't go so far as to say she's neglected in the abusive sense, but he definitely checks out quite a lot. I just felt so sorry for her.
What I loved is how Lauren tries to keep a connection to her mum in secret. She only just remembers her, but her mum was into the occult, and read tarot and cast spells. Lauren has her book, a notebook that has obviously been passed down through generations, and added to, on witchcraft and tarot. Lauren pours over this book, and has learnt so many things. She reads tarot herself, experienced enough to be able to use playing cards when she doesn't have her own with her, and casts her own little spells. It's a way for her to feel close to her mum, but it also gives her a sense of control. She's doing something, she's trying to get answers somehow. It's also not a joke, there's no sense of Toon laughing at Lauren, a silly little girl with her fantasies, of even her mother. There is respect there, and as someone who practices, I really appreciate it, and it's inclusion.
I felt Pine ended a little abruptly; we get out answers, but we don't see much of the consequences. We get told things, but we don't see them. I would have liked there to have been a conversation between certain characters. I just wanted to know why, to have an explanation, beyond the obvious. But Pine is such a captivating story, slow and quiet, atmospheric and unsettling. I absolutely adored it! And I'm really looking forward to seeing what Toon writes next!
Content Warnings
Graphic: Alcoholism and Bullying
Minor: Drug use, Vomit, and Homophobia
sheryl_macca's review
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Pine is a modern ghost story which begins on Halloween night and is set in a rural, atmospheric village in Scotland.
I'm not sure that it is actually YA but since the protagonist is an 11 year old girl it reads that way.
The plot is suspenseful and tense. It slowly builds to the resolution of the mystery which we know is coming. The end wasn't shocking, it wasn't as emotional as expected and it was wrapped up a little too quickly but I did enjoy this book.
Something about Lauren and her father Niall really resonated with me. I felt protective of Lauren, I empathised with her. Niall is essentially a good man but he is lost and lonely and his daughter Lauren isn't the priority she should be. I couldn't dislike Niall for it though. The writing of his character was really wonderful.
Atmospheric is definitely the word for Pine. This book is a mood. It's not groundbreaking but read at the right time it's perfect.
I'm not sure that it is actually YA but since the protagonist is an 11 year old girl it reads that way.
The plot is suspenseful and tense. It slowly builds to the resolution of the mystery which we know is coming. The end wasn't shocking, it wasn't as emotional as expected and it was wrapped up a little too quickly but I did enjoy this book.
Something about Lauren and her father Niall really resonated with me. I felt protective of Lauren, I empathised with her. Niall is essentially a good man but he is lost and lonely and his daughter Lauren isn't the priority she should be. I couldn't dislike Niall for it though. The writing of his character was really wonderful.
Atmospheric is definitely the word for Pine. This book is a mood. It's not groundbreaking but read at the right time it's perfect.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Alcoholism, Animal death, Blood, Bullying, Death of parent, Grief, Violence, and Vomit
Moderate: Confinement, Drug use, and Murder
More...