thestarman's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Adventure, creatures, wizards, witches, thieves, swordplay, love & loss, and some light humor.

Three standout stories, one that was almost nonsensical, and the rest somewhere between adequate and good. Authors both established and first-time published here, as of 1985.

Overall it feels like a 3.5 to me, but I'm rounding to 4 as I'm no expert on the fantasy genre. I thought it a bit better than Book #1, which I gave 3 stars.
More...