Scan barcode
daftstephi's review against another edition
4.0
I loved the copious amount of notes that tie philosophy to Battlestar Gallactica.
I cannot pin point particular favorite chapters because the whole book had surprises for me but also affirmations of philosophic thoughts that I had about BSG. I think it's a great read for fans of BSG who notice and contemplate the philosophic, political, spiritual connections in the show.
I cannot pin point particular favorite chapters because the whole book had surprises for me but also affirmations of philosophic thoughts that I had about BSG. I think it's a great read for fans of BSG who notice and contemplate the philosophic, political, spiritual connections in the show.
wayhaught_n7's review
5.0
I've read several of the books in the Philosophy and Pop Culture Series and I have to say this is the best one so far. It may be because I'm a major Battlestar Galactica fan but I'd like to think this is the best one because of the subject matter of the show. The show has a tendency to make me agree with actions that I would have never thought I'd support and this book has done the same. It made me rethink a lot of philosophical topics in a way even The Matrix book in this series didn't.
I'd highly recommend this to any Battlestar fan because you will not look at the show in quite the same way again, but I'd especially recommend it to those Battlestar fans who love philosophy.
I'd highly recommend this to any Battlestar fan because you will not look at the show in quite the same way again, but I'd especially recommend it to those Battlestar fans who love philosophy.
pavonini's review
3.0
I really liked the idea behind it. Each chapter was written by a different person with a different approach, and the quality was variable. I found it was sometimes quite repetitive, dealing with the same moments over and over but never getting very in depth (into either BSG or philosophical concepts). I feel like it could have benefitted from better editing.
Honestly I would have been happy with "Gaius Baltar and Philosophy" as he could merit a book all on his own, or perhaps one on their leadership and its consequences.
This is not a bad book but it also didn't wow me overall. It's quite specific so I wouldn't recommend it to everyone. For me it was a worthwhile read.
Honestly I would have been happy with "Gaius Baltar and Philosophy" as he could merit a book all on his own, or perhaps one on their leadership and its consequences.
This is not a bad book but it also didn't wow me overall. It's quite specific so I wouldn't recommend it to everyone. For me it was a worthwhile read.
More...