Scan barcode
booksthatburn's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Yumeko spends a lot of time hiding the fact that she's half kitsune, with repeated references to how she's averting her instinctual reaction of doing magic when she's in danger, and making sure to avoid reflections (e.g. water, mirrors) because her ears and tail will be visible in them. I love how Yumeko gradually collects people and decides to journey with them while Tatsumi only barely avoids constantly feeling frustrated because he has to keep from showing any emotions at all. It's a great grumpy/sunshine dynamic and I enjoyed it immensely. At first I was a bit frustrated by Tatsumi's "no emotions" routine, but gradually it becomes apparent that he isn't actually emotionless and that the Shadow Clan conditioning him to be this way is actually a combination of emotional abuse and literal torture. He carries a demon-possessed sword which will take him over if it can get a strong emotional reaction from him (and it can do some damage with even mild emotions).
The worldbuilding is gradual, with Yumeko often serving as the mouthpiece because she's excited to explain whatever now-relevant thing the monks had taught her. Having two main characters with occasional other points of view for brief stretches allows for a lot of worldbuilding conveyed through the different ways they view what's happening. Occasionally when the perspective switches there will be an overlap in the scenes to convey at least what the second narrator thought about what happened, with only minor duplications when describing the events.
A few minor characters are portrayed in frustrating ways, such as in an early incident where a canonically fat character describes a (now dead) yōkai as the only one who ever loved him. He’s then almost immediately killed. I think his size was supposed to indicate that he used his wealth to hoard resources, especially when a later section comments on how farmers often starve for at least part of each winter, but it comes across as fatphobic when combined with his lament.
The three narrators for the audiobook work well, with one narrator each for Yumeko's and Kage Tatsumi's perspectives, then the third narrator for other points of view. The plot follows their travels from one temple to another, and the battles they fight along the way. By the time they get there, several events have created a new goal for them which I assume is the subject of the next book. The overarching goal of the trilogy as previewed here is to keep anyone from using a scroll (which was split into pieces and hidden at several temples) to summon the Kami dragon. I'm very interested in where this goes next, I enjoyed the characters and the cliffhanger ending promises answers which I very much want.
The worldbuilding is gradual, with Yumeko often serving as the mouthpiece because she's excited to explain whatever now-relevant thing the monks had taught her. Having two main characters with occasional other points of view for brief stretches allows for a lot of worldbuilding conveyed through the different ways they view what's happening. Occasionally when the perspective switches there will be an overlap in the scenes to convey at least what the second narrator thought about what happened, with only minor duplications when describing the events.
A few minor characters are portrayed in frustrating ways, such as in an early incident where a canonically fat character describes a (now dead) yōkai as the only one who ever loved him. He’s then almost immediately killed. I think his size was supposed to indicate that he used his wealth to hoard resources, especially when a later section comments on how farmers often starve for at least part of each winter, but it comes across as fatphobic when combined with his lament.
The three narrators for the audiobook work well, with one narrator each for Yumeko's and Kage Tatsumi's perspectives, then the third narrator for other points of view. The plot follows their travels from one temple to another, and the battles they fight along the way. By the time they get there, several events have created a new goal for them which I assume is the subject of the next book. The overarching goal of the trilogy as previewed here is to keep anyone from using a scroll (which was split into pieces and hidden at several temples) to summon the Kami dragon. I'm very interested in where this goes next, I enjoyed the characters and the cliffhanger ending promises answers which I very much want.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Violence, Confinement, Emotional abuse, Physical abuse, Blood, Gore, and Death
Moderate: Sexism, Classism, Alcohol, Kidnapping, Body horror, and Self harm
Minor: Torture, Suicide, Body shaming, and Fatphobia
tragedies's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
funny
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
A surprisingly fun read. I first saw this in a bookstore right when it came out, skimmed bits of the first chapter, and made a mental note to get a copy of it the next time I stopped by. It slipped my mind, but I eventually stumbled upon it again while scrolling through an online shop. And my goodness, I wish I read this sooner. Possibly as soon as I picked it up from that shelf a couple years ago. The story is fascinating, and the lore even more so. There's an interesting cast of characters as well, with great dynamics and hilarious banter. It reminds me of shows like Avatar: the Last Airbender and Yona of the Dawn. I swear, I can easily imagine it as a tv series or an anime. Although the romance isn't front and center, it's there, and it certainly made my heart melt.
It's my first time reading Julie Kagawa's work, and I'm so happy I finally gave it a shot. I can't wait to see where the story goes from here.
Reread (July 10, 2022): Loved this just as much as the first time I read it, if not more. Yumeko, Tatsumi, and the rest of the gang feel like old friends, and the writing is still as beautiful and immersive as I remember it to be. I honestly can't remember why I originally rated this four stars? I love everything about it! Can't wait to reread the next one. Hopefully, I can finish it soon, so I can finally start on the last book.
It's my first time reading Julie Kagawa's work, and I'm so happy I finally gave it a shot. I can't wait to see where the story goes from here.
Reread (July 10, 2022): Loved this just as much as the first time I read it, if not more. Yumeko, Tatsumi, and the rest of the gang feel like old friends, and the writing is still as beautiful and immersive as I remember it to be. I honestly can't remember why I originally rated this four stars? I love everything about it! Can't wait to reread the next one. Hopefully, I can finish it soon, so I can finally start on the last book.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Blood, Death, Gore, Emotional abuse, and Body horror
teri_b's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
I'm still loving this first book in the Shadow of the Fox the third time I read it on audiobook from the local library.
The story is actually more gory and bloody than I perceived it previously.
But you cannot not come to love Yokemi and root for Tatsumi and little Suki. Hers is the hardest story I have come across in my reading for quite a while.
Beautiful also, how all the storylines come together by the end of the book and open up to more mysteries and the question of what happens now.
This time round I struggled with the narrator's voices. Something just did not really gel with me.
The story is actually more gory and bloody than I perceived it previously.
But you cannot not come to love Yokemi and root for Tatsumi and little Suki. Hers is the hardest story I have come across in my reading for quite a while.
Beautiful also, how all the storylines come together by the end of the book and open up to more mysteries and the question of what happens now.
This time round I struggled with the narrator's voices. Something just did not really gel with me.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Blood, Death, Gore, Emotional abuse, and Physical abuse
mind control, mental abuse, demons, blood magicmorganish's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
Okay I'm VERY biased about this book because it basically has my favorite trope/character convention, and I feel like it's a trope I rarely see in books with western sff settings unless it's done... not to my taste. So this book was a completely delightful breath of fresh air, and I'm not really able to look at it clearly through other lenses, because I'm just so happy to have found this one!
The trope I'm talking about doesn't have a consistent name that I've found, but it's essentially "character(s) who are outsiders/ostracized from their communities because of something about them which is magically/abnormally monstrous/demonic/inhuman." Bonus points if this is a part of the character's identity that they have to hide. A lot of how this is done in western fiction correlates really strongly with our ideas of race, which always gives me a bad vibe and is most often written by white people trying to explore elements of race/racism in a one-dimensional way. But my favorite stories use this in a way that, at least to me, feels like a more general metaphor for not fitting in, having any complex/dual identity, or exists as a stand-in for other things like queerness or neurodivergence rather than race.
Shadow of the Fox has not one but two main characters who fit this bill for me. Yumeko is part kitsune, and spends a lot of her life trying to balance her yokai self with being passably human. And she spends a lot of this story trying to hide her yokai heritage and abilities from others. Kage - Yumeko's unwilling partner, future love interest and the other MC - is an assassin viewed as dangerous by his clan because of the demon he has to carry as part of his role, and is kept wholly separated from other humans because of it.
Those characters alone are enough to make me like this, but there's also a sacred quest, a lot of intriguing mini-adventures, a slow-burn romance, and a surprising found-family element as they pick up companions along the way (at least one who provides a delightful amount of humor).
I watched a lot of anime in my late teens and early 20s, so there are a bunch of Japanese-inspired tropes and world-building I picked up on quickly and really enjoyed. But I'm not sure if people unfamiliar with Japanese media will recognize a lot of those tropes, or if readers who are familiar will automatically like this book. But for me, this is definitely one of my favorite books of the year, and a series I absolutely plan on continuing.
If you like Japanese-inspired fantasy, adventures with angsty murder boys, enemies-to-lovers romances, found-family dynamics, or humor juxtaposed with horror elements, this book should be fun! It doesn't have much that I can recall in the way of queer diversity, though, and the one major caveat I have about the book is that the enemies-to-lovers romance doesn't play around: Yumeko and Kage might like each other, but there's a very real element of both of them being like, "hope he doesn't murder her because she's a yokai and he's a possessed demon-slayer, lol." If that's not your thing, you might want to take a pass. In general, I'd say the best parts of the story take a while to warm up to, so this story has a lot of things I love, but it might not be as exciting for all other readers.
The trope I'm talking about doesn't have a consistent name that I've found, but it's essentially "character(s) who are outsiders/ostracized from their communities because of something about them which is magically/abnormally monstrous/demonic/inhuman." Bonus points if this is a part of the character's identity that they have to hide. A lot of how this is done in western fiction correlates really strongly with our ideas of race, which always gives me a bad vibe and is most often written by white people trying to explore elements of race/racism in a one-dimensional way. But my favorite stories use this in a way that, at least to me, feels like a more general metaphor for not fitting in, having any complex/dual identity, or exists as a stand-in for other things like queerness or neurodivergence rather than race.
Shadow of the Fox has not one but two main characters who fit this bill for me. Yumeko is part kitsune, and spends a lot of her life trying to balance her yokai self with being passably human. And she spends a lot of this story trying to hide her yokai heritage and abilities from others. Kage - Yumeko's unwilling partner, future love interest and the other MC - is an assassin viewed as dangerous by his clan because of the demon he has to carry as part of his role, and is kept wholly separated from other humans because of it.
Those characters alone are enough to make me like this, but there's also a sacred quest, a lot of intriguing mini-adventures, a slow-burn romance, and a surprising found-family element as they pick up companions along the way (at least one who provides a delightful amount of humor).
I watched a lot of anime in my late teens and early 20s, so there are a bunch of Japanese-inspired tropes and world-building I picked up on quickly and really enjoyed. But I'm not sure if people unfamiliar with Japanese media will recognize a lot of those tropes, or if readers who are familiar will automatically like this book. But for me, this is definitely one of my favorite books of the year, and a series I absolutely plan on continuing.
If you like Japanese-inspired fantasy, adventures with angsty murder boys, enemies-to-lovers romances, found-family dynamics, or humor juxtaposed with horror elements, this book should be fun! It doesn't have much that I can recall in the way of queer diversity, though, and the one major caveat I have about the book is that the enemies-to-lovers romance doesn't play around: Yumeko and Kage might like each other, but there's a very real element of both of them being like, "hope he doesn't murder her because she's a yokai and he's a possessed demon-slayer, lol." If that's not your thing, you might want to take a pass. In general, I'd say the best parts of the story take a while to warm up to, so this story has a lot of things I love, but it might not be as exciting for all other readers.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Blood, Child abuse, Death, Emotional abuse, Gore, Murder, Physical abuse, Torture, Toxic relationship, and Violence
Moderate: Confinement and Grief
Minor: Alcohol, Animal cruelty, and Body horror
Additional content warnings: *a romantic relationship where both parties are afraid that the male love interest might kill the female love interest. It's portrayed in such a way that it's based on fantastical storytelling elements instead of misogyny or IRL unhealthy relationship dynamics.
More...