Scan barcode
sinkitten's review against another edition
5.0
Something always happening but not in a way where it feels forced. A constant motion and a journey not just fluff and then a destination.
Going into the series I wasn't all that sure what to expect. The first 2 books were certainly enjoyable with some common themes that managed to feel not over done and terribly cliche. This book however, is even better than the first 2 and I enjoyed it immensely. A not so fairy tale series with not so perfect or clear cut characters. The book/series has certainly left me feeling the way it was designed to, and I'm glad for a book that makes me give pause during and after reading it.
Going into the series I wasn't all that sure what to expect. The first 2 books were certainly enjoyable with some common themes that managed to feel not over done and terribly cliche. This book however, is even better than the first 2 and I enjoyed it immensely. A not so fairy tale series with not so perfect or clear cut characters. The book/series has certainly left me feeling the way it was designed to, and I'm glad for a book that makes me give pause during and after reading it.
winnerswayy's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.75
ceuran's review against another edition
2.0
2.5*
The book is written very well, and while I did really enjoy the first and second book in this series I think I simply waited too long before I picked this one up. I just didn't really care about the characters or the plot of the story anymore. I had a hard time remembering what all of the terminology was for this series and was often detached from the story/confused by it as a result.
On the plus side, here's another series on my shelf that I have finished!! :)
The book is written very well, and while I did really enjoy the first and second book in this series I think I simply waited too long before I picked this one up. I just didn't really care about the characters or the plot of the story anymore. I had a hard time remembering what all of the terminology was for this series and was often detached from the story/confused by it as a result.
On the plus side, here's another series on my shelf that I have finished!! :)
ahoipanem's review against another edition
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
keeganrb's review against another edition
adventurous
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
Content Warnings
Moderate: Death
schin's review against another edition
3.0
I have absolutely adored this series, because it totally brings out the importance of family and especially sisterhood(or in others' case brotherhood). I love the plot, but I find that it cannot really wow me. But still, good book.
angelcwrites's review against another edition
4.0
Discovery: I first read Prophecy of the Sisters, the first book in this trilogy, a few months ago. Despite the creepy twin statues on the cover–Doctor Who has ruined me for life–I sped through the novel and bawled for ten minutes straight at the end. I’m glad I discovered these books only a few months away from the conclusion.
+ Themes. I may have cried buckets over Prophecy of the Sisters and shed some tears over the ending to this one, but I’m grateful that Michelle Zink had the courage to be true to the story. These books took a bond touted as unbreakable–that of sisters–and illustrated just how easy it is to warp love. Fate and destiny come to blows with the indomitable human spirit. Lia is a strong girl, but even she must find the strength to do the right thing, especially when faced with a sister for an enemy. That struggle can be found in countless stories and events throughout history, and Michelle Zink did a commendable job of writing it into this series.
+ Mythology. Ever since I was a little girl, I’ve had an unwavering fascination with mythology. As crazy as it may sound, the legends surrounding Satan and the fallen angels have always held appeal to me. This series fed my interest and I’m quite satisfied with the result. Lia’s dreams scared me more than Samael–who wouldn’t be terrified if they were controlled by a dream? I loved the way Altus and its people were portrayed and I appreciated the flaws they displayed. Myths come from a place in the human heart that yearns for truth and creativity at the same time, and the results are beautifully broken tales which reflect their creators. It’s in the interpretation that they become more than what they are cast as, something we would all do well to remember.
+ Characters. I’ll admit it: Dimitri stole my heart. I have a well-documented weakness for male characters who are devoted and true to the right cause and he just pushed all my buttons repeatedly. Not to mention, he’s really really hot. (I’ll try to keep that fangirling to a minimum.) But while I adored Dimitri, my heart aches for James. I do think that he got the short end of the stick and part of me has issues with how his story was resolved because it just seemed too abrupt. He did nothing wrong, and deserved far more than what Lia and Alice gave him.
The focus of the story is on the Milthorpe sisters, of course, and Lia and Alice are both luminous in this final installment. Lia embodies the depths of weakness that the human spirit can sink too just as strongly as she does our strengths. I loved that she didn’t pretend to be more than what she was: a young girl caught in the middle of something she doesn’t really understand either. Alice’s decisions seem strange at times, but I do believe that the ending is satisfying, albeit heartbreaking. I admire both sisters and their hearts.
- Pacing. If I’d had time to write reviews for Prophecy and Guardian of the Gate, I would have already mentioned this. The novels are very well-written, but there are a few chapters in each book where the action seems to slow to a crawl. I personally attribute this to the author helping the reader to step into Lia’s shoes as she seeks to end the prophecy. Nevertheless, it does make reading a little difficult when one’s attention isn’t fully focused.
Recommendations: I would definitely recommend this to any YA reader, and adults as well. The Prophecy series is a fantastic and delicate journey into the human heart and its capacity for love.
Rating: Excellent.
+ Themes. I may have cried buckets over Prophecy of the Sisters and shed some tears over the ending to this one, but I’m grateful that Michelle Zink had the courage to be true to the story. These books took a bond touted as unbreakable–that of sisters–and illustrated just how easy it is to warp love. Fate and destiny come to blows with the indomitable human spirit. Lia is a strong girl, but even she must find the strength to do the right thing, especially when faced with a sister for an enemy. That struggle can be found in countless stories and events throughout history, and Michelle Zink did a commendable job of writing it into this series.
+ Mythology. Ever since I was a little girl, I’ve had an unwavering fascination with mythology. As crazy as it may sound, the legends surrounding Satan and the fallen angels have always held appeal to me. This series fed my interest and I’m quite satisfied with the result. Lia’s dreams scared me more than Samael–who wouldn’t be terrified if they were controlled by a dream? I loved the way Altus and its people were portrayed and I appreciated the flaws they displayed. Myths come from a place in the human heart that yearns for truth and creativity at the same time, and the results are beautifully broken tales which reflect their creators. It’s in the interpretation that they become more than what they are cast as, something we would all do well to remember.
+ Characters. I’ll admit it: Dimitri stole my heart. I have a well-documented weakness for male characters who are devoted and true to the right cause and he just pushed all my buttons repeatedly. Not to mention, he’s really really hot. (I’ll try to keep that fangirling to a minimum.) But while I adored Dimitri, my heart aches for James. I do think that he got the short end of the stick and part of me has issues with how his story was resolved because it just seemed too abrupt. He did nothing wrong, and deserved far more than what Lia and Alice gave him.
The focus of the story is on the Milthorpe sisters, of course, and Lia and Alice are both luminous in this final installment. Lia embodies the depths of weakness that the human spirit can sink too just as strongly as she does our strengths. I loved that she didn’t pretend to be more than what she was: a young girl caught in the middle of something she doesn’t really understand either. Alice’s decisions seem strange at times, but I do believe that the ending is satisfying, albeit heartbreaking. I admire both sisters and their hearts.
- Pacing. If I’d had time to write reviews for Prophecy and Guardian of the Gate, I would have already mentioned this. The novels are very well-written, but there are a few chapters in each book where the action seems to slow to a crawl. I personally attribute this to the author helping the reader to step into Lia’s shoes as she seeks to end the prophecy. Nevertheless, it does make reading a little difficult when one’s attention isn’t fully focused.
Recommendations: I would definitely recommend this to any YA reader, and adults as well. The Prophecy series is a fantastic and delicate journey into the human heart and its capacity for love.
Rating: Excellent.
kriti4309e's review against another edition
2.0
Okay the conclusion of this story was well ummm interesting. I have realized something though. Lia absolutely bores me and I just find her extremely bland! Dimitri is marble statue of perfect! To be honest Lucia was my favorite character in this entire trilogy. I didn't think this novel was awful per say. It was just underwhelming.
celbl8o's review against another edition
5.0
One of my all time favorite finales to a series! Total tearjerker... I cried for hours at the end when they're standing around Alice's grave.