Scan barcode
kimball_hansen's review against another edition
4.0
So glad this series is back again. Pittacus did a terrific job of giving us new content and expounding the story line/going off into a tangent instead of just regurgitating the same ol' stuff like some authors do. I wonder at what point he decided to continue those story/go off into the tangent.
Minor complaints:
I wish the author had given more backstory because it's been a few years since I finished United as One. So I was unfamiliar with a few things. He was severely lacking in the details department. So there are still Mogs around? What happened to Six and Seven or Adam? I bet Five will come back somehow and be a bad guy again.
All these POVs are hard to keep track of. But I did like that we get to see what it's like for the humans to become the Garde. This was a good story but was a little hard to follow in parts, maybe because I was too busy concentrating on Plablo. It was fun to listen to a book agian while playing so I can cement memories of the story as I am wont to do.
Minor complaints:
I wish the author had given more backstory because it's been a few years since I finished United as One. So I was unfamiliar with a few things. He was severely lacking in the details department. So there are still Mogs around? What happened to Six and Seven or Adam? I bet Five will come back somehow and be a bad guy again.
All these POVs are hard to keep track of. But I did like that we get to see what it's like for the humans to become the Garde. This was a good story but was a little hard to follow in parts, maybe because I was too busy concentrating on Plablo. It was fun to listen to a book agian while playing so I can cement memories of the story as I am wont to do.
anderpa's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
vidhi26p's review against another edition
4.0
3.5 Stars
This was a starkly contrasting novel in comparison to the original Lorien Legacy series. First and foremost, the characters aren’t introduced cautiously and organically, but are rather thrown into the readers face, as we start off with 4 different POVs. Which is normal and fine usually, but felt awkward in this world and vastly different from what I expected. Second, the stakes are considerably lowered as our new cast of heroes are no longer fighting for the survival of the world as we know it and instead are merely fighting smaller battles. Untrained and green, these heroes are thrust into the throes of battle against their greatest enemy — themselves.
Overall, if you’re yearning for a return to the world Pittacus Lore splendidly illustrated in the Lorien Legacies, this novel isn’t for you. Besides our devilishly handsome and favorite Garde Nine — this is a new generation with new battles to fight and the background with the Mogadorian Invasion might as well not even have occurred for its importance in this novel and the lives of most of the characters. As lovely as it was hearing Nine’s vivid insults again, this remained your average “teens with superpowers fight supposed bad guys” novel with its stereotypical tropes — nothing remotely close to the magnificence of its predecessor series. Nonetheless, if read for pure entertainment and without begetting comparison to the Lorien Legacies, it still remains a fairly mediocre and passable work of fantasy.
This was a starkly contrasting novel in comparison to the original Lorien Legacy series. First and foremost, the characters aren’t introduced cautiously and organically, but are rather thrown into the readers face, as we start off with 4 different POVs. Which is normal and fine usually, but felt awkward in this world and vastly different from what I expected. Second, the stakes are considerably lowered as our new cast of heroes are no longer fighting for the survival of the world as we know it and instead are merely fighting smaller battles. Untrained and green, these heroes are thrust into the throes of battle against their greatest enemy — themselves.
Overall, if you’re yearning for a return to the world Pittacus Lore splendidly illustrated in the Lorien Legacies, this novel isn’t for you. Besides our devilishly handsome and favorite Garde Nine — this is a new generation with new battles to fight and the background with the Mogadorian Invasion might as well not even have occurred for its importance in this novel and the lives of most of the characters. As lovely as it was hearing Nine’s vivid insults again, this remained your average “teens with superpowers fight supposed bad guys” novel with its stereotypical tropes — nothing remotely close to the magnificence of its predecessor series. Nonetheless, if read for pure entertainment and without begetting comparison to the Lorien Legacies, it still remains a fairly mediocre and passable work of fantasy.
alucinadalibros's review against another edition
5.0
Pittacus Lore nunca decepcionan!!! si bien apenas empecé a leer el libro me costó engancharme, conocer a los nuevos protagonistas... los autores saben cómo entretener! sin caer en la historia repetida, siguen con la dinámica de la Garde, sin aburrir. muy muy bueno! espero ansiosa el próximo!! 😍
knynas1's review against another edition
4.0
4 ⭐
Great start to another series in the I Am Number Four world! This book follows human guard who developed legacies during and after the invasion. The human guard are sent to an academy run in part by Nine and Malcom Goode. Full of action and intrigue!
Great start to another series in the I Am Number Four world! This book follows human guard who developed legacies during and after the invasion. The human guard are sent to an academy run in part by Nine and Malcom Goode. Full of action and intrigue!
aposternak's review against another edition
adventurous
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
sandmoe's review against another edition
3.0
generation one is a COMEDY compared to i am number four
booksandlemonsquash's review against another edition
3.0
I enjoyed this but it really didn’t get going til right at the end. There are too many new characters and not enough explanations about what’s going on - you’re left to assume a fair bit. I’m looking forward to more though as the end held real promise about where this is going.
e_robertson1989's review against another edition
5.0
I've read the entirety of the Lorien Legacies and the Lorien Legacies Reborn multiple times, and each time I enjoy it more. I wholeheartedly believe my favourite scene in the whole series is where Isabella imitates Nine to beat the challenge.
paige_georgia_reads's review against another edition
adventurous
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25
Some of the characters irked me a little, and I think there was a bit of an odd change to Nine's personality to make some of the plot worked. All the characters do have some interesting motivations for the actions they take.