Reviews with content warning for Domestic abuse - Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City

Reviews tagging 'Domestic abuse'

Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City by Matthew Desmond

35 reviews

fkshg8465's review against another edition

challenging dark emotional informative sad slow-paced

5.0

The more I read and learn and understand how institutionalized racism started and continues to be reinforced, the more I fear for this country.

Content Warnings

shannahtan's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging sad medium-paced

I feel weird rating this book because it’s almost a memoir of these people’s lives.

Ethnography is so interesting because the person is actually trying to live this life in first person. Desmond mentioned he didn’t pay folks for interviews, which in part I understand that he maybe didn’t want to get a biased point of view. However, I feel like they should get paid for this book as he was telling their life stories. Although Desmond recognizes his privilege, he still got to leave the trailer park. He was never evicted. The people in the book are still living this life of eviction. All in all, the book is dense and is a very good window into the life of so many people in the United States. The last two chapters explain how a universal housing voucher has helped other countries combat houselessness. I tandem read this through audiobook and ebook.

Content Warnings

amyvl93's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark informative medium-paced

4.5

This was an excellent if very bleak look at cycles of poverty through the lens of those who are evicted from their rental properties. Desmond follows 8 families in particular who live in Milwaukee - all of whom are paying significant amounts of their income on rent - as well as a couple of landlords, one who runs a condemned trailer park and the other, and one who owns numerous properties in poor areas of the city.

Desmond treats all the individuals he features with such empathy, it really felt like you were alongside them. There are moments of great tragedy sitting alongside everyday tragedies. He shines a light on systems that exploit those they should protect - from the incredibly profitable business of filling your properties with those on state support because you don't run the risk of losing rent, whilst not considering whether the properties really meet their needs, to the truly insane practice of raising grievances against landlords when residents call the police (including in cases of domestic abuse) that can lead families being evicted because landlords don't want to be considered nuisance properties. When this happened to one family, who finally appeared to be on the 'up', I very nearly cried out of frustration for them.

Alongside the problems of housing, Evicted also looks at the factors that can tip people what many may refer to as 'chaotic lives'. Drug addiction is a pattern for many of those profiled here - a nurse who loved their job who gained an opioid habit following an injury loses his job after he stole and finds himself in a trailer park. But alongside this is abusive relationships, childhood trauma, limited employment that enables the flexibility that many women raising children need and proximity to crime. The families that are able to find stability are those that are able to finally get themselves into spaces where they can build connections, find stable employment and access support - all of which is underpinned by high quality housing. Desmond very clearly articulates how being stuck in a horrible home impacts the way people feel about themselves; and how a home to be proud of improves people's ways of seeing themselves - which is even more true of the children and teenagers profiled here.

Written in 2016, so much of Desmond's writing and findings feel prescient to today. I'm looking forward (?) to reading his latest book Poverty next.

Content Warnings