Aside from the poor writing quality it's hard to take this as a "factual" account, considering that Bathsheba Sherman never lived in this house, never went on trial for allegedly killing a baby and did not commit suicide. It also seems strange that according to this book before Bathsheba was blamed for this alleged haunting that the family had a dog named Bathsheba who was hit by a car and then shot by police, and that Carolyn was supposedly accused of being a witch by their neighbor. It seems like the family was already very troubled before they ever moved to the allegedly haunted house since according to this account their cat had been "brutalized" at their previous home and their kitten murdered by a neighbor, their home broken into etc. I love a good ghost story but this isn't one. There is too much presented as "fact" when evidence shows otherwise. Why would a ghost haunt a house that had nothing to do with her in life.
marinazala's profile picture

marinazala's review

1.0

even it's based on true story from the conjuring. the storyline is very boring.. too many details and repetition..