jonwood's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional informative reflective relaxing slow-paced

2.75

I wanted to like this book, but just did not. I found the author waxing poetically and trying to make major philosophical insights a bit too much for a science history book. Reading the acknowledgments, she made a comment about this book being her attempt to be an ultimate history on the subject, and perhaps she let that standard go to her head a bit too much writing purply prose to inflate the importance, scope of the book. I don't know, I just found many passages tedious to read. The author would frequently mention how we shouldn't speculate or project our views/bias onto Neanderthals, but it often felt like she was doing that, especially the beginning of each chapter starting with a superfluous narrative, that sounds like it was made to inflate the importance of the book. Also, I found the book confusingly organized, I get she did it by topic, but I think if it was done by site or history, it would have been easier to follow her references and remember what site, Neanderthal skeleton was which.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
More...