You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

4.32 AVERAGE

mindoflex's review

3.5
dark emotional informative slow-paced

Chang’s memoir provides a detailed account of three generations living in 20th-century China, focusing on Mao’s rule while also exploring earlier periods like the Japanese occupation and the rise of the Communist Party. She uses straightforward language, which makes the text accessible to readers with little to no knowledge of modern Chinese history. Some chapters are dense with detail, which may appeal to those deeply interested in or studying the topic, but can test the patience of casual readers.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

If I could give this book 6 stars, I would. This book is beautifully written, and the subject matter is fascinating, terrifying, and inspiring. I wish I had read this before I went to China.

Fascinating account of China under Chairman Mao. Partly page Turner, partly a slog (depending on the chapter)

Required reading!!
challenging reflective sad slow-paced

Fue un libro un tanto difícil de leer por el tema.
Lo que mas me impresionó fue la el grado tan grande de resiliencia de las mujeres de esa familia y la convicción de los papás por el comunismo.
Sufrí al leer todo lo del salto adelante y ni se diga sobre la Revolución Cultural.
Admiro mucho a la abuela y la admiro como admiro a mi propia abuela, todo lo que son capaces de hacer por apoyar a los hijos y no abandonar a los nietos.
Admiro a la mamá por nunca darle la espalda al marido a pesar de su testarudez, de su fuerza de voluntad y de que nunca disminuyo su energía para lograr un ambiente familiar sano sin importar lo que ella sufriera.
challenging dark informative sad tense medium-paced

This was definitely not a fast book, but I really loved the transition from one generation to the next with a great feel for both the time periods and the culture of each woman.

Toch wel weer een indrukwekkend boek om na 25 jaar nog eens te lezen. Een boek dat eerder op mij grote indruk maakte. Nu stoort de schrijfstijl me enigszins, het is geen mooie literatuur. Dat vind ik vaker een probleem bij biografieën, net als de opsomming van levensgebeurtenissen, data, anekdotes etc. Sommige delen ging ik snel scannend door, maar dit boek heeft mij (eerst als middelbare scholier en nu een eindje verder in het leven) een goede inkijk in de verschrikkingen van een totalitair regime gegeven.
challenging dark emotional reflective sad medium-paced

A powerful family biography, looking at China in the 19th century from a "Ground view"

The first 50 pages of this book are extremely gripping, after this, there definitely are slower parts where it can drag a bit, and it's hard to keep track of all of the names, but the story remains compelling throughout.

It's incredible, how much cruelty this family managed to survive. I would have liked an extra chapter or two at the end detailing her transition to the west, especially as it's been built up during the book.