2.15k reviews for:

Fire Night

Penelope Douglas

3.97 AVERAGE


4.5/5

Coming as no shock to anyone, this was my favourite in the series.

Emory Scott and Will Grayson III were just made to be together - they are the perfect example of a slow burn, second chance romance that truly just shows their individual personalities and building each of their characters beyond what we have seen of them in the past books.

There were some minor things I wish were built on more. I would have liked to see more of Will’s addiction struggles, and hear more from Emmy after she left Thunder Bay, etc. But they are such small pieces of information that truly are not important for the greater story but something I just wish I got to see.

Will was such a fun character. I liked his lightness and humour, especially after a dark book like Damon’s. It just brought back the spirit and joy of the story, and he fit so well with Emmy through their journey and incidents.

I loved the setting in Blackchurch and that unfolding. Once they returned to Thunder Bay, I will say that the storyline began to lose me. I do understand that there was a long running story to wrap up and lots of lose ends to tie, but it just went on for a really long time and started to lose its impact after a while.

After finishing the series, I don’t feel like Alex’s character was done justice and the introduction of Aydin in this book just felt like a way of shutting people up about Alex getting a happy ending. It didn’t feel right for the story.

I did love this though. I loved the suspense, I loved the “trapped” sort of vibe in the house, the flashbacks, the dancing scene (IYKYK - the whole reason I picked up this series). It was a really nice way to finish it all up and it was nice to finally follow a couple where the guy just truly loved and adored his girl. He had no shame in how much love he has for Emmy and it just warmed my heart. Everyone needs a Will Grayson.

i would have loved this more if it weren't for that one chapter. if you know, you know.

4.9 ⭐
4.6

5 ⭐
0.5/5

Okay 4.5 ⭐️, I meannnn I have no words other than William Grayson III is everything
adventurous fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

I was so consumed by will and emory’s story. Their story was my favorite out of the horsemen couples. I just loved seeing different perspective on certain scenes that were told in other books. Overall great ending to a great series.

The adventure and trouble never stops with this group. As always, i enjoyed reading about this group of friends! Nice short story of events that happened during fire night.
dark mysterious relaxing tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No
fast-paced