Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.1 AVERAGE
4.1 AVERAGE
challenging
dark
emotional
informative
inspiring
mysterious
reflective
sad
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
This is my first Tana French book, and I absolutely loved it. It's kind of like everything rolled into one, mystery/suspense/drama/literature and even a little bit of romance. I did the audible version of this, and the narrator was fantastic. Everything came together so well, and the author did a great job of developing each individual character and seeing them through to the end. I'm just now realizing this is book two of a series, so I'm looking forward to book one, as it will explain some of the things about Cassie's previous partner that I didn't quite get all of in this one.
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
Disappointing follow up to In The Woods. Trying to suspend my belief that this mission would exist in a world similar to reality, was too much of a stretch for me.
dark
mysterious
sad
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
This book is tricky to review. It's the follow up to the wonderful In the Woods, and features the partner of In the Wood's protagonist. It is well-written, creepy, with a really interesting plot line. I didn't like it as much as In the Woods, even though the writing was still very strong. The plot line was just slightly too unbelievable, and the ending threw in some curves that didn't add in anything to the story except drama that didn't fit in the last few pages. Overall, it was a disappointing sequel. I'll pick up the third in the series, hoping this was just a case of a sophomore slump.
Female detective on a case where a young woman who looks just like her has been found dead. Detective goes undercover as the dead girl.
Very good surprising ending. I just wanted some explanation of how they looked like twins without actually being related.
Very good surprising ending. I just wanted some explanation of how they looked like twins without actually being related.
The whodunnit aspect was interesting and kept me reading. The narrator’s constant ruminating about her undercover role wasn’t the most interesting.
4.75 stars
IF YOU CLICKED ON THIS REVIEW WITHOUT HAVING READ THE BOOK, BE WARNED: IT SPOILS EVERYTHING. EVERYTHING. DO NOT READ.
This book SERIOUSLY had almost everything I wanted. An undercover op, strange university students with even stranger secrets, Ireland as a Setting, not a setting. In no particularly order, here were the things I liked:
1) Cassie is cool AF. Her infiltration of a group of sinister students is nearly seamless, but it's not just the stuff she does right. She has a flaw--identifying too much with Lexie Madison. She withholds evidence, defies direct orders, and messes with her recording device. The first time she did something like that, I was annoyed. It seemed more like something the author wanted than Cassie. But as the story went on, it became obvious that the flaw was not with Tana French, but with Cassie. She's still awesome, though! Love you!
2) The students she's infiltrating had distinct personalities, and I got to know each of them. From creepy creepy creepy Daniel (blank eyes hidden by glasses are ALWAYS creepy) to adorable (murderous) Justin to suave Rafe to Abby, whom I'd kind of like to be best friends with, each housemate flew off the page.
3) To keep this list short, I'll stick to three things. Off the top of my head, another thing I loved was the Irish history and Whitehorn house. It's really the history and the picture of Ireland that makes this book not just a mystery, but literary fiction. Honestly, I like Tana more than Donna (see what I did there? Donna Tart, if you were wondering).
Three things I didn't like/left me dissatisfied:
1) So does Daniel have a criminal past or not? If so, what? Please don't leave us hanging!
2) Why did the Whitehorn house group assume Lexie would stop trying to sell her share of the house after being stabbed??? What's their logic? Lexie is trying to sell share-->Lexie gets stabbed-->Lexie loses memory of day she was stabbed-->Lexie stops trying to sell share? Was this explained? I don't think it was. Maybe, though. But I don't remember it.
3) I just can't get over the central conceit. I mean, two unrelated women that look so alike that one can TAKE OVER THE OTHER'S LIFE??? I kept picturing a stranger taking my friend's place, and it just never computed. I really can't imagine it. I had to force my disbelief to suspend itself.
IF YOU CLICKED ON THIS REVIEW WITHOUT HAVING READ THE BOOK, BE WARNED: IT SPOILS EVERYTHING. EVERYTHING. DO NOT READ.
This book SERIOUSLY had almost everything I wanted. An undercover op, strange university students with even stranger secrets, Ireland as a Setting, not a setting. In no particularly order, here were the things I liked:
1) Cassie is cool AF. Her infiltration of a group of sinister students is nearly seamless, but it's not just the stuff she does right. She has a flaw--identifying too much with Lexie Madison. She withholds evidence, defies direct orders, and messes with her recording device. The first time she did something like that, I was annoyed. It seemed more like something the author wanted than Cassie. But as the story went on, it became obvious that the flaw was not with Tana French, but with Cassie. She's still awesome, though! Love you!
2) The students she's infiltrating had distinct personalities, and I got to know each of them. From creepy creepy creepy Daniel (blank eyes hidden by glasses are ALWAYS creepy) to adorable (murderous) Justin to suave Rafe to Abby, whom I'd kind of like to be best friends with, each housemate flew off the page.
3) To keep this list short, I'll stick to three things. Off the top of my head, another thing I loved was the Irish history and Whitehorn house. It's really the history and the picture of Ireland that makes this book not just a mystery, but literary fiction. Honestly, I like Tana more than Donna (see what I did there? Donna Tart, if you were wondering).
Three things I didn't like/left me dissatisfied:
1) So does Daniel have a criminal past or not? If so, what? Please don't leave us hanging!
2) Why did the Whitehorn house group assume Lexie would stop trying to sell her share of the house after being stabbed??? What's their logic? Lexie is trying to sell share-->Lexie gets stabbed-->Lexie loses memory of day she was stabbed-->Lexie stops trying to sell share? Was this explained? I don't think it was. Maybe, though. But I don't remember it.
3) I just can't get over the central conceit. I mean, two unrelated women that look so alike that one can TAKE OVER THE OTHER'S LIFE??? I kept picturing a stranger taking my friend's place, and it just never computed. I really can't imagine it. I had to force my disbelief to suspend itself.