Scan barcode
arce's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25
careinthelibrary's review against another edition
2.0
This volume was actually a bit disappointing. The cut-off period that it hits felt awkward. It contained the events of the novel that I least enjoyed. Of course, I still love the story but it just felt like a "in-between" book.
andrewl600's review against another edition
4.0
These three books were the first ever Graphic Novels I had ever read and honestly I was pleasently surprised by the whole experience.
I’ve read some manga in the past so I guess I had some experience with reading narration and speech bubbles, but I really enjoyed seeing a book and TV series I love come to life by an artist and writer’s imagination.
AND…The three graphic novels were definitely a nice break from reading the 1000+ page novels I’m so used to.
On a different note, I may be alone in thinking this but I believe that some characters from a book just can’t be portrayed on a TV or movie screen properly.
Personally I enjoy this look to Robert Baratheon much more than the one we got on the show. This look appears a bit more natural and a good mix of king and drunk fat man. The Robert we got in the show never was much more than the latter.
After looking at those panels I know what you’re thinking. WOW this artwork is really good!
Well you’re right, I’d dare to say its fantastic. Every little inch of each panel has so much detail to it. It is so beautifully made. Like look at Danaerys’ dress. It’s so perfectly drawn.
The art is done by a guy named Tommy Patterson and I really think you should look him up. He does a hell of a job.
Here’s a few more of his creations in the Graphic Novels
Look at all of the individual swords that make uo the Iron Throne. You can’t imagine that, and you sure as hell can’t show that on TV. This was one of the best moments that won me over in the books.
This quality of art and the depiction of the book series into pictures has definitely turned me on to looking at more graphic novels in the future.
Another thing about Graphic Novels that I thought of while reading these 3 is that graphic novels are the perfect middle ground for people who don’t read much, but want to read a book series of their favourite television shows.
They’re not text heavy. They can actually be read in probably a few hours only. Plus they offer really beautiful visuals that might surpass even your imagination of what things really looked like.
I know that was the case for me. Looking at the Graphic Novels actually made me imagine a few characters to be different than when I originally imagined them.
Verdict: Worth the read, especially if you’re not a regular reader but want to better understand Game of Thrones as a whole or if you want to see the beautiful depictions of the characters and the story.
Let me know in the comics what graphic novels you’re reading. I’m new to the genre, but so far I’m hooked so I’d love to start exploring some more.
I’ve read some manga in the past so I guess I had some experience with reading narration and speech bubbles, but I really enjoyed seeing a book and TV series I love come to life by an artist and writer’s imagination.
AND…The three graphic novels were definitely a nice break from reading the 1000+ page novels I’m so used to.
On a different note, I may be alone in thinking this but I believe that some characters from a book just can’t be portrayed on a TV or movie screen properly.
Personally I enjoy this look to Robert Baratheon much more than the one we got on the show. This look appears a bit more natural and a good mix of king and drunk fat man. The Robert we got in the show never was much more than the latter.
After looking at those panels I know what you’re thinking. WOW this artwork is really good!
Well you’re right, I’d dare to say its fantastic. Every little inch of each panel has so much detail to it. It is so beautifully made. Like look at Danaerys’ dress. It’s so perfectly drawn.
The art is done by a guy named Tommy Patterson and I really think you should look him up. He does a hell of a job.
Here’s a few more of his creations in the Graphic Novels
Look at all of the individual swords that make uo the Iron Throne. You can’t imagine that, and you sure as hell can’t show that on TV. This was one of the best moments that won me over in the books.
This quality of art and the depiction of the book series into pictures has definitely turned me on to looking at more graphic novels in the future.
Another thing about Graphic Novels that I thought of while reading these 3 is that graphic novels are the perfect middle ground for people who don’t read much, but want to read a book series of their favourite television shows.
They’re not text heavy. They can actually be read in probably a few hours only. Plus they offer really beautiful visuals that might surpass even your imagination of what things really looked like.
I know that was the case for me. Looking at the Graphic Novels actually made me imagine a few characters to be different than when I originally imagined them.
Verdict: Worth the read, especially if you’re not a regular reader but want to better understand Game of Thrones as a whole or if you want to see the beautiful depictions of the characters and the story.
Let me know in the comics what graphic novels you’re reading. I’m new to the genre, but so far I’m hooked so I’d love to start exploring some more.
crowyhead's review against another edition
3.0
This continues to be a workmanlike adaptation, but nothing big to write home about. This book was desperately in need of a "cast of characters" page, particularly since a lot of the character designs are so similar.
caoimhin42's review against another edition
4.0
Enjoying this version of Game of Thrones. Art is well done.
jenniofoldstones's review
adventurous
dark
emotional
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
indiepauli47's review against another edition
5.0
Third volume of the first book, as great as the first two, the illustrations as beautiful as ever. The universe of ASOIAF is perfectly depicted and the illustrator couldn't have done better.
I hate reaching this part in the story, cause the decisions of a few characters change the entire course of the story. And this is happening now. For the worst unfortunately.
I hate reaching this part in the story, cause the decisions of a few characters change the entire course of the story. And this is happening now. For the worst unfortunately.