Scan barcode
1outside's review
5.0
This might actually be my favourite BF story with this crew configuration. Certainly better than most (all?) of their TV stories. (Mind you, I enjoy this period of Who a lot, but I always felt the actual stories never quite delivered on these characters' potential.)
Who doesn't like a base under siege story, especially if the threat doesn't come from the outside, especially if there's a bit of timey-wimey involved, and especially if there's a touchy-feel-y AI on board?
Some of the story's themes were quite grim and harsh, but the chemistry of all the characters worked very well and even offered a few funny moments here and there.
Doctor: These are creatures of pure instinct, they don't deserve that cruelty.
Tegan: I don't know, I'd feel a lot happier if those things were put out of action on a permanent basis.
Doctor: And I'm sure they'd say the same about you, Tegan.
Who doesn't like a base under siege story, especially if the threat doesn't come from the outside, especially if there's a bit of timey-wimey involved, and especially if there's a touchy-feel-y AI on board?
Some of the story's themes were quite grim and harsh, but the chemistry of all the characters worked very well and even offered a few funny moments here and there.
Doctor: These are creatures of pure instinct, they don't deserve that cruelty.
Tegan: I don't know, I'd feel a lot happier if those things were put out of action on a permanent basis.
Doctor: And I'm sure they'd say the same about you, Tegan.
nwhyte's review
3.0
This is one of the most audacious ideas Big Finish have had: reuniting Team Tardis from 1983 for three new audio plays, with Peter Davison as the Doctor, Sarah Sutton as Nyssa, Janet Fielding as Tegan and Mark Strickson as Turlough. (I'm trying to think of any previous Big Finish play which reunited more than two contemporaneous members of the cast of the classic series, and so far failing. Adric's return two years ago saw him played not by Matthew Waterhouse but, as Peter Davison cruelly said, by an actor.)
Cobwebs is a good start to this mini-season. The set-up is decently spooky: the Doctor, Tegan and Turlough encounter Nyssa - for whom many years have elapsed since she left the Tardis - on a deserted space station filled with, well, cobwebs, also robots and a deranged computer. The plot develops into a tale of cures for space plague and temporal paradoxes, and impressively manages to wrench two of the three cliff-hangers from what is apparently the same situation viewed from different time periods. I wasn't quite sure that the temporal paradox was satisfactory in the end - to what extent did the Doctor cause his own involvement in the situation? - but perhaps this will be resolved in the two sequels - the loose ends here seem to indicate that the three stories will be linked.
What makes it of course is that the core cast are obviously having a whale of a time getting back into the spirit of '83. Tegan if anything is more spiky than I remember her - did she ever have a go at Nyssa in the original series? She lets fly at everyone here. Of the cast of creepy scientists and others, Raymond Coulthart stands out as the various artificial intelligences, though the other guest cast (all moderately well-known actors) are decent as well.
After the increasingly fannish progression of the last mini-season (Legend of the Cybermen would be pretty impenetrable to listeners who had not seen a particular Second Doctor story, though very enjoyable to those in the know) I'm glad to say that Cobwebs would probably be accessible to listeners with only a vague knowledge of Who (basically, that it's about this guy who travels in time), and probably a good starting point for Big Finish newbies. Recommended.
Cobwebs is a good start to this mini-season. The set-up is decently spooky: the Doctor, Tegan and Turlough encounter Nyssa - for whom many years have elapsed since she left the Tardis - on a deserted space station filled with, well, cobwebs, also robots and a deranged computer. The plot develops into a tale of cures for space plague and temporal paradoxes, and impressively manages to wrench two of the three cliff-hangers from what is apparently the same situation viewed from different time periods. I wasn't quite sure that the temporal paradox was satisfactory in the end - to what extent did the Doctor cause his own involvement in the situation? - but perhaps this will be resolved in the two sequels - the loose ends here seem to indicate that the three stories will be linked.
What makes it of course is that the core cast are obviously having a whale of a time getting back into the spirit of '83. Tegan if anything is more spiky than I remember her - did she ever have a go at Nyssa in the original series? She lets fly at everyone here. Of the cast of creepy scientists and others, Raymond Coulthart stands out as the various artificial intelligences, though the other guest cast (all moderately well-known actors) are decent as well.
After the increasingly fannish progression of the last mini-season (Legend of the Cybermen would be pretty impenetrable to listeners who had not seen a particular Second Doctor story, though very enjoyable to those in the know) I'm glad to say that Cobwebs would probably be accessible to listeners with only a vague knowledge of Who (basically, that it's about this guy who travels in time), and probably a good starting point for Big Finish newbies. Recommended.
More...