Scan barcode
sznnbrgrn's review against another edition
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.25
lux_klara's review against another edition
4.0
I'll start saying that IF YOU HATE CLIFFHANGERS THEN YOU SHOULD WAIT FOR THE NEXT BOOK TO COME OUT BEFORE READING THIS ONE.
I would also like to add that the end is a cliffhanger but one that makes complete sense. I can't see the author ending the book before or after that "moment" and it's obvious that it's crucial to future books and the development of characters & story. THIS IS A TRANSITION BOOK, and it must be read with that in mind and judged as such. It is obviously fundamental for what will come later on, it has its own plot and mistery but, at the end of the day, it's purpose is to built up other books and events. And the cliffhanger itself needs too much build up ( + introduction of a new character) so I don't think you could cut part of this book either just to fit everything in one. (And due to the way the ending is written I think that, at the end, the author herself suggest that things are going to be okay)
I also know that several people hate cliffhangers because other writers often use cliffhangers to make readers keep reading their books but this is the 11th book of a series, not the first. The author doesn't need to convince you to keep reading or bait you in doing it because if you arrived at this point, chances are, that you already love the series and would keep reading it. This cliffhanger has a purpose, or so I think. So I just suggest to those that hate cliffhangers to wait for the next book so that they won't be angry at this one, judging it harshly for something that I don't think could be avoided.
That said, I really loved this book, the relationship between Elena and Raphael is always special. I've always appreciated how Nalini never uses things like love triangles to keep the relationship interesting. Sure, we can see them being a bit jealous but they don't question their relationship. They grow together, learn to be together and solidify their connection.
I also appreciate how the author keeps building up the overall plot and characters and, at the same time, write a separated plot for that specific book. In this book in particular, the Guild has to rethink the solitary role of the Slayer and its consequences and Elena gives a very smart suggestion that could solve the problem.
We can also see more about Elena's family (tough I would like to see a bit more about them) and I'm really curious to see how things will progress in future books, because I doubt that what happened in this book won't have any consequences on that front as well.
I would also like to add that the end is a cliffhanger but one that makes complete sense. I can't see the author ending the book before or after that "moment" and it's obvious that it's crucial to future books and the development of characters & story. THIS IS A TRANSITION BOOK, and it must be read with that in mind and judged as such. It is obviously fundamental for what will come later on, it has its own plot and mistery but, at the end of the day, it's purpose is to built up other books and events. And the cliffhanger itself needs too much build up ( + introduction of a new character) so I don't think you could cut part of this book either just to fit everything in one. (And due to the way the ending is written I think that, at the end, the author herself suggest that things are going to be okay)
I also know that several people hate cliffhangers because other writers often use cliffhangers to make readers keep reading their books but this is the 11th book of a series, not the first. The author doesn't need to convince you to keep reading or bait you in doing it because if you arrived at this point, chances are, that you already love the series and would keep reading it. This cliffhanger has a purpose, or so I think. So I just suggest to those that hate cliffhangers to wait for the next book so that they won't be angry at this one, judging it harshly for something that I don't think could be avoided.
That said, I really loved this book, the relationship between Elena and Raphael is always special. I've always appreciated how Nalini never uses things like love triangles to keep the relationship interesting. Sure, we can see them being a bit jealous but they don't question their relationship. They grow together, learn to be together and solidify their connection.
I also appreciate how the author keeps building up the overall plot and characters and, at the same time, write a separated plot for that specific book. In this book in particular, the Guild has to rethink the solitary role of the Slayer and its consequences and Elena gives a very smart suggestion that could solve the problem.
We can also see more about Elena's family (tough I would like to see a bit more about them) and I'm really curious to see how things will progress in future books, because I doubt that what happened in this book won't have any consequences on that front as well.
ilia_'s review against another edition
4.0
Oh, it is good! Came back to the series after a year-long break and I devoured this book. I enjoyed both the Raphael & Elena story line and the Slayer suspense story but basically found myself speed reading to get to the pages relating to the prophecy and the changes caused by the Cascade. The last 50 pages were a rollercoaster! I went from sheer excitement to gloom and sorrow, to calmness and then impatience. And I loved that! Glad I already have the next book in the series on my shelf.
indecisivesailorscout's review against another edition
4.0
2nd read: I definitely didn't have as strong a response the second time around, but it was still pretty good and surprising, just the right amount of twists and turns to make Raphael and Elena actually interesting again.
1st read: Well that was bullshit. I am so upset right now. I'm too upset to give it 5 stars. I hate cliffhangers. I also hate the angry sads I have now. Why is this happening. UGH. UGH, I SAY. I'm ready to riot. This is me rioting.
1st read: Well that was bullshit. I am so upset right now. I'm too upset to give it 5 stars. I hate cliffhangers. I also hate the angry sads I have now. Why is this happening. UGH. UGH, I SAY. I'm ready to riot. This is me rioting.
kate_and_books's review against another edition
4.0
3.5
“Stay a little mortal, won’t you, Archangel.” “You are my immortality”
Ms. Singh is a true genius when it comes to the Guild Hunter series although late to the party I have loved every single book. Okay so maybe not Viper’s but that is not to be mentioned.
Whereas I always love visiting Elena & Raphael this time was different. I just need to explain why now.
What happens in this book is important to the overall story so it is a book that needs to be read. I have a lot of mixed feelings on this one and I wish I hadn’t I truly wish that I could give it any easy 5 stars for its brilliance and where it is brilliant for me there was something missing. Elena’s past is rehashed again and where it is heart-breaking it is always different variations of what has been read in other books focusing on E & R. There is a slow pace to the story which didn’t really work for me.
Don’t even get me started on that ending, I mean WTF? And the next one is out in 2019. Will it be E & R again? Or will we finally get Bluebell and Sparkles?
Although not completely satisfying it took care of my fix for this couple and series.
“Stay a little mortal, won’t you, Archangel.” “You are my immortality”
Ms. Singh is a true genius when it comes to the Guild Hunter series although late to the party I have loved every single book. Okay so maybe not Viper’s but that is not to be mentioned.
Whereas I always love visiting Elena & Raphael this time was different. I just need to explain why now.
What happens in this book is important to the overall story so it is a book that needs to be read. I have a lot of mixed feelings on this one and I wish I hadn’t I truly wish that I could give it any easy 5 stars for its brilliance and where it is brilliant for me there was something missing. Elena’s past is rehashed again and where it is heart-breaking it is always different variations of what has been read in other books focusing on E & R. There is a slow pace to the story which didn’t really work for me.
Don’t even get me started on that ending, I mean WTF? And the next one is out in 2019. Will it be E & R again? Or will we finally get Bluebell and Sparkles?
Although not completely satisfying it took care of my fix for this couple and series.
coralivashkov's review against another edition
3.0
I used to love these series, I really liked the characters and the storyline… but not this book. A very slow and boring plot tbh, another recap of Elena’s life, and her stubbornness felt more immature than a good trait, also Raphael is barely there anymore, I didn’t even feel his presence, just every other moment, what’s the point?
It took me TWO YEARS to finish this book, with that I say it all. 3 stars just for the memories and affection.
It took me TWO YEARS to finish this book, with that I say it all. 3 stars just for the memories and affection.
meaganpauli's review against another edition
3.0
11th book slump. I asked for an Elena power up, not a weird regression back to mortality and a mothman cliffhanger.
leguminose's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
4.75