Scan barcode
cec_loves_to_read_books's review
4.0
When we finished What Snail Knows, by Kathryn Apel, I asked Mr 7 if he liked it, his response was, ‘Yes, it was really good, I liked it, quite a lot actually, it was very good.’ I probably don’t really need to add anything to that endorsement but I will!
My small person and I read this book over a series of nights as our bedtime reading. One chapter a night to enable him to get used to the verse novel format and also manage the feelings that came with reading this…it’s a sad story to begin with about loneliness, isolation and grief. At times I didn’t think he’d stick with it as he was a little worried in places and clearly uncomfortable with the content (he’s a sensitive little soul and worries about things - even fictional characters - deeply). But, he stuck with it and I’m so glad he/we did.
This little book gently tells a tale of the love between a father and daughter and in doing so also touches on environmental issues, poverty and the need for everyone to have friendship and community. It’s a super sweet story about finding your place.
As an introduction into verse novels and an age appropriate story about environmental action and community building this book is a clear winner. The illustrations are gorgeous and it lends itself to so much discussion (for parents and teachers) and extension activities (for teachers).
Highly, highly recommended.
My small person and I read this book over a series of nights as our bedtime reading. One chapter a night to enable him to get used to the verse novel format and also manage the feelings that came with reading this…it’s a sad story to begin with about loneliness, isolation and grief. At times I didn’t think he’d stick with it as he was a little worried in places and clearly uncomfortable with the content (he’s a sensitive little soul and worries about things - even fictional characters - deeply). But, he stuck with it and I’m so glad he/we did.
This little book gently tells a tale of the love between a father and daughter and in doing so also touches on environmental issues, poverty and the need for everyone to have friendship and community. It’s a super sweet story about finding your place.
As an introduction into verse novels and an age appropriate story about environmental action and community building this book is a clear winner. The illustrations are gorgeous and it lends itself to so much discussion (for parents and teachers) and extension activities (for teachers).
Highly, highly recommended.
lawbooks600's review
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Representation: Side Asian character
Score: Seven points out of ten.
I found out that one of the two libraries I go to still had verse novels up their sleeve like this one and after reading some I thought sometimes they were a hit and other times they were a miss. Not long after I picked it up and read it, and when I finished it swiftly I felt it had a great execution making it stand out from other novels like this I've read. It starts with the main character Lucy (This is the fourth character with that name I saw this year. Coincidence? Probably.) whose last name I don't know who recently moved to a new place (presumably somewhere in Australia) with her father. Lucy transfers to a new school (who knows how many schools she went to before leaving since her father moves a lot?) but this time she wants to stay because of all the new characters. I noticed a few titbits about the narrative which I didn't mind (I only found them intriguing.)
The story said Lucy is in Year Two (the Australian equivalent of second grade because school works differently here) which means that she'd be seven or eight. With that out of the way Lucy tries to convince her father to stay here and initially he wants to move again to someplace else but I don't know why until much later on. The other integral part revolves around a snail called Snail (Out of all the names in the world the snail is called Snail. Really?) Snail is a side character which I enjoyed reading but wasn't significant but some references to snails are in the writing style and even some poems are in the shapes of snails and hearts which I don't see that often but good for me I suppose. There's also a plot point about cane toads and killing them with 'kindness' as they are an invasive species (which is true.) There is a revelation where the father says Lucy's mother died from an illness and he could never fully move on from that but in the end he decides to stay ending the narrative on a high note.
Score: Seven points out of ten.
I found out that one of the two libraries I go to still had verse novels up their sleeve like this one and after reading some I thought sometimes they were a hit and other times they were a miss. Not long after I picked it up and read it, and when I finished it swiftly I felt it had a great execution making it stand out from other novels like this I've read. It starts with the main character Lucy (This is the fourth character with that name I saw this year. Coincidence? Probably.) whose last name I don't know who recently moved to a new place (presumably somewhere in Australia) with her father. Lucy transfers to a new school (who knows how many schools she went to before leaving since her father moves a lot?) but this time she wants to stay because of all the new characters. I noticed a few titbits about the narrative which I didn't mind (I only found them intriguing.)
The story said Lucy is in Year Two (the Australian equivalent of second grade because school works differently here) which means that she'd be seven or eight. With that out of the way Lucy tries to convince her father to stay here and initially he wants to move again to someplace else but I don't know why until much later on. The other integral part revolves around a snail called Snail (Out of all the names in the world the snail is called Snail. Really?) Snail is a side character which I enjoyed reading but wasn't significant but some references to snails are in the writing style and even some poems are in the shapes of snails and hearts which I don't see that often but good for me I suppose. There's also a plot point about cane toads and killing them with 'kindness' as they are an invasive species (which is true.) There is a revelation where the father says Lucy's mother died from an illness and he could never fully move on from that but in the end he decides to stay ending the narrative on a high note.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Terminal illness, Injury/Injury detail, and Death
Full trigger warnings: Hospitalisation, physical injury, death of a mother in the past from an illness
More...