Scan barcode
nobodyspoet's review
3.5
Woefully lopsided, it feels disingenuous to label this as a Beatles biography when in reality it's "John and, by proximity, Paul" with Ringo forever as the comic relief and George as a static portrait, if he's remembered at all. Seriously, it's amazing to me how much I had to learn about John Lennon when, in a book so focused on deconstructing the archetypes of early Beatlemania, George was relegated to the quiet one who either mooned (quietly) or lost his temper (quickly), with a mere footnote at the end to essentially say he lived and he died, and Ringo just sort of floating in and out of the frame, with his seemingly largest contribution being how many times he got physically picked up and swung around (I got to three before I stopped counting).
That said, I especially found the beginning, pre-fame telling to be intriguing, but I wish anything that came after Help! got even half that long-winded treatment. It's as if the editor came through and realized just how big this book was and started lopping off the end. Honestly, with a book this long, I think you just have to commit, so if it needs to crack 900 or more pages of actual book, not including notes and attributions, then do it. I never thought I'd be implying I wish this book was longer, but I'd have been all for it.
The thing is, though, I still read all 857 pages, and was genuinely engaged for my entire three week read time. I've previously read Spitz's Julia Child biography and adored it, and it's all due to how downright accessible his writing feels. Not too dry, not too many glaring liberties taken; it's comprehensive without pandering and moves along really well. I looked forward to picking this book up each day, and can see myself reading more of Spitz's work in the future. I honestly think it just comes down to the fact that, for figures with such large legends looming overhead, there's so much to tell, and Spitz, better suited to focus on just one subject, falters in balancing a large primary cast of characters.
That said, I especially found the beginning, pre-fame telling to be intriguing, but I wish anything that came after Help! got even half that long-winded treatment. It's as if the editor came through and realized just how big this book was and started lopping off the end. Honestly, with a book this long, I think you just have to commit, so if it needs to crack 900 or more pages of actual book, not including notes and attributions, then do it. I never thought I'd be implying I wish this book was longer, but I'd have been all for it.
The thing is, though, I still read all 857 pages, and was genuinely engaged for my entire three week read time. I've previously read Spitz's Julia Child biography and adored it, and it's all due to how downright accessible his writing feels. Not too dry, not too many glaring liberties taken; it's comprehensive without pandering and moves along really well. I looked forward to picking this book up each day, and can see myself reading more of Spitz's work in the future. I honestly think it just comes down to the fact that, for figures with such large legends looming overhead, there's so much to tell, and Spitz, better suited to focus on just one subject, falters in balancing a large primary cast of characters.
samcarlin's review
5.0
I loved this book. This is one of the most detailed Beatles book I have read. There was so much information about the Beatles, and having read several Beatles biographies there was still a lot that I didn't know. Very interesting from start to finish!
loonyboi's review
5.0
An excellent, well researched, very readable biography of The Beatles. If I have any complaint, it's that the book ends when the band does. Which is a shame, since there's so much more to say about each member.
But really, it's a great book. And I suppose it says something that my only issue with this thousand page book is that it's over too soon. Highly recommended.
But really, it's a great book. And I suppose it says something that my only issue with this thousand page book is that it's over too soon. Highly recommended.
5easypieces's review
5.0
Even as a huge Beatles fan that thought he knew just about all there was to know, this book presented plenty of surprises. Thoroughly researched, and engagingly written. Highly recommended.
adevans16's review
3.0
It's a huge doorstop without a real thesis, but the research is good. I enjoyed it. My favorite Yoko story: sick after a miscarriage, she has a bed brought into the studio with a microphone nearby so that she can comment on what the band is doing.