Scan barcode
tombennett72's review against another edition
4.0
A well written story that moves at a cracking pace. Really enjoyed it.
polychrome's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
Interesting way to learn more about this period of Indian history and colonialism.
Good, twisty, mystery with an interesting main character.
Good, twisty, mystery with an interesting main character.
willrefuge's review against another edition
4.0
4.0 / 5 ✪
https://arefugefromlife.wordpress.com/2021/04/07/a-rising-man-by-abir-mukherjee-review/
The year is 1919. The Great War has ended. The British Empire spans the globe. Former Scotland Yard Detective Sam Wyndham has recently returned home from the continent to find the life he lived pre-war is at an end. All the friends he shipped out with are dead. As is his young wife, Sarah, to whom he was wed not two days before leaving for the war. With nowhere to turn, Sam soon finds himself in the gutter, addicted to the morphine they’d given him to dull the pain of his war wounds. After the morphine runs out, he turns to opium—a cheaper and more plentiful alternative.
A chance telegram saves Sam’s life. A few months later, Sam Wyndham sets foot on the Indian subcontinent for the first time. His new life as a Captain in the Imperial Police Force in Bengal to begin on the second of April, one day after his arrival. A week later, the body of a senior official is found in the sewer, a note in his mouth warning of a potential insurrection among the natives.
So begins an investigation that will drag Wyndham all across Kolkata—from the slums packed with native Indians to the upscale mansions of the British Elite, from seedy opium dens to the jungles of the rural countryside. A son of the empire and a native son rub elbows in the Imperial Police, while an intoxicating woman split between both worlds may yet steal his heart away. From natives to expats, Wyndham must choose his allies wisely, as there’s no telling which allegiance they hold any more than whose pocket they may be in. The only certainty is that Wyndham must solve this murder and soon, before tensions between the Indians and the Empire boil over.
I stumbled upon A Rising Man while shopping for a Christmas present for my father. While I ultimately did not get him this, I ended up buying it for myself as it sounded so interesting. A historical mystery, A Rising Man does a pretty good job of transporting us to Colonial India—a melting pot of English “civility” and native “savagery”. With Buddhists, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians, Europeans, Indians, and more alike all forced together by the hands of capitalism, Colonial India feels like a caldera waiting to erupt. Abir Mukherjee does an incredible job capturing the atmosphere of the place: the tensions, the humidity, the jungle and predators and flies, the wealth and poverty all jammed together. It’s quite good.
The mystery itself toes the line between fascinating and convoluted, with so enough twists and turns that kept me on my toes throughout. While everything is a bit thick and murky at the outset, the waters eventually cleared enough for me to get a handle on everything as the mystery progressed. While I did call one major reveal very early on, it actually took me quite some time to figure out whodunnit in time for the conclusion. The pacing was a bit stop-start, but I realize that’s a tough ratio to hit, especially for a new author and in a debut series. While it’s not a Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot calibre mystery, A Rising Man kept me easily entertained throughout, and guessing until the final page was turned.
One final note on A Rising Man is the issues it tackles. The story takes place at a global crossroads, where many historically rival cultures compete with one that is very heterogeneous, and used to having its own way. At the time it would’ve been one of the few places on earth with so many different cultures locked in a war against homogenization, as opposed to somewhere like Colonial America where everything seemed to just blend together (well, not everything, sadly). From bigotry to religious discrimination to who and whom its acceptable to love, the story is really set at a very interesting—if incredibly tense—time period. While it does an adequate job of addressing the tension between the English and Bengali people, I would like to see more of the region’s minorities in ethnicity and religion in later books. Additionally, I really would’ve liked to have more of a look into the caste system at this time—which is only rarely mentioned, but never focused on.
TL;DR
A Rising Man combines historical fiction with a complex and engrossing mystery with twists and turns enough to have me guessing until the very end. Though Sam Wyndham isn’t the greatest narrator, he does an adequate job of tackling both the investigation and the region’s tensions. He’s also a bit of git. But while you probably won’t buy A Rising Man for the romance or action, the mystery itself is more than enough of a reason to. All combined with a one of a kind setting that finds opulent wealth rubbing shoulders with crippling poverty and a melting pot of cultures, religions, ideals, and ethnicities, makes A Rising Man a great read, and a mystery you won’t want to put down until the last page is turned.
https://arefugefromlife.wordpress.com/2021/04/07/a-rising-man-by-abir-mukherjee-review/
The year is 1919. The Great War has ended. The British Empire spans the globe. Former Scotland Yard Detective Sam Wyndham has recently returned home from the continent to find the life he lived pre-war is at an end. All the friends he shipped out with are dead. As is his young wife, Sarah, to whom he was wed not two days before leaving for the war. With nowhere to turn, Sam soon finds himself in the gutter, addicted to the morphine they’d given him to dull the pain of his war wounds. After the morphine runs out, he turns to opium—a cheaper and more plentiful alternative.
A chance telegram saves Sam’s life. A few months later, Sam Wyndham sets foot on the Indian subcontinent for the first time. His new life as a Captain in the Imperial Police Force in Bengal to begin on the second of April, one day after his arrival. A week later, the body of a senior official is found in the sewer, a note in his mouth warning of a potential insurrection among the natives.
So begins an investigation that will drag Wyndham all across Kolkata—from the slums packed with native Indians to the upscale mansions of the British Elite, from seedy opium dens to the jungles of the rural countryside. A son of the empire and a native son rub elbows in the Imperial Police, while an intoxicating woman split between both worlds may yet steal his heart away. From natives to expats, Wyndham must choose his allies wisely, as there’s no telling which allegiance they hold any more than whose pocket they may be in. The only certainty is that Wyndham must solve this murder and soon, before tensions between the Indians and the Empire boil over.
I stumbled upon A Rising Man while shopping for a Christmas present for my father. While I ultimately did not get him this, I ended up buying it for myself as it sounded so interesting. A historical mystery, A Rising Man does a pretty good job of transporting us to Colonial India—a melting pot of English “civility” and native “savagery”. With Buddhists, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians, Europeans, Indians, and more alike all forced together by the hands of capitalism, Colonial India feels like a caldera waiting to erupt. Abir Mukherjee does an incredible job capturing the atmosphere of the place: the tensions, the humidity, the jungle and predators and flies, the wealth and poverty all jammed together. It’s quite good.
The mystery itself toes the line between fascinating and convoluted, with so enough twists and turns that kept me on my toes throughout. While everything is a bit thick and murky at the outset, the waters eventually cleared enough for me to get a handle on everything as the mystery progressed. While I did call one major reveal very early on, it actually took me quite some time to figure out whodunnit in time for the conclusion. The pacing was a bit stop-start, but I realize that’s a tough ratio to hit, especially for a new author and in a debut series. While it’s not a Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot calibre mystery, A Rising Man kept me easily entertained throughout, and guessing until the final page was turned.
One final note on A Rising Man is the issues it tackles. The story takes place at a global crossroads, where many historically rival cultures compete with one that is very heterogeneous, and used to having its own way. At the time it would’ve been one of the few places on earth with so many different cultures locked in a war against homogenization, as opposed to somewhere like Colonial America where everything seemed to just blend together (well, not everything, sadly). From bigotry to religious discrimination to who and whom its acceptable to love, the story is really set at a very interesting—if incredibly tense—time period. While it does an adequate job of addressing the tension between the English and Bengali people, I would like to see more of the region’s minorities in ethnicity and religion in later books. Additionally, I really would’ve liked to have more of a look into the caste system at this time—which is only rarely mentioned, but never focused on.
TL;DR
A Rising Man combines historical fiction with a complex and engrossing mystery with twists and turns enough to have me guessing until the very end. Though Sam Wyndham isn’t the greatest narrator, he does an adequate job of tackling both the investigation and the region’s tensions. He’s also a bit of git. But while you probably won’t buy A Rising Man for the romance or action, the mystery itself is more than enough of a reason to. All combined with a one of a kind setting that finds opulent wealth rubbing shoulders with crippling poverty and a melting pot of cultures, religions, ideals, and ethnicities, makes A Rising Man a great read, and a mystery you won’t want to put down until the last page is turned.
tibbsy's review against another edition
2.0
Pretty run-of-the-mill detective story, and not one my wife or I enjoyed. Very predictable.
Imperial British Detective fresh out of the war, who lost his love, suffered injuries, and is addicted to drugs goes to a different country for work? Check. Stereotypical native sidekick who helps the detective break down social barriers at the time? Check. A whole slew of racist and misogynist coworkers at the department who the detective proves wrong and puts in their place? Check. A female love interest who is connected to the deceased and the detective becomes entwined with? Check. A murder in which internal and national politics might be involved, including a high-ranking official getting involved suspiciously? Check.
Imperial British Detective fresh out of the war, who lost his love, suffered injuries, and is addicted to drugs goes to a different country for work? Check. Stereotypical native sidekick who helps the detective break down social barriers at the time? Check. A whole slew of racist and misogynist coworkers at the department who the detective proves wrong and puts in their place? Check. A female love interest who is connected to the deceased and the detective becomes entwined with? Check. A murder in which internal and national politics might be involved, including a high-ranking official getting involved suspiciously? Check.
melanto_mori's review against another edition
3.0
Questo è il primo volume di una serie di quattro romanzi (di cui l'ultimo ambientato PRIMA di questo, se non erro - ma non sono andata a leggermi le trame degli altri per evitare eventuali spoiler. Odio gli spoiler XD).
Diciamo che ero partita benissimo, perché aveva tutti gli elementi che potevano interessarmi a prescindere: un giallo, ambientato in India. Ottimo, ero già sua.
Purtroppo la vicenda ha faticato a ingranare. Ho dovuto aspettare di arrivare a pagina 100 per dire "mh, inizia a farsi interessante", ma ciò non significa che dopo sia stato un crescendo fino al finale
Per buona parte della storia, il protagonista non ha fatto altro che girare in tondo e fare cose decisamente inutili nell'economia della vicenda e anche dell'indagine in sé.
Inoltre, ho capito chi era il colpevole praticamente come ha aperto bocca. XD
Punto a suo favore è che la scrittura di Mukherjee è molto scorrevole, una prima persona agile.
Ho trovato che la scelta del tempo di ambientazione mi ha messa un po' in crisi. E non perché l'autore non sia stato bravo, anzi: siamo in un momento in cui l'India non è ancora indipendente dall'Inghilterra e il razzismo così palese mi ha infastidito da morire e mi ha fatto venire voglia di prendere a calci tutti gli inglesi che aprivano bocca. XD Quindi dovrei dire che è un punto a suo favore, se voleva comunque provocare sentimenti forti a riguardo. Trovarmi però proprio da parte del punto di vista inglese mi ha provocato anche l'orticaria, quindi, insomma è stato un lungo digerire (peggio di un pasto della signora Tebbit).
Ho faticato un po' anche a entrare in sintonia col protagonista. Penso che alcuni suoi vizi siano stati un inserimento un po' inutile all'interno della storia, non hanno un vero e proprio peso, ma sembrano quasi delle scuse perché certe cose, più importanti, avvengano. Mah, se devi dare delle ombre a un pg credo che debbano avere un peso rilevante e non spuntare solo al bisogno. Ma vedremo se negli altri volumi la faccenda possa tornare in qualche modo.
Perché, sì, nonostante non mi abbia fatto gridare "al miracolo", penso che leggerò anche gli altri libri - di sicuro quelli ambientati in India, non assicuro sul prequel - e uno dei motivi è perché ho letteralmente ADORATO Surrender-not Banerjee, la spalla del nostro eroe. Per me è il personaggio migliore e che meglio emerge di tutto il romanzo.
In generale: senza infamia e senza lode; si poteva fare meglio. Spero negli altri! :D
Diciamo che ero partita benissimo, perché aveva tutti gli elementi che potevano interessarmi a prescindere: un giallo, ambientato in India. Ottimo, ero già sua.
Purtroppo la vicenda ha faticato a ingranare. Ho dovuto aspettare di arrivare a pagina 100 per dire "mh, inizia a farsi interessante", ma ciò non significa che dopo sia stato un crescendo fino al finale
Spoiler
(finale che pareva uscito da quei film azione targato anni 50'/60', piuttosto citofonati e con questa sequenza d'azione veramente OLDISSIMO style XD Davvero, ho immaginato i personaggi come avvolti da questa pellicola in colore un po' sbiadito, roba alla Gregory Peck).Per buona parte della storia, il protagonista non ha fatto altro che girare in tondo e fare cose decisamente inutili nell'economia della vicenda e anche dell'indagine in sé.
Inoltre, ho capito chi era il colpevole praticamente come ha aperto bocca. XD
Punto a suo favore è che la scrittura di Mukherjee è molto scorrevole, una prima persona agile.
Ho trovato che la scelta del tempo di ambientazione mi ha messa un po' in crisi. E non perché l'autore non sia stato bravo, anzi: siamo in un momento in cui l'India non è ancora indipendente dall'Inghilterra e il razzismo così palese mi ha infastidito da morire e mi ha fatto venire voglia di prendere a calci tutti gli inglesi che aprivano bocca. XD Quindi dovrei dire che è un punto a suo favore, se voleva comunque provocare sentimenti forti a riguardo. Trovarmi però proprio da parte del punto di vista inglese mi ha provocato anche l'orticaria, quindi, insomma è stato un lungo digerire (peggio di un pasto della signora Tebbit).
Ho faticato un po' anche a entrare in sintonia col protagonista. Penso che alcuni suoi vizi siano stati un inserimento un po' inutile all'interno della storia, non hanno un vero e proprio peso, ma sembrano quasi delle scuse perché certe cose, più importanti, avvengano. Mah, se devi dare delle ombre a un pg credo che debbano avere un peso rilevante e non spuntare solo al bisogno. Ma vedremo se negli altri volumi la faccenda possa tornare in qualche modo.
Perché, sì, nonostante non mi abbia fatto gridare "al miracolo", penso che leggerò anche gli altri libri - di sicuro quelli ambientati in India, non assicuro sul prequel - e uno dei motivi è perché ho letteralmente ADORATO Surrender-not Banerjee, la spalla del nostro eroe. Per me è il personaggio migliore e che meglio emerge di tutto il romanzo.
Spoiler
E IO LO SHIPPO COL PROTAGONISTA. I REGRET NOTHING! Non mi importa quando Sam sia stato sposato, abbia il mezzo interesse amoroso per una tipa o per la qualunque, li shippo. XDIn generale: senza infamia e senza lode; si poteva fare meglio. Spero negli altri! :D
atomecko's review
adventurous
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
dana_yakobchuk's review against another edition
adventurous
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.0
fellrnr's review against another edition
informative
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
desolation73's review against another edition
4.0
A really enjoyable historical fiction set in India in 1919.
lindseypeapod's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
3.5