Scan barcode
tankiestein's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
3.5
There were few stories in here that were an absolute vibe. Stag was immaculate, I still think about it.
Great sampling dish of different horror authors to check out.
Great sampling dish of different horror authors to check out.
weirdtea's review against another edition
3.0
3.5
Overall, this is a pretty damned decent collection of short stories. I’m pleased I stumbled across it.
I loved the theme of lost films—it’s got so much potential and so many different directions to go in. I gotta give credit to a collection that brings inspiration along with it. The stories vary enough in levels of horror and weird that the balance is quite satisfying.
As with most collections, there are hits and misses—and those are going to vary from reader to reader. There were one or two that I was ultimately neutral about. One I thought was weak mostly because it relied on lazy stereotypes (automatic deduction for butterball as descriptor) and didn’t really hang together. A couple I don’t really remember.
My favorites:
Gemma Files’ “The Church in the Mountains” for character, atmosphere, and tension. Cool use of the theme.
“Elephants That Aren’t” by Betty Rocksteady. Wonderfully weird and unsettling with a great hook for the main character. Extra points for the illustration!
“Things She Left in the Woods” by Jessica McHugh kept me reading.
“The Fantastic Flying Eraser Heads” by David James Keaton got off to a slow start. It’s worth getting through the beginning because once it gets rolling it’s really satisfying. There are some excellent ideas and I enjoyed seeing them play out. Also, as a former video store clerk I have to applaud.
Bonus: The Introduction by Max Booth III was particularly well done.
Overall, this is a pretty damned decent collection of short stories. I’m pleased I stumbled across it.
I loved the theme of lost films—it’s got so much potential and so many different directions to go in. I gotta give credit to a collection that brings inspiration along with it. The stories vary enough in levels of horror and weird that the balance is quite satisfying.
As with most collections, there are hits and misses—and those are going to vary from reader to reader. There were one or two that I was ultimately neutral about. One I thought was weak mostly because it relied on lazy stereotypes (automatic deduction for butterball as descriptor) and didn’t really hang together. A couple I don’t really remember.
My favorites:
Gemma Files’ “The Church in the Mountains” for character, atmosphere, and tension. Cool use of the theme.
“Elephants That Aren’t” by Betty Rocksteady. Wonderfully weird and unsettling with a great hook for the main character. Extra points for the illustration!
“Things She Left in the Woods” by Jessica McHugh kept me reading.
“The Fantastic Flying Eraser Heads” by David James Keaton got off to a slow start. It’s worth getting through the beginning because once it gets rolling it’s really satisfying. There are some excellent ideas and I enjoyed seeing them play out. Also, as a former video store clerk I have to applaud.
Bonus: The Introduction by Max Booth III was particularly well done.
mercwolfmoor's review against another edition
4.0
A great anthology about haunted media. The stories compliment each other nicely, and there is a wide range of tone and style and what constitutes "lost film" -- if you like creepy and haunted films, videos, VHS tapes, streaming and more, you will probably enjoy a bunch of the stories in here.
(I posted some thoughts on individual stories in a twitter thread: https://twitter.com/Merc_Wolfmoor/status/1210297223575212032 )
(I posted some thoughts on individual stories in a twitter thread: https://twitter.com/Merc_Wolfmoor/status/1210297223575212032 )
More...