Reviews

Craft: Everyday Magic for Modern Witches by Gabriela Herstik

treewitchrey's review against another edition

Go to review page

A sleek informative modern overview of magic, but for me maybe stayed too superficially on all the different approaches. I did like the tone, but in the end i guess it's not what i needed at the moment!

kimlovesstuff's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Great beginners guide

Really comprehensive guide for beginners, resonates more than say 'To Ride A Silver Broomstick' as far more contemporary. That being said, not loads here from more experienced witch types.

sjbnxo's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

DNF, like 30-odd pages in. Terrible. Please do not use the term "Smudge" and don't use white sage or palo santo. This is cultural appropriation. I'm fairly new and always going to be learning and evolving but this feels too instagrammy to me.

feliciavanleeuwen's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Nice introduction for people beginning their journey, haven't read every tit bit yet but take it out when I want to look something up. Love the short tarot schedule.

katemaxwell's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative inspiring medium-paced

3.0

slutforhotwings's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative inspiring reflective medium-paced

3.5

laurenvoice's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A perfect book for anyone interested in witchcraft. Very informative with details, excellent for beginners or those who want to learn more about their ancestors.

emiloid_reads's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Fine as a guide to the super beginner witch, and I liked the beginning bits on meditations, casting a circle, and rituals for each Sabbat. I didn't like the way the book tended to touch on different potentially interesting topics but not really get into them in any substantial way, like kitchen magic and contacting fae.

onceuponabookcase's review

Go to review page

5.0

4.5 Stars.

Craft by Gabriela Herstik is one of the books I've had my eye on for a while, and when I was finally able to buy it, I started reading it right away and flew through it. This book is fantastic!

What I loved most about this book is Herstik's focus on how no-one's practice looks quite the same, and every witch must find their own path. Craft is the first book I've read to really emphasise this. Other books have mentioned it, but then gone on to explain witchcraft and the various aspects of it, bu Herstik comes back to it time and again; "You could say something like this," "You can adapt this," "Some witches believe this, but if this doesn't work for you, that's fine." I'm paraphrasing, she might not use those exact words, but this is her theme throughout; she's not necessarily telling you what you should or shouldn't do, she explains things, she gives spells and rituals you can adapt, she gives advice and suggestions - always emphasising that you should do you. While reading the books on witchcraft previous to this, I've been feeling a little lost, when things were discussed that didn't really fit for me, so it was amazing to have Herstik emphasise that this is your practice and your spiritual journey.

I also loved Herstik's voice. Not only does she write as if she's having a conversation with you, but she allows her personality to shine through, too. Her passion and enthusiasm, even swearing - she's fully put herself into this book, which made me feel more relaxed while reading; it's like having a conversation with a friend, and one who actually cares. She's helpful, and down to earth, comes across as being approachable. I just felt like I trusted her, and the suggestions/advice she was giving.

There were a number of things in this book that wouldn't personally work for me, but I'm with Herstik's focus on finding our own paths, I actually felt ok about it. And really, the more I read about what isn't going to work for me, the clearer I'm getting on what my own path is becoming, which is so helpful. And it's so interesting to learn about the way other people practice. So even though there were a number of things that aren't right for me, it's still such an incredible book. The subtitle of Craft is How to Be a Modern Witch, and you really feel that that's what Herstik is. Especially with the chapter on Glamour Magick, which hasn't been mentioned in any other book I've read so far; the use of clothing, make-up and accessories in magick. It was fascinating!

There was also a lot of astrology which is just so helpful! I've been reading various witch's blogs online, and your personal astrology has been emphasised a lot, but there hasn't been much on working out what your birth chart means, but Herstik really breaks it down for you - and gives a lot more info than Practical Magic did. I'd already ordered a book on astrology before reading Craft, but it'll probably go into more depth so it's fine, but I think Craft would be really useful for at least starting to get to grips with your birth chart - I just suggest having your birth chart in front of you as you read this chapter, unlike I did the first time round, which caused a little confusion as not having anything to relate what was being said to (Herstik gives a number of websites where you can generate your birth chart for free).

I think it's important to point out that Herstik talks about "smudging" - a Native American practice - with white sage or palo santo - which are both endangered due to over harvesting - to cleanse your space, and also lists Moon goddesses from various cultures, and suggests working with whichever one catches your eye. This can be seen as cultural appropriation. However, I should also point out that Herstik has a video up on Instagram where she discusses what she's learnt in the year since Craft has been published, and addresses the use of the term "smudging", and the burning white sage and palo santo, and how she's learnt since publishing and now doesn't use any of them - the term or the specific herbs.

All in all, Craft is an incredible book, and one I know I'll be dipping in and out of as needed. Herstik has another book coming out at some point, and I'll definitely be picking it up. I really can't recommend Craft (or Inner Witch in the US) enough; it really is everything someone new to witchcraft could want in a guide. I'll leave you from a quote from the end of the book that had me really emotional:


'Your energy is sacred, your energy is powerful and your energy is transformative. May you never forget who you are: an incredible, powerful, worthy witch. May your magick grow as you do. May it evolve as you do, and may it help you bring a deeper sense of purpose and meaning to everything you do. With a blessing from the Earth and the Cosmos, with a blessing from me to you, with a blessing from the Universe, find your magick, find your path - and know in your bones that it is your truth.' (p280)

stephb85's review

Go to review page

5.0

I've read quite a few books on the Craft over the past 20 years and it's always fun to get a fresh perspective from new authors. The chapter on glamour and fashion was especially fascinating.