lalala123987's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I listened to these, and I loved the first story (by Philippa Ballantine). I had to stop both the second and third party way through. The reading in the second was painful to the my ears. The 3rd was the first Nathan Lowell story I have ever disliked (prior to this 4 stars is the lowest I have ever rated his work), being correct to the period came through as so painfully racist I couldn't stomach it. I'm not going to try any more of them.

beulahhatchet's review

Go to review page

3.0

I liked it and it was nice to learn some back story for all the little references in Phoenix Rising. However,the part where the guy kisses the grieving widow while she's being attacked by her dead husband is far-fetched.
More...