Scan barcode
gijanechosen's review against another edition
3.0
Got this book as a gift from a friend. It is a nice collection of poems by Longfellow, both short and lengthy (for a poem).
towardinfinitybooks's review against another edition
2.0
This edition of selected poems by Longfellow features the epic poem "Evangeline", which narrates the tale of two lovers separated during "The Great Upheaval", or Britain's forced removal of the Acadian people to the American colonies during the French and Indian War. The poem relies heavily on natural imagery and invocations of the Trinity, and is written in dactylic hexameter, which was also used for Homer's [b:Illiad|692108|Illiad and Odyssey of Homer|Barbara Leonie Picard|http://www.goodreads.com/assets/nocover/60x80.png|678446] and [b:Odyssey|1381|The Odyssey|Homer|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1349112871s/1381.jpg|3356006].
Despite really liking some of the other (shorter) poems in this collection, I'm not a huge fan of this poem. The natural descriptions are stunning and surprisingly, the poem is easy to read despite the meter (I remember finding Homer difficult in high school). But the story doesn't resonate with me.
I suspect that my reaction may be tainted with my position as a 21st-century reader as opposed to a 19th-century reader. For one thing, I think the readers of the 19th century had longer attention spans than I do. Forty-seven pages of metered poetry was a struggle. Also, I can't help but feel that the story of separated lovers wandering the lands in search of each other year after year after year may have been a newer concept to those readers of the past. Or maybe it's that they had a particular fascination with the colonies and early America welcoming the distressed Acadians, uprooted from their homes by common-enemy Britain. Longfellow was known (and criticized) for giving readers what they wanted.
Apparently, Longfellow's account of "The Great Upheaval" has long been considered the most popular (though biased) version. There is even a monument dedicated to the fictional Evangeline in Louisiana. I'm glad I read the poem as it was Longfellow's most-read work, but I had more luck with other poems such as "Carillon" and "Mezzo Cammin."
Despite really liking some of the other (shorter) poems in this collection, I'm not a huge fan of this poem. The natural descriptions are stunning and surprisingly, the poem is easy to read despite the meter (I remember finding Homer difficult in high school). But the story doesn't resonate with me.
I suspect that my reaction may be tainted with my position as a 21st-century reader as opposed to a 19th-century reader. For one thing, I think the readers of the 19th century had longer attention spans than I do. Forty-seven pages of metered poetry was a struggle. Also, I can't help but feel that the story of separated lovers wandering the lands in search of each other year after year after year may have been a newer concept to those readers of the past. Or maybe it's that they had a particular fascination with the colonies and early America welcoming the distressed Acadians, uprooted from their homes by common-enemy Britain. Longfellow was known (and criticized) for giving readers what they wanted.
Apparently, Longfellow's account of "The Great Upheaval" has long been considered the most popular (though biased) version. There is even a monument dedicated to the fictional Evangeline in Louisiana. I'm glad I read the poem as it was Longfellow's most-read work, but I had more luck with other poems such as "Carillon" and "Mezzo Cammin."
cgcpoems's review against another edition
It's difficult for me to rate this. On one hand, the language was lovely. On the other hand, it was laid on a bit thick in parts. On a third hand, these poems were written in the 1800's so who am I to really judge pieces written so far away from where I am?
I'll just say that I'm glad I read these poems, and Evangeline was very interesting, but Longfellow isn't a poet that intrigues me as much as other writers from his time.
I'll just say that I'm glad I read these poems, and Evangeline was very interesting, but Longfellow isn't a poet that intrigues me as much as other writers from his time.
mikagatsby's review against another edition
4.0
I wasn't prepared at how good this book was! Evangeline broke my heart. "So close yet so far." Sigh.
More...