Reviews with content warning for Medical content - Dead Collections

Spooky trans vampire archivist queer romance mystery written by a trans archivist! With niche archives references! Probably not for everyone but definitely exactly for this trans archivist :D

Content Warnings

anxiousnachos's review

Go to review page

mysterious slow-paced

3.0

I have mixed feelings on this one. There were moments that took my breath away; there is such a gentle, tender but unflinching portrayal of a trans masc vampire and nonbinary love interest and some of the moments these two considered their gender and identity just took my breath away in how deeply I felt: same. This novel feels like a deeply personal experience, like looking into someone’s mind, it feels like you are glimpsing the author’s trans experience, from the way they explore butchness, to the way lesbian and trans masc identities can be so entwined, to the workplace discrimination. It feels very intimate.

I thought it raised some very interesting ideas around vampirism, death and archiving. But this is unfortunately where it began to let me down because it was all just rather…shall we say it, boring? Trying to be philosophical but just losing the engagement along the way?

So I have mixed thoughts and ultimately I am settling somewhere on a mixed rating. Because whilst there are some moments of real, deep familiarity and connection, there is also a lot to swim through to reach those moments.

Content warnings: transphobia, blood, needles and other medical content, dysphoria, disability discrimination in the workplace, graphic sex, deadnaming, outing (in the workplace), vampirism as chronic illness, car accident, suicidal ideation

Content Warnings

kell_xavi's review

Go to review page

mysterious reflective slow-paced

3.0

This book made me feel weird. So much of it was similar to my reality and my writing style, and yet I found an underlying uncanniness to the whole that I don’t think was intentional. Like a photograph half-developed: there are a few typographic mistakes, continuity oddnesses (slang that seems anachronistic); there are many discussions of transness that, as a transmasc person, came across to me as both overwrought and unable to find the centre. I was bothered by the novel’s circling, looking for and reflecting on and deeply desiring substance, but only building and building a show rather than hitting on the crux. It’s so difficult to explain what I mean, this strange experience of reading.

I enjoyed, was excited about, the use of a science fiction TV show and fandom as jumping off points for the novel. I was curious about internal references and Sol’s attachment to this fictional universe; finding self in it, or looking back and seeing self not yet found, in the interaction with it. I wanted more of archival work, beyond a single personal collection of someone who so evades knowing, and is never quite a useful character or metaphor.

The novel is so often steeped in Sol’s perspective, and while we can’t name everything neurodivergence, there is a sort of autistic quality to his continued unhappiness, dissociation, distance, single-minded deep interests, loneliness, and difficulty anticipating social situation… he has a particular kind of oddness, and Fellman has a particular way of describing both his thoughts and his vampire body, that reads as autistic (but unaware of it) to someone who has ASD. The things I liked and the things that didn’t work may both be rooted in this factor (the perspective, the masking/ignorance).

I think this book will stay memorable, but right now it’s still caught, half-processed, in my mind.

Content Warnings

uranaishi's review

Go to review page

dark emotional hopeful mysterious reflective medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

Content Warnings

rorikae's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional reflective slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

'Dead Collections' by Isaac Fellman is a relatively slow and contemplative novel about death, life, identity, and belonging.
The story centers on Sol, an archivist who also happens to be a vampire. Since he can't go out in the sun, he lives and works in the basement archives of his job. When a woman donates the collection of her recently deceased wife, who just so happens to also be the writer of one of Sol's favorite sci-fi television series, the two hit it off and begin a slow but caring relationship. But Sol's collections appear to be decaying faster than they should be and Sol has to determine what is happening while also considering his own role as an archivist and a vampire.
There are so many things that I really liked about Dead Collections. I do think it is important going in to know that this story is much slower and more contemplative than the jacket copy suggests. It is much more Sol's musing on being an archivist, Sol's life as a trans man who is also a vampire, and exploring identity. The first half in particular is quite slow and I found that there wasn't any great stakes or intense plot moments. There is a light mystery, some romance, and many deep questions considered.
There are great discussions on identity between Sol and Elsie, who is considering her own gender and identity. There are also great discussions on archives and the work of an archivist. As someone who is fascinated by archives, I found this interesting but it may be a bit boring for someone who has less interest in it.
One of my favorite aspects of the book is the way the story is told. Most of the story is told through prose but there are also letter and email correspondences, forum discussions, and text messages included as well. This was a great compliment to the discussions of archives and the different pieces that Sol is sorting, which are also highlighted in spots throughout the narrative.
I did find myself highlighting quite a few quotes as Fellman does so much great work with his characters on identity, archives, and belonging. Utilizing Sol's vampirism, Fellman is able to dive further into these themes.
Even though I don't think that this book is for everyone, I do think that it will find a number of people who will love it fiercely. If you are interested in slow, contemplative novels that focus more on the characters and their discussions, like the idea of different formats used throughout the book, and have an interest in archives, I would recommend picking up 'Dead Collections.'

Content Warnings