You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.13 AVERAGE
3.13 AVERAGE
Interesting 2 stories, bit of a shame one got over confident, and one was too moral. Make those sacrifices...
«Фантастична четвірка: Династія М»:
Ледь дочитав ще один тайін «Фантастична четвірка: Династія М» Джона Леймана та Скота Ітона до події «Династія М», що українською вийшла від видавництва Mal’opus.
Я дійсно не знаю нащо тут в назві «Ф4», бо я б краще назвав «Доктор Дум», за сюжетом він тут головний персонаж, а герої Ф4 залучені, як додаткові, хоч і в незвичному амплуа. Загалом тут розповідаєть про маленьку співпрацю і протистояння Доктора Дума і Маґнето, що мало б теоретично бути цікавим. Але, на жаль, мені таким не виявилося. Тому краще обходити цей тайін. Хоч малюнок був норм, трішки полегшив мої страждання.
«Залізна Людина: Династія М»:
А ось тайін «Залізна Людина: Династія М», яка входить в одну збірку із «Ф4: Династія М» трохи кращий у сюжетному плані.
Цей комікс також розповідає про новий світовий порядок, де мутанти стали на верхівці панування Землею. Одним з найбільших розомів людства все ще є Тоні Старк, але всі події «Династії М» сильно змінили його стосунки зі своїми обладунками, батьком та світом загалом. Він трохи дивитися не в ту сторону, яку б мав, бо все ж таки він людина.
Тут маємо трохи стосунків із батьком, трішки переосмислення ідеалів та бачення ситуації у світі, де панують мутанти. Ґреґ Пак видав навіть досить терпимий сюжет, але через те, що малюнок Пата Лі мені не зайшов, все якось сильно погіршило ситуацію. Не знаю чи вартує звертати вам увагу на цей тайін також.
Ледь дочитав ще один тайін «Фантастична четвірка: Династія М» Джона Леймана та Скота Ітона до події «Династія М», що українською вийшла від видавництва Mal’opus.
Я дійсно не знаю нащо тут в назві «Ф4», бо я б краще назвав «Доктор Дум», за сюжетом він тут головний персонаж, а герої Ф4 залучені, як додаткові, хоч і в незвичному амплуа. Загалом тут розповідаєть про маленьку співпрацю і протистояння Доктора Дума і Маґнето, що мало б теоретично бути цікавим. Але, на жаль, мені таким не виявилося. Тому краще обходити цей тайін. Хоч малюнок був норм, трішки полегшив мої страждання.
«Залізна Людина: Династія М»:
А ось тайін «Залізна Людина: Династія М», яка входить в одну збірку із «Ф4: Династія М» трохи кращий у сюжетному плані.
Цей комікс також розповідає про новий світовий порядок, де мутанти стали на верхівці панування Землею. Одним з найбільших розомів людства все ще є Тоні Старк, але всі події «Династії М» сильно змінили його стосунки зі своїми обладунками, батьком та світом загалом. Він трохи дивитися не в ту сторону, яку б мав, бо все ж таки він людина.
Тут маємо трохи стосунків із батьком, трішки переосмислення ідеалів та бачення ситуації у світі, де панують мутанти. Ґреґ Пак видав навіть досить терпимий сюжет, але через те, що малюнок Пата Лі мені не зайшов, все якось сильно погіршило ситуацію. Не знаю чи вартує звертати вам увагу на цей тайін також.
fast-paced
The first part, the "Fantastic" or rather "Fearsome Four" issues were okay. But the "Iron Man" issues... what the hell was that? I hated the art, the story was a mess and I'm sorry, but Hank Pym may have made some mistakes in his time but having him be a genocidal maniac didn't help. Not good. The worst House of M tie-in yet.
My golden boy, the world is yours.The Fantastic Four part was fun, I like Doom, but the Iron Man part didn't really catch me, neither story-wise, nor art-style-wise. And it didn't necessarily connect much to the main storyline.
4.5 stars!
This is where House of M is getting me more interested again! Though I'm not a Fantastic Four fan, I actually found Lord Doom interesting enough here to like the first half of this volume.
I loved the Iron Man half that followed. I think Tony Stark has a lot of potential as a character that isn't always used well; the guy has a lot of sides to him that are deeper than most Iron Man comics get into. Here, his issues with his father and his alcoholism take center stage, and it pays off.
We also get into some interesting ethics questions about Stark's work that I enjoyed seeing explored. Should he work with government agencies that will inevitably use his technology in violent ways so that he can theoretically be a part of what goes on and control the damage done, or should he risk denying them access to his work and seeing them take it out of his control entirely? Can he fight against mutants that are harming humans while still choosing to save innocent mutant lives? How does public perception of the choices he makes change the dynamic between humans and mutants? I could have read a ten issue volume on what happened during the three issue Iron Man arc here.
If the rest of the series is as thoughtful and character-driven as this one was, I'm in for a treat!
This is where House of M is getting me more interested again! Though I'm not a Fantastic Four fan, I actually found Lord Doom interesting enough here to like the first half of this volume.
I loved the Iron Man half that followed. I think Tony Stark has a lot of potential as a character that isn't always used well; the guy has a lot of sides to him that are deeper than most Iron Man comics get into. Here, his issues with his father and his alcoholism take center stage, and it pays off.
We also get into some interesting ethics questions about Stark's work that I enjoyed seeing explored. Should he work with government agencies that will inevitably use his technology in violent ways so that he can theoretically be a part of what goes on and control the damage done, or should he risk denying them access to his work and seeing them take it out of his control entirely? Can he fight against mutants that are harming humans while still choosing to save innocent mutant lives? How does public perception of the choices he makes change the dynamic between humans and mutants? I could have read a ten issue volume on what happened during the three issue Iron Man arc here.
If the rest of the series is as thoughtful and character-driven as this one was, I'm in for a treat!
Fantastic Four was pretty good. Kind of dark and creepy with the family lovin on Doom. It must be fun to write this alternate universe stuff because they can kill off whoever they want and it doesn't effect the regular continuum.
Iron Man was okay, but I got kind of sick of Howard Stark treating Tony like crap. I felt like It was a little over done. Still not sure why Tony made the decision he did in the end about Magneto.
Iron Man was okay, but I got kind of sick of Howard Stark treating Tony like crap. I felt like It was a little over done. Still not sure why Tony made the decision he did in the end about Magneto.
This book collects two mini-series related to the House of M crossover event - Fantastic Four: House of M 1 - 3 and Iron Man: House of M 1 - 3. The creative team on the Fantastic Four series are all new to me - it was written by John Layman with pencils by Scott Eaton and inks by Don Hillsman. The Iron Man series was written by Greg Pak, whose work I know from the Planet Hulk and World War Hulk books, and the art was by another unknown to me Pat Lee.
For a world that is supposed to give the heroes their dreams come true neither Victor von Doom or Tony Stark are particularly happy with their lot - though this could be seen as some dormant, nagging sense that something is not right. The stories are both fine in themselves without really adding much to the central story.
Pat Lee's art in the Iron Man story is quite strange. There is a lot of it that contains sentinels, armoured humans and other mecha and this is all really good but when it comes to the depiction of the people itjust does not do it for me.
For a world that is supposed to give the heroes their dreams come true neither Victor von Doom or Tony Stark are particularly happy with their lot - though this could be seen as some dormant, nagging sense that something is not right. The stories are both fine in themselves without really adding much to the central story.
Pat Lee's art in the Iron Man story is quite strange. There is a lot of it that contains sentinels, armoured humans and other mecha and this is all really good but when it comes to the depiction of the people itjust does not do it for me.
adventurous
emotional
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes