Reviews

Welcoming Elijah: A Passover Tale with a Tail by Lesléa Newman, Susan Gal

mldavisreads's review

Go to review page

hopeful reflective
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.0

Children's picture book.  I had seen this book discussed in various places and wanted to read and review it before the Passover season started so other readers could find it.  Inside, a Jewish family shares the traditional Seder to start Passover. Outside, a young kitten wanders alone.  As the text progresses, the parallels between the outside scene and the inside one increase.  When the young boy opens the door to see if the prophet Elijah has come, the kitten bolts in, earning itself the name Elijah and a new home.  Lovely illustrations and a sweet story.  This text is informative, but is a more interesting story than a straightforward "this is what the Passover meal looks like" story would be.

tashrow's review

Go to review page

4.0

In a warm, brightly lit home, a Seder is about to start. Outside sits a lonely kitten, looking at the festivities through the window. Guests arrive to the Seder and it begins lit by candles that glow out into the dark night where the kitten sits. The boy washes his hands, dips parsley into salt water, breaks matzo, and listens to the tale of the Israelites leaving Egypt. Outside, the kitten washes his paws, eats a wet blade of grass, drinks from a puddle, and waits. Songs are sung inside and the kitten mewls outdoors. Finally, the door is opened for the prophet Elijah to enter, bringing peace. When the boy opens the door, there is the white kitten who found a home and a name, Elijah.

Newman’s text moves back and forth between the Seder and the darkness outside, cleverly tying the two together in small moments that echo one another. The beauty and solemnity of the Seder works in harmony with the beauty of the night outside and yet contrasts against it as well with the lone kitten and the house full of people. The text is simple and graceful, completed by an Author’s Note that offers more details about Passover, Seders and Ellijah.

The illustrations are done in ink, charcoal and digital collage. They use warm yellows for the indoor Seder and blues and blacks for the night outside. Readers will glimpse the indoor scenes from the kitten’s perspective as well as the darkness outside from inside the home. That connection is maintained throughout the book.

A lovely Passover book with whiskers. Appropriate for ages 2-4.
More...