Reviews with content warning for Transphobia - Breasts and Eggs

A wonderful and important book. I love how the author described colors, feelings, and people. I’m also surprised at the emotions it got out of me. Truly a lovely piece of writing, even if some parts of it drag a bit.

Content Warnings

loveryoushouldvecomeovermp3's review against another edition

Go to review page

reflective slow-paced

3.75

one thing I've noticed a lot in books about women is how much the author needs to stress the womans attractiveness. even when it's a book written by a woman, for women. even when it's explicitly about the suffering of women, the author needs you to know that yes she is beautiful. maybe she doesn't notice it because shes so entrenched in her sadness but she is beautiful and she is attractive. her sadness comes from within not from her outsides. it's something I've noticed especially with modern female authors, those who are hailed by booktok as 'sad girl literature'. Which is why i appreciate that natsuko is never subjected to that. she describes her body multiple times but the gaze feels different, noticeably so. i also loved that this book has mainly female characters who have meaningful discussions, who hurt and help each other. but in general i felt the book was a bit meandering. it's a good book, for sure, ive annotated it to death, but sometimes it feels so lost in the narrative of 'womanhood is suffering'. like every page, every monologue continues to drive in that idea, it's very repetitive. midoriko's diary entries especially. all her entries revolve around periods and the female body. it felt like the author saw the entries as an easy way to drive in the point of the book. even with this i did that it had very good prose, and i do think it touched on some important topics. we definitely do need books about the lives of women and i did tear up multiple times. i just feel this book was almost there, just a little less monologues. a little more show dont tell.

Content Warnings

maritzelle's review against another edition

Go to review page

reflective medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

Puede que sea la única que lo piense pero yo no lo entendí como un libro o historia feminista. Pienso que habla sobre la soledad, la identidad, la búsqueda de un objetivo. Pero para nada lo recomiendo como feminista. La escritura me gustó, pero le faltó conexión. Me lo vendieron como historia de dos hermanas, casi ni hay interacción entre ellas. Me dijeron que es feminista, pero siento que mas bien está enfocado en la maternidad. Y esas dos cosas no son exclusivas pero siento que lo describían como algo que no es. También hubo comentarios transfobicos, el tono es depresivo, y es muy difícil de empatizar con los personajes.

Content Warnings