Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.36 AVERAGE
3.36 AVERAGE
3.5 stars. "The Smart One" is the first book that I've read by Jennifer Close. It's easy to see why her books have been so successful thus far. It's a story about a family where each member of the family seems to be dealing with something vastly different. It's about coping and how even with so much wrong, a good family can always help you out.
I love family stories. Between the writing and the family story, both really kept me reading. I had a hard time connecting with any of the characters really but they were definitely interesting to read about!
I love family stories. Between the writing and the family story, both really kept me reading. I had a hard time connecting with any of the characters really but they were definitely interesting to read about!
Finished this up a few days ago. Overall, an okay book, 3 stars, but with a really good audiobook (4.5 stars). It was largely character-driven as opposed to plot, which I liked. I think getting the perspective of the four women, seeing their major and minor life changes were affecting them and those around them, was interesting. There were some moments that I didn't like, which they could be more me than anything, but I discuss everything in detail in my full, non-spoiler review on my blog: http://taleswithkayla.com/br-thesmartone/
I saw a lot of myself in this book. It was like this author crawled inside my life, mashed things up a bit, and put it all down for other people to read.
When I received an email asking me if I would like to review Jennifer Close’s second novel, I said yes immediately. I know her debut novel was immensely popular, and I have it on my shelf somewhere to be read, and so I knew Jennifer Close came with some backing behind her, especially after I read that her novels are witty, and the novel version of Girls (not that I base what I read on Girls since I’ve never seen it, but I know the gist of what it’s about and so, a book like Girls is going to interest me even if Girls itself does not). I was interested to read about a dysfunctional family because dysfunctional families usually make for the best characters in novels.
While I found Things We Need to be interesting, I sadly didn’t find it to be witty. It was definitely smart, and Jennifer Close can definitely get into the middle of a crazy family and make it interesting to read about them, I didn’t feel like the book really blew me away. I very much enjoyed reading the novel, and some of the characters really impressed me but mostly it was just your average family drama and there was nothing that really separated it from the pack, something that made it stand out and be really memorable. I liked the idea of the novel, but it wasn’t executed as well as I’d have liked.
One thing I really enjoyed was the variety of characters. Each of the narrators in the novel are varied and enjoyable. My favourite character was Cleo, although I wasn’t 100% sold on where her plot went. I felt she went from being an incredibly strong character to someone who sort of fell by the wayside and had everyone judge the life out of her. I wanted the sparky Cleo back, the one who fearlessly wore bikinis down at the shore, much to the digust of the entire Coffey family who found that horrific (because what else do you wear to the beach?). I also found Martha strangely compelling. I felt she perhaps had a touch of autism or aspergers, but it seemed as though she just suffered with being the kid that everyone bigs up constantly and needs to be the center of attention. I could never decide how I felt about Claire; I liked her but on the other hand she was quite mean to her sister and quite ungrateful to her despite the fact her parents took her in when she had nowhere else to go. Weezy, too, was an enigma. I liked her, but, again, I felt she was very judgemental.
Overall, I’m pleased I read Things We Need, and I wished that the whole idea of the “Things We Need” list had been explored a bit more. Mostly, though, this was a novel that explored family life as it is on a general day-to-day basis and it was very believable; I find myself getting irritated with my sister/mother/dad all of the time, and in that sense the novel was really, really honest. But honesty doesn’t always breed a fantastic read and this one was a little bit slow for my liking. It could have done with a bit more humour. Close is a really good writer, and I did find the narratives to be compelling but as a whole the novel was just a tad too slow for me. For those who like their novels a bit slower, who like to get to the nitty-gritty of family life, this one is for them.
While I found Things We Need to be interesting, I sadly didn’t find it to be witty. It was definitely smart, and Jennifer Close can definitely get into the middle of a crazy family and make it interesting to read about them, I didn’t feel like the book really blew me away. I very much enjoyed reading the novel, and some of the characters really impressed me but mostly it was just your average family drama and there was nothing that really separated it from the pack, something that made it stand out and be really memorable. I liked the idea of the novel, but it wasn’t executed as well as I’d have liked.
One thing I really enjoyed was the variety of characters. Each of the narrators in the novel are varied and enjoyable. My favourite character was Cleo, although I wasn’t 100% sold on where her plot went. I felt she went from being an incredibly strong character to someone who sort of fell by the wayside and had everyone judge the life out of her. I wanted the sparky Cleo back, the one who fearlessly wore bikinis down at the shore, much to the digust of the entire Coffey family who found that horrific (because what else do you wear to the beach?). I also found Martha strangely compelling. I felt she perhaps had a touch of autism or aspergers, but it seemed as though she just suffered with being the kid that everyone bigs up constantly and needs to be the center of attention. I could never decide how I felt about Claire; I liked her but on the other hand she was quite mean to her sister and quite ungrateful to her despite the fact her parents took her in when she had nowhere else to go. Weezy, too, was an enigma. I liked her, but, again, I felt she was very judgemental.
Overall, I’m pleased I read Things We Need, and I wished that the whole idea of the “Things We Need” list had been explored a bit more. Mostly, though, this was a novel that explored family life as it is on a general day-to-day basis and it was very believable; I find myself getting irritated with my sister/mother/dad all of the time, and in that sense the novel was really, really honest. But honesty doesn’t always breed a fantastic read and this one was a little bit slow for my liking. It could have done with a bit more humour. Close is a really good writer, and I did find the narratives to be compelling but as a whole the novel was just a tad too slow for me. For those who like their novels a bit slower, who like to get to the nitty-gritty of family life, this one is for them.