Reviews with content warning for Grief - The Incendiaries

How do you judge Will’s character? He starts off innocent and safe and changes into someone unrecognizable. Obsessed with Phoebe, he becomes coercive, controlling, ultimately raping her. While there is clearly self-loathing happening, he doesn’t seem particularly remorseful. I think he’s an untrustworthy narrator. His perspective is the most represented so it makes the many questions this books ends with even more mysterious. What actually happened? Is Phoebe alive or is that a part of Will’s delusion?

R.O. Kwon is a phenomenal writer.

Content Warnings

kry_yang's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional reflective sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.0

Honestly a forgettable read for me. I almost DNF-ed in the middle, because there wasn't really any deep substance (plot, character, theme, or style-wise) that was compelling enough for me to pick it up. But the book is a super fast read, so I figured I should still finish it just to say that I read this book.

I think The Incendiaries attempts to tackle concepts like religious fanaticism, faith, love, and grief. I couldn't really connect with any the characters though. RO Kwon really takes her time developing a dream-like, surreal vibe to the entire story, but her style just left me feeling confused and frustrated. While reading, I kept getting the characters' perspectives mixed up. The ending was my favorite part of the book, but I think that's only because something concrete and action-worthy actually happens in the last 50 pages. I feel like this is the type of book where, despite reading the entire story, I still need to refer to the back of the cover when describing it to someone else.

I think R.O. Kwon is a really talented writer (and an overall super-cool person). But nothing is this book *really* worked for me. There was beautiful language, some poignant descriptions of characters' meditations on faith, and I did get some dark-academia vibes with the Noxhurst college setting. Unfortunately, that's pretty much everything I enjoyed about this book.

Content Warnings

maryy_r0se's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional mysterious reflective sad tense slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

"I ate pain. I swilled tears. If I could take enough in, I'd have no space left to fit my own."

Every so often, I read a book that I just cannot get out of my head. This is certainly one of those books.

Will Kendall transfers to Edwards University after abandoning his fundamentalist Christian beliefs and subsequently, leaving his Bible School behind as well. He meets Phoebe Lin, an infectious and enigmatic young woman who is struggling with guilt after her mother's death. He is immediately drawn to her, and the two embark in a relationship. Things begin to fracture, however, as Phoebe grows closer to John Leal, a charismatic religious leader who Will is unable to trust.

With breathtaking, descriptive prose, R.O. Kwon reveals the ugly, complex side of faith. This story provides the most masterful and nuanced interpretation of religious trauma that I have ever witnessed. Though the story is mainly told from Will's perspective, Phoebe and John also share the narration, although even then, Will acts as a sort of vessel for their stories. While Will provided an interesting and resentful view of religion, it was Phoebe's sections that I looked forward to the most. That said, if you are looking for likable characters, look elsewhere.

Will, who begins the book as an ambiguous, morally gray narrator, becomes utterly irredeemable about 3/4 in. I will admit that after Will's unforgivable act, I was a bit conflicted on the book. In retrospect, as horrific as it was, it does make sense for his character. By the book's end, the most sympathetic character was Phoebe, a five-time murderess and Christian terrorist.

If you're looking for a compelling view of religion through the eyes of three narrators who are all corrupt in different ways, this may be the book for you.

I unfortunately think that the publishers may have failed this novel, because the most common description of the book feels inaccurate and incomplete. The story does not focus on Will's search for Phoebe; that section makes up about 10% of the book at most. The story focuses on the events leading up to the event, and Will witnessing Phoebe's descent into extremism. It focuses on a toxic relationship just as much as it focuses on the dangers associated with religion.

The prose in this novel is some of the best prose I have ever read, alongside Donna Tartt, Scott Heim, and Jeffrey Eugenides. If you don't like descriptive prose, it may not be for you. The best way to explain how gorgeous it can be is to give an example, and the book's final passage is the best example there is. The passage states:

That morning in June, when I'd seen Julian, I went down into the Columbus Circle station. It was loud inside, the platform more crowded than usual. I sighted the source of the tumult: a band of six male dancers, in white latex tights. With bodies liberated from gravity's laws, they swung out of handsprings into lithe spins. More people turned to watch while an express train hurtled in, the gust of wind nudging thin fabric around bare arms and thighs. The wind blew through, until it looked as if the entire population might float up out of the tunnel, cracking through its stone and earth, into the day's hot light. We can all go. No one gets left behind. The world's graves fling open, the giddied, dirt-stained dead rushing toward the streets of gold, alive again, at last. The wind settled. In minutes, the local train arrived. I pushed in, then I kept waiting.

I cannot wait to read everything else Kwon has ever written and will ever write. This book will stick with me for a long, long time.

Content Warnings

mikaelaandherbooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark mysterious reflective medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? N/A
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.0

A very interesting fictional novel that tugs at the conversation of religion versus cult, and has a great mix of mystery/thriller elements to it.

Content Warnings

More...