Scan barcode
trudilibrarian's review against another edition
4.0
I have been, and always shall be, your friend. ~Spock, The Wrath of KhanI'm betting the vast majority of readers/listeners finding their way to this book will have been lifelong Trekkies, having come of age watching Star Trek in syndication, waiting with keen anticipation as each motion picture installment was released in the franchise, discovering new things to love about the Trek verse as it expanded/exploded to include The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine and Voyager.
Of my friend, I can only say this: Of all the souls I have encountered in my travels, his was the most...human. ~Capt. Kirk, The Wrath of Khan
This isn't me. I'm coming to Trek shockingly late -- 50 years after the 1966 premiere of the original series starring William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy. For me the paint isn't even dry. It started only last summer with the release of Star Trek: Beyond. I decided I would go see it, but I didn't want to do that until I had watched the first two movies in JJ Abrams reboot (keeping in mind I had never seen an episode of Star Trek -- ANY Star Trek -- in my life, nor any of the movies). As someone who had been raised and steeped in the horror tradition, A LOT of sci-fi nerdy stuff passed me by altogether (yes, including Star Wars). I wasn't interested, and for a long time, I really didn't think any of it was being made for me anyway. None of it felt like my "tribe" so to speak, or anything I was able or willing to relate to.
Fast forward to August 2016. I watch the Abrams movies and LOVE them -- especially Beyond which is my favourite of the three. I loved these movies so much, and fell in love with Pine's and Quinto's portrayals of Kirk and Spock so completely, it triggered an almost immediate overwhelming desire to go back and watch the entire run of the original Star Trek -- yes, even season 3, all of it -- which as any Trekkie reading this knows is an exercise in endurance, patience and frustration at the sharp decline in quality the series would take in its final year.
But it was worth it -- after seeing a new generation of young actors tackle these iconic characters so successfully, I had to go back to the beginning and experience the Shatner/Nimoy dynamic that launched a franchise so big and so far reaching it was still finding people and captivating them five decades later. I needed to see with my own eyes, feel with my own heart, what was so special about this low-budget sci-fi television show from the 60s that would make millions of people from all over the world into lifelong Trekkies.
I came to this project with a lot of skepticism, certain after all these many decades there was no way the show would have the ability to resonate with me now or hold my interest. Too much time had passed. It would seem too old-fashioned, cheap and silly. And for sure, watching those first few episodes I giggled at some of the ridiculous cheesy "special effects", the poorly choreographed fight sequences where no attempt was made to hide the stunt double, and Shatner's chewing up the scenery every chance he got.
But these elements became part of the show's vintage charm for me, and more than that, superficial characteristics of a show that would go on to convince me of its imaginative and thought-provoking storytelling wrapped up in a contagious adventure of the week style. I was hooked. More than that, like millions before me, I was falling in love with Mr. Spock -- the forever logical, keenly observant and emotionally controlled First Officer of Starfleet's USS Enterprise -- a role I can't believe anyone else could have brought to life so vividly or memorably as Leonard Nimoy.
As I made my way through the original TV series (with the help and guidance from a bona fide Trek nerd who shall remain unnamed), I would also begin watching the films. The deeper into the Trek verse I went, the more deeply attached I became to the characters, and began to fully appreciate the unique on-screen chemistry shared between Shatner and Nimoy. The best actors act -- they are paid to feel things they are not really feeling -- but that nebulous, indefinable chemistry cannot be bought and sold, faked or forced. What Shatner and Nimoy share on the screen as Kirk and Spock is something special and precious to behold. It would shape and inform a unique, sometimes difficult and contentious, friendship that would last half a century.
Listening to Shatner read aloud his remembrances of his friendship with such a charismatic, multi-talented, deeply loved man, I came to the conclusion that Shatner is being sincere here. You can hear the respect and unchecked admiration for the man Nimoy was, and the blinding love Shatner held for him (even when his narcissistic tendencies would bring up feelings of competition and jealousy and even resentment). It's sweet, and at times terribly sad. You can detect a note of loneliness in Shatner's words as he confesses to his lack of any lasting friendships with anyone, save for Nimoy who Fate had fused the two men together on this remarkable journey of a lifetime. But even Nimoy -- after decades of sharing his world with Shatner -- would suddenly (and inexplicably from Shatner's viewpoint) end their relationship and cut off all direct contact.
Shatner doesn't go into too much detail regarding the men's epic falling out. He's playing dumb and seems honestly baffled and hurt why Nimoy would cut him out of his life around the time Shatner was making the documentary The Captains in 2011. Obviously, whether Shatner wants to confront his role in the falling out or not, the saddest part of all of this is that these two men brought together, and held together, by extraordinary circumstances, would not have each other as one faced a terminal illness and death. When Nimoy finally did pass away in February 2015, Shatner chose to appear at a charity fundraiser for the Red Cross and would not make it to Nimoy's funeral, a fact I'm sure some Trekkies will never forgive him for.
I choose to be a little more forgiving and understanding. I feel Shatner's grief and sense of loss are genuine and keenly, sharply experienced. While there is a lot of information presented here that is re-hashing material previously published elsewhere, there is also a new-found humility as Shatner tries to work through some of his feelings of inadequacy, and never quite measuring up to the depth and breadth of talent and integrity that was Leonard Nimoy. It really is a love letter in a lot of important ways, as Shatner attempts to make sense of the wonder of it all and his and Nimoy's place in it as he faces his own inevitable mortality.
I can only hope when it's Shatner's turn to shuffle off this mortal coil, there is some kind of afterlife waiting for all of us, and that he and Nimoy find each other there and find a way back to forgiveness and the special friendship they once shared.
I'm going to end this review by recommending the recent documentary For the Love of Spock. This isn't just mandatory viewing for Trek fans, but is also a poignant and comprehensive look at the life of a remarkable man and the resonating influence of an iconic figure who has come to mean so much to so many. LLAP friends.
birdkeeperklink's review
3.0
No, I don't actually like crying, it just happens....
This is basically a love letter to Leonard Nimoy in extended form, by means of retelling his life and career. That's all well and good, and nothing about it made me annoyed or angry, but there are a few things you should know before you dive in:
1) If you've read either of Leonard Nimoy's autobiographies, particularly his second one, then a lot of this will be information you've read before. The repetition can lead to skimming a bit, and slight boredom.
2) Despite the subtitle, there are very, very few reminisces about memories of their friendship from William Shatner. He does explain this at the end of the book--that after a lifetime, it's all sort of blended together until they're not so much memories as general warm feelings--but I could have done with that note at the beginning of the book, because as it was, I spent the whole time waiting for something that wasn't going to happen.
Still, this is a good book, with a clear love and respect for Leonard Nimoy, and I don't think any of his fans should miss out on adding it to their collections. It's a quick, easy read as well, so even if you don't think you'll like it, it won't hurt you to try it out.
This is basically a love letter to Leonard Nimoy in extended form, by means of retelling his life and career. That's all well and good, and nothing about it made me annoyed or angry, but there are a few things you should know before you dive in:
1) If you've read either of Leonard Nimoy's autobiographies, particularly his second one, then a lot of this will be information you've read before. The repetition can lead to skimming a bit, and slight boredom.
2) Despite the subtitle, there are very, very few reminisces about memories of their friendship from William Shatner. He does explain this at the end of the book--that after a lifetime, it's all sort of blended together until they're not so much memories as general warm feelings--but I could have done with that note at the beginning of the book, because as it was, I spent the whole time waiting for something that wasn't going to happen.
Still, this is a good book, with a clear love and respect for Leonard Nimoy, and I don't think any of his fans should miss out on adding it to their collections. It's a quick, easy read as well, so even if you don't think you'll like it, it won't hurt you to try it out.
cuteasamuntin's review against another edition
reflective
sad
fast-paced
2.75
While billed as a Leonard Nimoy (z”l) biography penned by a lifelong friend, this ghostwritten narrative reads equally or more as a William Shatner memoir.
At many points in my reading, I found myself pausing to ruminate on Shatner’s apparent inability to either critically self-reflect or sincerely apologize for his own mistakes and misdeeds. Overall, this book’s purpose seems to be in Shatner’s defense. Throughout, we are privy to Shatner 1) organizing and processing his feelings about Captain James T. Kirk and the Star Trek franchise, 2) reminiscing about his own life in parallel with Nimoy’s, 3) attempting a post-mortem apology to Nimoy (z”l) and to fans of Kirk, Spock, and the Star Trek franchise. It left me feeling melancholy and bereft, perhaps even mournful, but likely not in the way intended by Shatner and his ghostwriter.
Most anecdotes and facts will not be new information to TOS fans, readers of previous memoirs and biographies, or those knowledgeable in either 1960s Hollywood or Gene Roddenberry’s (I hesitate to add, z”l) life. The audiobook quality is not amazing, but if you enjoy Kirk’s heartfelt speeches in the Trek movies, listening to at least the last chapter may be worthwhile.
At many points in my reading, I found myself pausing to ruminate on Shatner’s apparent inability to either critically self-reflect or sincerely apologize for his own mistakes and misdeeds. Overall, this book’s purpose seems to be in Shatner’s defense. Throughout, we are privy to Shatner 1) organizing and processing his feelings about Captain James T. Kirk and the Star Trek franchise, 2) reminiscing about his own life in parallel with Nimoy’s, 3) attempting a post-mortem apology to Nimoy (z”l) and to fans of Kirk, Spock, and the Star Trek franchise. It left me feeling melancholy and bereft, perhaps even mournful, but likely not in the way intended by Shatner and his ghostwriter.
Most anecdotes and facts will not be new information to TOS fans, readers of previous memoirs and biographies, or those knowledgeable in either 1960s Hollywood or Gene Roddenberry’s (I hesitate to add, z”l) life. The audiobook quality is not amazing, but if you enjoy Kirk’s heartfelt speeches in the Trek movies, listening to at least the last chapter may be worthwhile.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Grief and Alcoholism
Moderate: Death and Terminal illness
Minor: Addiction, Antisemitism, Toxic friendship, Bullying, and Mental illness
livelymon's review
4.0
It's clear how much Shatner adores and respects Nimoy (even through their differences) and it is both a delight and trial to read.
stevewhitaker's review
3.0
So look, ignore the star rating. There was no way I wasn't going to read this book, and if you're a Star Trek fan who also loves Leonard Nimoy, I'm guessing you'll read it, too - regardless of reviews.
What a convoluted sentence that was.
Here's the thing: it's a book by William Shatner. It actually reads like a book *dictated* by William Shatner, which I suspect it is. So, you're gonna get your fair share of Shatner in the book - there are lots of stories that make sure you know Bill was involved in them, but not quite to the point of self-servitude.
Somebody described this book as his "love letter" to Leonard Nimoy. That's probably fair, but this also reads a little bit like a confessional - maybe as close to an apology as Shatner is capable of for being such a - well, Shatner - all those years. The stories about Nimoy are good, and I hadn't heard a lot of them before. He sounds like the remarkable man I've always suspected him to be, and hearing them made me sad that he's gone, all over again.
It's worth a read. Look past the Shatner and find the Nimoy, and you'll likely appreciate it.
What a convoluted sentence that was.
Here's the thing: it's a book by William Shatner. It actually reads like a book *dictated* by William Shatner, which I suspect it is. So, you're gonna get your fair share of Shatner in the book - there are lots of stories that make sure you know Bill was involved in them, but not quite to the point of self-servitude.
Somebody described this book as his "love letter" to Leonard Nimoy. That's probably fair, but this also reads a little bit like a confessional - maybe as close to an apology as Shatner is capable of for being such a - well, Shatner - all those years. The stories about Nimoy are good, and I hadn't heard a lot of them before. He sounds like the remarkable man I've always suspected him to be, and hearing them made me sad that he's gone, all over again.
It's worth a read. Look past the Shatner and find the Nimoy, and you'll likely appreciate it.
zeldahime's review
I got a quarter of the way in and Shatner and Nimoy hadn’t even met yet. It also contains a great deal more information about Shatner than Nimoy, which I suppose is understandable but I found deeply irritating.
elysareadsitall's review against another edition
emotional
informative
medium-paced
4.5
<i>Leonard</i> is William Shatner's memoir of his friendship with Leonard Nimoy, their time on <i>Star Trek</i>, and their lives after. His love for Nimoy is apparent in the book, and it was interesting to see how similar their backgrounds are and how they approached fame. I learned about some of Nimoy's work that I didn't previously know about, so I'll be looking into those. I enjoyed this book overall and would recommend it for fans.
kmg365's review
3.0
Geez, Bill, were you late for an appointment? Did you have “no retakes” written into the audiobook contract? I have never before heard an audiobook reading so rushed, with numerous, plainly audible page turns on the recording. About 50% of the time, the phrase “Live long and prosper” was read as “Long live and prosper.”
There were a couple of personal anecdotes here, but the book relies heavily on other published sources (and imdb) for much of the material. For any Trek fan who’s been paying attention for the last 50 years, there’s not much that’s new.
Do I think Bill cashed in to make a quick buck from the death of a man he calls his best friend? No. I think he genuinely wanted to honor the man he was most closely associated with in the popular imagination for the majority of his working life. Does the book succeed in that? Somewhat, but I rather suspect Shatner’s not capable of close friendship in the way most people experience it. He alludes briefly to that in the text, calling it a by-product of the acting life.
The text of the note that Bill sent to Leonard when he realized how ill he was is saved for last, and it’s the only part that Bill reads with care and attention, and even with a little emotion. If you’re of a certain age, and already know about stolen bicycles and “most favored nation” clauses, grab this in a bookstore and read the last 6 pages or so. If you’re new to the ST:TOS mythos, this is not the book you want to start with.
ferrisscottr's review
4.0
Part biography, part memoir of a person who spent a great deal of their life with someone.
This is all Shatner but also all Nimoy.
It's one side of a great story and a friendship that lasted decades.
I grew up on "In Search Of" and that led me to "Star Trek" which led me to Alien Voices.
So, I'm a fan.
Of both Nimoy and Shatner.
I have critiques and things I would have done different/better in this book but all in all I enjoyed it. It was entertaining and I also learned a lot about but Nimoy and Shatner. A well spent couple of hours. Good stuff.
This is all Shatner but also all Nimoy.
It's one side of a great story and a friendship that lasted decades.
I grew up on "In Search Of" and that led me to "Star Trek" which led me to Alien Voices.
So, I'm a fan.
Of both Nimoy and Shatner.
I have critiques and things I would have done different/better in this book but all in all I enjoyed it. It was entertaining and I also learned a lot about but Nimoy and Shatner. A well spent couple of hours. Good stuff.