Harrowing at times but unflinching in its determination to make us see the gaping logical holes in our carnist practices

作为一个非素食主义者,我更多的是以批判性的目光看这本书,希望收获一些我所不知道的知识和角度。如果以此来作为评判标准,那么这本书达到了我一开始的目的。但是我又更希望这本"award winning"的书能更加理性的陈述观点,说服我成为vegan/vegetarian, 抑或是vegan ally。

这本书阅读起来给我一种还有更多研究需要完成,更多直接的证据支撑作者的观点,更全面的告知读者vegan的好处与坏处,而不是单纯的抨击carnism。

Hmmm lol. I’ve been vegetarian for a few years for many of the reasons presented: sanctity of life, not wanting to participate in another being’s suffering, etc. this book started off as an interesting look into the meat industry and commentary on the seemingly standard feelings toward meat in society. Maybe it was on me for expecting a more philosophical discussion, but the author suddenly WENT NUTS on insisting that vegans have “broken free of the matrix.” She makes comparisons to the holocaust as well so heads up on that. I feel like this book could have been so much more, and in being less slanted may have achieved its greater aim to reach a greater audience. For me, this seems like a book for vegans who already think this way.
blackcatranch's profile picture

blackcatranch's review

5.0

If you consider yourself a compassionate person and you still eat meat - I beg you to read this book! Overall it is a very good & quick read without being preachy. The author offers a an unpacking of the invisible backpack of entitlement of human superiority. This book discusses the cognitive games we play to justify the widespread Holocaust of non-human animals and offers a different perspective for viewing the way we look at our place in life on this planet.
challenging dark informative inspiring reflective sad tense fast-paced

4.4
challenging reflective fast-paced
informative

Un ensayo interesante para quienes se inician en el vegetarianismo o quieren saber más sobre el funcionamiento del sistema. Más allá de los capitulos 2 y 3 en los que realmente se moja y presenta testimonios (muy duros, por cierto), siento que es muy superficial y se limita a una acumulación de datos que no son ninguna revelación para quienes ya estamos introducidos en este mundo.

laurieluna's profile picture

laurieluna's review

5.0

Going to take some time to think about this one.