Scan barcode
bookworm_oakey's review against another edition
2.0
I really wanted to love this novel but I think I thought it was going to be something it wasn't. After waltzing my way through books like The Night Circus and Caraval I was hoping for a similar vein .... But this book touched on much darker topics. This story will definitely appeal to some but didn't quite float my boat
mazza57's review against another edition
1.0
I received an ARC of this book via Netgalley. The title is totally misleading suggesting to me some fantastical or creative celebration. Marked as "Fantasy" and "Books about Books" it does not really fulfill the criteria for either of those genres. For me it felt to have both a feeling of horror and a twisted erotica. Horror I don't really mind and, although this was at times very dark, it did not make me want to stop reading. The erotica carried through the storyline of ink maids was a different thing.
This is quite a lengthy book which, in my opinion, introduces many facets that could grasp the reader's imagination but fails to carry any of them through to completion. It has a disconnection to it and reminds me of someone trying to get every idea they ever thought of into a book that has little relation to the majority of those thoughts. I found it hard to really like any of the characters.
The ending suggests to me that something might spring from the ashes of this carnival into a second book, I would not be tempted to read it
This is quite a lengthy book which, in my opinion, introduces many facets that could grasp the reader's imagination but fails to carry any of them through to completion. It has a disconnection to it and reminds me of someone trying to get every idea they ever thought of into a book that has little relation to the majority of those thoughts. I found it hard to really like any of the characters.
The ending suggests to me that something might spring from the ashes of this carnival into a second book, I would not be tempted to read it
annarella's review against another edition
4.0
Something in this book made me think about Italian romantic story of the XIX century. Poets, words, a city that could be in Italy.
I liked the style of writing and liked the characters, the different stanzas were an interesting literary artifice but I was sometimes confused by the variety of characters.
All in all I liked this book.
Recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine
I liked the style of writing and liked the characters, the different stanzas were an interesting literary artifice but I was sometimes confused by the variety of characters.
All in all I liked this book.
Recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine
openmypages's review against another edition
2.0
"As a rule, the abbot said as little as possible. He treated every word as though they were a personal gift from God himself, only parting with them with extreme reluctance."
----------------------
I was really on the struggle bus with this one. The concept is so intriguing, a city in Italy that rivals Venice's art scene but with words. Poetry is everything. The politics, the religion, the day in and day out interactions are all about elevating, adoring and creating poetry. The idea and the writing are immensely beautiful. The plot and the arrangement just were very confusing to follow. There are so many characters and our POV changes so many times that by the time we settle with a character, the story has moved on and we don't get back to them fast enough for me to have remembered the details of their story.
I'm hoping I can revisit this one another time and perhaps it will all click for me. It's the first book I've read in a while that I wasn't sure if it was me or the writing that was the issue.
Thanks to Netgalley for access to an advanced copy. All opinions above are my own.
----------------------
I was really on the struggle bus with this one. The concept is so intriguing, a city in Italy that rivals Venice's art scene but with words. Poetry is everything. The politics, the religion, the day in and day out interactions are all about elevating, adoring and creating poetry. The idea and the writing are immensely beautiful. The plot and the arrangement just were very confusing to follow. There are so many characters and our POV changes so many times that by the time we settle with a character, the story has moved on and we don't get back to them fast enough for me to have remembered the details of their story.
I'm hoping I can revisit this one another time and perhaps it will all click for me. It's the first book I've read in a while that I wasn't sure if it was me or the writing that was the issue.
Thanks to Netgalley for access to an advanced copy. All opinions above are my own.
powder_and_page's review against another edition
2.0
DNF at ~30%
Lovely setting and extravagant prose.
Somewhat misleading synopsis/branding as fantasy. It's definitely more of an alternate history with a fictional Italian city populated by pompous poets. Ultimately, I thought it was boring.
Lovely setting and extravagant prose.
Somewhat misleading synopsis/branding as fantasy. It's definitely more of an alternate history with a fictional Italian city populated by pompous poets. Ultimately, I thought it was boring.
janettedv's review against another edition
3.0
This is a really tricky book to review. I was hooked on the initial idea of an Italian city where poets rule and the written word is king but it didn’t quite live up to its promise.
The book is told from multiple points of view. Each canto tells the story of a different character in the city, many of whose lives intercept at different points. As always with this method of story telling, there are some stories that you feel more invested in than others. The author’s writing style is gorgeous and the city and its inhabitants really come alive. However, sometimes, this can be almost a problem as there are one or two very dark chapters and I could have done with slightly less detail in these.
I loved parts of this book and disliked others in almost equal measure. However, I was drawn through the story as we see the gradual collapse of the city of Cadenza.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book.
The book is told from multiple points of view. Each canto tells the story of a different character in the city, many of whose lives intercept at different points. As always with this method of story telling, there are some stories that you feel more invested in than others. The author’s writing style is gorgeous and the city and its inhabitants really come alive. However, sometimes, this can be almost a problem as there are one or two very dark chapters and I could have done with slightly less detail in these.
I loved parts of this book and disliked others in almost equal measure. However, I was drawn through the story as we see the gradual collapse of the city of Cadenza.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book.
darladark's review against another edition
3.0
I was given an advance reading copy by the publisher for an honest review.
I did not enjoy this novel at all. I liked the description and was excited to read it but the style of writing and the storyline were utterly confusing.
I did not enjoy this novel at all. I liked the description and was excited to read it but the style of writing and the storyline were utterly confusing.
timemm's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.25
karireads's review against another edition
This is a very peculiar novel and not at all what I was expecting. Tried to get into it, but it just wasn't what I wanted.
readtoramble's review against another edition
4.0
4.5 STARS
I read this book for a blog tour, so thank you to the blog tour organiser for having me on this tour. And thank you to the author and the publisher for providing me with a free copy of the book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Trigger warnings: violence, death, murder, betrayal, treachery, gore/body horror, blood, suicide/suicidal thoughts, torture, sexual violence and abuse/rape, ableism, sexism, medical content, misogyny, drunkness. (Please let me know in th comments if I have missed any).
The Carnival of Ash by Tom Beckerlegge is described on Goodreads and other sites as fantasy, but from reading it and from the other reviews on this tour, I think it’s fair to say this is definitely more of a lyrical historical fiction with some fantasy and theatrical elements, which is perfectly fine by me, but maybe confused some people as they were expecting full-on fantasy, as was I.
I think the main thing I have to say about this book before I can describe it in more detail and give you my thoughts is that it is HELLA violent, gory, descriptive and definitely, 100% NOT for the faint of heart. If you are even slightly squeamish about any of the trigger warnings I have mentioned above, I would not read this book if I were you. The violence, gore, etc, go hand in hand with the style and prose of the book, I don’t think any of it is gratuitous, at least not in my opinion. I am not bothered by any of these elements in the least because I can put it into perspective with the kind of book it is. It is just something to keep in mind. It is set in Cadenza, a kind of imaginary city in which so many awful things happen, in a type of Renaissance setting. If any of you are into history, you’ll know that this period was quite gory, violent and there was a lot of blood-lust and sexual violence, to only name a few. This book really fits into this time frame, genre and style, so just be aware of these things before jumping into the book as I know a few bloggers on the tour had quite the surprise. It is a dark book, it is violent, it is gory, it is quite long and it is sometimes a bit confusing, but overall, it is a unique and lyrical tale that I think works thoroughly well.
This is also a very vivid and vividly described setting/city. I could literally feel the place jumping off the page at me, it felt so real, so palpable. The author, Tom Beckerlegge has an AMAZING way with words, and so many sentences were just breathtaking. The author has created such a fascinating and fantastical “fake” city in Italy, it feels so real though. At first, I have to admit that I found the Cantos a little confusing as I was expecting the characters to come back and maybe meet, and they don’t really, although it does do a sort of loop toward the end where all the strings are finally woven together to give a grand view of Cadenza, the characters and the whole plot. Once I got over the desire to see all the characters again, I got swept up in the lyrical and magical feel of this book and I was so immersed in every Canto, every character, their feelings, their thoughts and what happens to them. I felt like a really long series put into one big book, although I never found it clunky, heavy or drawn-out, which I think shows just how wonderful and clever this world is. I never found it info-dumpy, it’s just not. It is extremely well-written and just flows so well.
And now, to talk about the atmosphere, a.k.a, my favourite part of a book. WOW, this story has Atmosphere with a capital a. This is a very sinister book and I could really feel how as the book went along and the different stories unfurled, it was getting progressively darker. I mean, the things that happen in this book as just crazy and the author did such a good job on the atmosphere but also on the writing which is just beautiful while the plot is despicable and atrocious. I don’t think I’m selling this book very well, but I think the people who dig these vibes will definitely know what I’m talking about and want to jump on the chance to read this book, it is 100% worth it.
The writing style is really what took my breath away, and also one of the reasons I can’t get all my thoughts in order. It was just stunning and I definitely had to take my time with it because it deserved to be read slowly and digested. I don’t personally think it is a book you can binge read unless it’s a reread. The first time around when you have no idea what is happening, the characters involved and the plot unfolding, it’s just too complex and insane to wrap your head around it. I do really look forward to picking this up for a second time. Maybe in winter as I think the darkness and sinister aspect of the story would really make a perfect dark winter night read in front of a fire. I want to go back to this city, I want to feel Cadenza envelop me in its ominous setting, its vile characters and its unforgettable descent into mayhem and destruction.
I gave this book 4.5 stars and I found it to be just a fantastic read that had me immersed and fascinated throughout. It’s all woven together seamlessly and even if you really don’t “get it”, just let yourself go along with it and enjoy it for what it is. A mix of tales and characters all living and going about their daily lives in Cadenza, to the backdrop of dramatics, commedia dell’arte, debauchery, the Renaissance and most importantly, poets trying to find their way, their voice and their art in a city built on words. It sounds far-fetched and crazy, and I have to admit that it is, but it is also wonderful.
If you are a fan of the commedia dell’arte feel with all the elements I have mentioned above, a sweeping tale of multiple stories and characters, a beautiful city which is described in the most lyrical and magical way, and above all a beautifully written and sinister plot, this is the book for you. I 100% recommend it, just make sure to check out the trigger warnings first as it is dark and daunting from the very first page.
I read this book for a blog tour, so thank you to the blog tour organiser for having me on this tour. And thank you to the author and the publisher for providing me with a free copy of the book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Trigger warnings: violence, death, murder, betrayal, treachery, gore/body horror, blood, suicide/suicidal thoughts, torture, sexual violence and abuse/rape, ableism, sexism, medical content, misogyny, drunkness. (Please let me know in th comments if I have missed any).
The Carnival of Ash by Tom Beckerlegge is described on Goodreads and other sites as fantasy, but from reading it and from the other reviews on this tour, I think it’s fair to say this is definitely more of a lyrical historical fiction with some fantasy and theatrical elements, which is perfectly fine by me, but maybe confused some people as they were expecting full-on fantasy, as was I.
I think the main thing I have to say about this book before I can describe it in more detail and give you my thoughts is that it is HELLA violent, gory, descriptive and definitely, 100% NOT for the faint of heart. If you are even slightly squeamish about any of the trigger warnings I have mentioned above, I would not read this book if I were you. The violence, gore, etc, go hand in hand with the style and prose of the book, I don’t think any of it is gratuitous, at least not in my opinion. I am not bothered by any of these elements in the least because I can put it into perspective with the kind of book it is. It is just something to keep in mind. It is set in Cadenza, a kind of imaginary city in which so many awful things happen, in a type of Renaissance setting. If any of you are into history, you’ll know that this period was quite gory, violent and there was a lot of blood-lust and sexual violence, to only name a few. This book really fits into this time frame, genre and style, so just be aware of these things before jumping into the book as I know a few bloggers on the tour had quite the surprise. It is a dark book, it is violent, it is gory, it is quite long and it is sometimes a bit confusing, but overall, it is a unique and lyrical tale that I think works thoroughly well.
This is also a very vivid and vividly described setting/city. I could literally feel the place jumping off the page at me, it felt so real, so palpable. The author, Tom Beckerlegge has an AMAZING way with words, and so many sentences were just breathtaking. The author has created such a fascinating and fantastical “fake” city in Italy, it feels so real though. At first, I have to admit that I found the Cantos a little confusing as I was expecting the characters to come back and maybe meet, and they don’t really, although it does do a sort of loop toward the end where all the strings are finally woven together to give a grand view of Cadenza, the characters and the whole plot. Once I got over the desire to see all the characters again, I got swept up in the lyrical and magical feel of this book and I was so immersed in every Canto, every character, their feelings, their thoughts and what happens to them. I felt like a really long series put into one big book, although I never found it clunky, heavy or drawn-out, which I think shows just how wonderful and clever this world is. I never found it info-dumpy, it’s just not. It is extremely well-written and just flows so well.
And now, to talk about the atmosphere, a.k.a, my favourite part of a book. WOW, this story has Atmosphere with a capital a. This is a very sinister book and I could really feel how as the book went along and the different stories unfurled, it was getting progressively darker. I mean, the things that happen in this book as just crazy and the author did such a good job on the atmosphere but also on the writing which is just beautiful while the plot is despicable and atrocious. I don’t think I’m selling this book very well, but I think the people who dig these vibes will definitely know what I’m talking about and want to jump on the chance to read this book, it is 100% worth it.
The writing style is really what took my breath away, and also one of the reasons I can’t get all my thoughts in order. It was just stunning and I definitely had to take my time with it because it deserved to be read slowly and digested. I don’t personally think it is a book you can binge read unless it’s a reread. The first time around when you have no idea what is happening, the characters involved and the plot unfolding, it’s just too complex and insane to wrap your head around it. I do really look forward to picking this up for a second time. Maybe in winter as I think the darkness and sinister aspect of the story would really make a perfect dark winter night read in front of a fire. I want to go back to this city, I want to feel Cadenza envelop me in its ominous setting, its vile characters and its unforgettable descent into mayhem and destruction.
I gave this book 4.5 stars and I found it to be just a fantastic read that had me immersed and fascinated throughout. It’s all woven together seamlessly and even if you really don’t “get it”, just let yourself go along with it and enjoy it for what it is. A mix of tales and characters all living and going about their daily lives in Cadenza, to the backdrop of dramatics, commedia dell’arte, debauchery, the Renaissance and most importantly, poets trying to find their way, their voice and their art in a city built on words. It sounds far-fetched and crazy, and I have to admit that it is, but it is also wonderful.
If you are a fan of the commedia dell’arte feel with all the elements I have mentioned above, a sweeping tale of multiple stories and characters, a beautiful city which is described in the most lyrical and magical way, and above all a beautifully written and sinister plot, this is the book for you. I 100% recommend it, just make sure to check out the trigger warnings first as it is dark and daunting from the very first page.