Reviews

Howard Wallace, P.I. by Casey Lyall

hasnow's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Absolutely hilarious. This would be a great book to read aloud, if I had any reason to do so. Howard's private investigator inner monologue made me laugh out loud on multiple occasions. I was worried I might get sick of it after the first few chapters, but it toned down once he develops a partnership/friendship with Ivy.

evaosterlee's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous funny mysterious fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

msvenner's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Part of my effort to read this year's Blue Spruce Forest of Reading program nominees. I feel like I'm still learning this genre and age range so don't feel I can fairly review however, knowing my own 11 year old, I wasn't sure this was engaging or intriguing enough to warrent an award.

lazygal's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Cute, and reminded me of Grisham's Theodore Boone series.

ARC provided by publisher.

tiffani_reads's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Howard Wallace is exactly the type of person that I would want working my case if I was ever being blackmailed. This book was seriously fun! Howard and Ivy make a great team and the witty banner plus old school detective speak was just awesome. This book was throughly entertaining and I couldn’t put it down.

asolodkin's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I received this as a Goodreads giveaway.

This book was really great! I enjoyed the characters and the tweeny mystery. Looking forward to handing this off to the kids. And maybe following some more Howard Wallace adventures in the future. Nothing negative to say at all, it was an enjoyable read start to finish.

jbrooxd's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Such a fun mystery! I love Howard (for teachers, he would be a great example of voice when you talk about writing). I love how he and Ivy come together. I loved the caper/case and how it worked out. Can't wait to read more of Howard and Ivy's adventures!!

scostner's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Take your average middle school boy. He has a couple of close friends and they enjoy comics, hanging out together, and dressing up like super heroes on Halloween. But one friend's growth spurt lands him on all the sports teams and he becomes an uber-jock. The second friend moves away. And the last friend is left to survive middle school alone. What does he do? Well, if he happens to be Howard Wallace, he decides to become a detective. Howard loves film noir detective stories and studies them for technique and style. He creates the Rules of Private Investigation based on his film heroes. Since he doesn't own a trench coat, he wears a brown bathrobe (rule #1 -work with what you've got). He's already solved a case of vandalism at the local pawn shop, so now he's building his reputation and his clientele. That's where we as readers enter the story.

Howard takes on several cases at the beginning of the book. There is the problem of a neighbor's missing cat. A girl wants to know who the secret admirer is that keeps leaving things in her locker. Another kid whose trumpet has gone missing and who doesn't want to spend the year stuck in the recorder section asks Howard for help. An elementary school student needs help finding the action figure he spent all his savings on. And then there is Meredith - the treasurer of the student council. Someone is blackmailing her and their threat is serious; if she doesn't resign, the blackmailer will tell everyone that she lost the council's checkbook. How can one P.I. solve all of these mysteries and still keep up with homework and chores?

As luck would have it, there is a new girl who is bored with everything in the small town of Grantleyville. Ivy is used to the big city and latches onto Howard as the only person doing anything interesting. So he now has a junior partner on a trial basis. They stake out lockers, interview suspects and potential witnesses, and generally get on everyone's nerves. After being taken to the principal's office, Howard is grounded by his parents and told he can never investigate again. But would Philip Marlowe let that stop him? He just has to be more stealthy than normal.

Despite drawbacks like an older sister who calls him "Howeird," a 30-year-old bicycle that has seen better days, and being the target of two hulking bullies, Howard still maintains client confidentiality and does his best to close very case. All the elements of middle school are there - the cliques, the clubs, the changing relationships between friends as they grow up, the teachers, and the bad cafeteria food. There is also the ambiance of the small town with the local "royalty" who own the majority of the businesses and expect their children to be the stars of the school, the gossip that lets everyone know when there is trouble, and the type of neighborhoods where kids still ride their bikes to school.

Howard is funny, smart, determined, and I really enjoy the way he talks as if he is in one of those movie he enjoys so much. A middle school kid saying things like his investigation "would be a lot easier if I didn't have an interfering lookie-loo horning in on the job," or asking his junior partner, "Are you gonna be shirty or work this case with me?" has got to tickle your funny bone. And if that's not enough, the way he calls all the other students "kid" like he's Humphrey Bogart will do the trick. And Ivy has her own quirks that add to the odd-couple charm of the story.

Highly recommended for fans of school mysteries and buddy stories (even the unlikely buddies of a loner who thinks he's a P.I. and a city girl looking for some excitement). Readers will have a new character to admire and the hope of new mysteries for Wallace Investigations to solve.

I received an advance copy from the publisher for review purposes.

lenni_loves_literature's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

"She didn't knock, just barged through like she owned the place. She did own it, but that was beside the point." These are the first sentences in the book Howard Wallace, P.I. Reading them, I felt like they sounded like some cheesy, black and white detective movie. And THAT is what drew me in from the very beginning.

I guess you could say that Howard Wallace is the stereotypical teen boy. "Luckily, I had two bananas browning on my bookshelf so I didn't have to waste any time gathering breakfast." Howard isn't afraid of getting in a little trouble and he can be pretty rude to some adults. So, if you are worried about your children finding Howard Wallace a bad influence, your fears are pretty rational.

Howard could be sweet at times, like on page 54(I'm not saying what happens because it becomes more important later on in the book). He was also a little bad at trusting others since he had been hurt in the past which is something I can totally relate to. All in all, I think Howard was a cool guy, but maybe he needs to stick up for himself a little more.

Enough about Howard, let's talk about Ivy. Ivy was pretty cool chiz and she's also been hurt in the past so it's perfect that she met Howard. Ivy kind of reminded me of a different Ivy from the book The World's Greatest Detective by Caroline Carlson. They both wanted to solve mysteries and had their ways of getting what they want. I like characters with those kinds of personalities.

I give Howard Wallace a 3 star rating and I know now who I'm going to be calling if I'm ever stuck in a blackmailing situation.

amiew's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This kids mystery is told in the style of Dashiell Hammett and Raymond Chandler and features Howard Wallace, a middle school Sam Spade or Phillip Marlowe. Even though kids won't get the old school detective references, they'll appreciate a humorous story about friendship.